Andy Maciver

Why Andy Burnham’s best bet is an election right now

'Mr Burnham’s supporters are attempting to portray the speech as one of history’s greatest orations by one of history’s great orators. It wasn’t and he isn’t' <i>(Image: Stefan Rousseau)</i>
'Mr Burnham’s supporters are attempting to portray the speech as one of history’s greatest orations by one of history’s great orators. It wasn’t and he isn’t' (Image: Stefan Rousseau)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

It was okay, I thought, Andy Burnham's speech to the Labour Party conference in Liverpool earlier this week. It was fine.

The giddy excitement with which Labour members, and it must be said several sections of the national press, have greeted Mr Burnham’s effort is probably an indication of how low the bar set by Sir Keir Starmer really was.

Mr Burnham’s supporters are attempting to portray the speech as one of history’s greatest orations by one of history’s great orators. It wasn’t and he isn’t. It was okay. But it was not Gettysburg. And he’s not Lincoln.

It was a braver speech, though, than anyone else in British politics today would have given. It indicated that he would follow through on his long-held belief that the first-past-the-post electoral system should be scrapped and replaced with something more proportional. This is the system which returned Labour MPs to two-thirds of Westminster’s seats based on only one-third of the votes, and without it hundreds of the parliamentarians in the hall would be working as press officers for a trade union. Asking turkeys to vote for Christmas and having them cheer you out of the building is quite a feat, and an indication of his undeniable strength.

It also indicated an ultimate desire not just to creep closer to the European Union, but even perhaps to rejoin it. Again, there were dozens of cheering backbenchers who could lose their seats as a result of this policy.


Read more:


Brave as those two sections of the speech were, and popular as they will be with sections of the electorate, we should all raise a toast to Mr Burnham for being the leader who, finally, pledged to scrap the pensions triple lock. The unwillingness of previous Prime Ministers and opposition leaders to tackle this most obvious of problems has been one of the more dispiriting aspects of the last decade of politics. The triple lock is one of Britain’s most iniquitous policies. A generation of workers, who will never be as wealthy as their parents, is paying for a level of pension protection which they themselves have absolutely zero chance of ever obtaining. In the grand scheme of things, Mr Burnham’s abandonment of one of the three locks (the earnings link) is hardly radical, leaving us still with a double lock which remains generous to pensioners and ungenerous to their children. It is, however, a start, and for that he should be congratulated.

And we do need to start. Britain today spends more than half of its entire national expenditure on welfare benefits and healthcare. Another 10 or so per cent disappears in interest payments on our £3 trillion national debt. If the welfare and healthcare bill continues to grow at the rate it has over the last 10 years, by 2050 welfare and healthcare will consume something around two-thirds of the pie. To give this some context, this is an amount of money which would wipe out almost all current expenditure on both education and defence.

It is only when you look closely and analytically at Britain’s balance sheet that you realise just what a fix Mr Burnham is in. Our real triple lock is found here. First, we have ballooning welfare and healthcare expenditure. Second, we have increasing interest on our growing debt. Third, we have a stagnant economy, projected to grow at no more than 1.6 per cent before 2030.

Mr Burnham’s pensions policy is projected to save something around £20 billion by 2040. The welfare budget right now is £400 billion. Context is everything.

And it is in that context that the most interesting and, perhaps, consequential question in British politics today is whether or not Mr Burnham will call an early general election. Speculation was supercharged by the fact that the Prime Minister had just made a speech about all the tremendous things he would do when he was given his own mandate by the people, whilst simultaneously denying that he would seek such a mandate before 2029.

The smart money is on him holding off, as he and his aides say he will. He is nothing if not full of self-belief that he can turn this supertanker around, convince 40 per cent of the electorate to back him at a 2029 election and win a mandate for his platform. Furthermore, in any case, here is a man who has been desperate to be Prime Minister for most of his adult life. Why on earth would he put the keys to Downing Street in a bowl on the table having just been handed them?

For my money, though, we are at peak Burnham right now, today. His good vibes have been sufficient to register a polling bounce in the high single digits. He has neutered Zack Polanski and the Greens by moving against Israel. He has damaged Nigel Farage up north and, together with Rupert Lowe, multiple scandals and the spectre of Mr Farage being Prime Minister, Reform has gone from regularly polling 30-plus per cent to regularly polling 20-plus per cent. Kemi Badenoch’s popularity is mushrooming, but there is no evidence that those who are warming to her are anything but decidedly cool towards her party; the memories are too fresh.

'For my money, though, we are at peak Burnham right now, today. His good vibes have been sufficient to register a polling bounce in the high single digits' (Image: Peter Byrne)

Mr Burnham is unlikely to be able to win a majority now but, on a good night, he might win 300 seats and be in a position where he can give Sir Ed Davey a call and ask him to be Secretary of State for the European Union or, if he prefers, Secretary of State for Electoral Reform.

This is not a great outcome for a man with a massive majority, but all rational analysis would suggest that it may be the best of two bad options, with the other being losing power completely at a poll in 2029.

I cannot help but wonder whether this is where Britain is heading. It is easy to hyperbolically compare Britain today with Britain in the 1970s. It isn’t that bad, of course, but there are plenty of signs that it may become so. Mr Burnham’s policy platform might look sensible today but, as his sometime informal adviser, and former Bank of England chief economist, Andy Haldane said, this ultimately looks like a traditional Labour tax-and-spend government with better TikTok videos.

That only ends one way. The 1970s ended in 1979, literally, metaphorically and politically. This is where we are going. If Mr Burnham wants a few more years in Downing Street while we get there, his best bet is to ask the people for permission as soon as humanly possible.


Andy Maciver is founding director of Message Matters and co-host of the Holyrood Sources podcast.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos