Glasgow warns UK asylum reforms will not ease crisis

Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood on the latest edition of Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg on BBC1 <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood on the latest edition of Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg on BBC1 (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The leader of Scotland’s largest council has warned that the UK Government’s new immigration plan will have little impact on Glasgow’s escalating asylum crisis.

The reforms, described as the “most sweeping” in modern times by Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood, would reshape how the UK treats refugees.

People will be given shorter, temporary permission to stay, and it will be far harder for them to settle permanently. The Labour Government also plans to make it easier to remove people from the country if their asylum claims fail.

Setting out the 84-page blueprint, Restoring Order and Control, Ms Mahmood told MPs the current asylum system “feels out of control and unfair”.

“It feels that way because it is,” she said. “The pace and scale of change has destabilised communities, it is making our country a more divided place.

“There will never be a justification for the violence and racism of a minority, but if we fail to deal with this crisis, we will draw more people down a path that starts with anger and ends in hatred.

“I have no doubt about who we really are in this country.

“We are open, tolerant and generous, but the public rightly expects that we can determine who enters this country and who must leave.”

The plan argues that the UK’s existing system is “more permissive than the European mainstream” and has become a “pull factor” drawing people to Britain.

Ms Mahmood told MPs: “It starts by accepting an uncomfortable truth. While asylum claims fall across Europe, they are rising here, and that is because of the comparative generosity of our asylum offer, when compared to so many of our European neighbours.”

Refugees who are granted leave will no longer receive five years’ protection with a route to settlement.

Instead, they will be placed on a new Core Protection track, receiving 30 months’ leave at a time. Permanent settlement will only be possible after 20 years and subject to new requirements still to be consulted on.

Automatic family reunion will also end. Refugees will only be able to bring relatives to the UK after moving into a new “protection work and study” route.

To do this, ministers plan to redefine Article 8 rights to family and private life.

Ms Mahmood told MPs: “Firstly, we will define what exactly a ‘family’ is, narrowing this down to parents and their children. Secondly, we will define the public interest test, so the default becomes a removal or refusal, with Article 8 rights permissible only in the most exceptional circumstances.”

She also confirmed asylum seekers will have “just one opportunity” to claim and one to appeal, saying this would end “the merry-go-round of claims and appeals that frustrate so many removals”.

The Government will also restart removals to countries where returns were previously paused, including Syria. Countries deemed uncooperative in taking back their nationals will face new visa sanctions.

Alongside the tougher approach to enforcement, Ms Mahmood insisted the UK would maintain safe and legal routes. “I know the British people do not want to close the doors.”

She promised that the Government would open new, capped schemes once “order and control is restored”.

She said these routes would make “sponsorship the primary means by which we resettle refugees”.

The new plan comes as Glasgow faces a fast-deepening refugee homelessness emergency. Council figures show households granted protection now account for 44% of all homelessness applications. The authority spent £27 million on refugee-related homelessness in 2024/25, with forecasts warning costs could reach £66 million within two years unless UK policy changes.

The crisis is being driven by the interaction of UK asylum rules with Scotland’s broader homelessness rights. Once refugees receive leave to remain, Home Office support ends and they must leave asylum accommodation within a fixed period. In England, councils only have a duty to house those in “priority need”. In Scotland, the safety net is far wider.

Susan Aitken, the SNP leader of Glasgow City Council, told The Herald: “Glasgow’s issue really is not the number of people seeking asylum, or how they reached this country. It is the alarming speed at which the Home Office has begun to force refugees given leave to remain into homelessness.

“The obsession with the small number of people who may be deported, at the expense of adequately supporting those that we agree do need this country’s help, has piled unsustainable pressure on cities up and down the UK.

“It is very hard to see how this plan will have any kind of positive impact on that crisis.”

Susan Aitken hit out at the plans (Image: Supplied)

Much of the package was briefed to media over the weekend, prompting a rebuke from the Deputy Speaker.

The Home Secretary and the Prime Minister also faced fierce opposition from some of their backbenchers. There was even speculation one minister could be set to resign.

One of the biggest clashes will be over measures to require asylum seekers with “assets” to use them to contribute towards the costs of their state support.

The plans are modelled on the system in Denmark, where a “jewellery law” requires asylum seekers to use assets towards their accommodation costs.

The Lib Dems accused ministers of plotting to snatch “heirlooms” from vulnerable people, but the Government insisted it was more about cars and e-bikes.

Sarah Owen, the Labour MP for Luton North, asked the minister what evidence she had "that taking personal belongings, such as jewellery from refugees and selling it off, actually works as a deterrent?”

The Home Secretary replied: “We are not taking jewellery at the border. I can’t say it any more clearly than that. She will know that the example I have used in my speech, the sort of case we’re going after, is those who have assets, those who have access to money and who can afford quite expensive cars, who should make a contribution to the cost of what is currently free asylum support.

“These two things are not the same, and I would urge her not to conflate the two. We will not – and never will – seize people’s jewellery at the border.

“We’re not going after their sentimental items like wedding rings and so on.”

The Scottish Greens described the Home Secretary’s speech in the Commons as “one of the vilest and most contemptible speeches ever given by a mainstream politician”.

MSP Maggie Chapman said: “It is reminiscent of Enoch Powell’s Rivers of Blood speech of nearly 50 years ago. Labour has not just lost its moral compass, it has smashed it to pieces.”

In the Commons, Liberal Democrats home affairs spokesman Max Wilkinson criticised the minister: “What is not helpful is the Home Secretary claiming that the country is being torn apart by immigration. Acknowledging the challenges facing our nation is one thing, but stoking division by using immoderate language is quite another.”

Responding, Ms Mahmood said: “I wish I had the privilege of walking around this country and not seeing the division that the issue of migration and asylum system is creating across this country.

"Unlike him, unfortunately, I am the one that is regularly called a f***ing P**i and told to go back home. It is I who knows, through my personal experience and that of my constituents, just how divisive the issue of asylum has become in our country.”

“This system is broken, and it is incumbent on all Members of Parliament to acknowledge how badly broken the system is and to make it a moral mission to fix this system so that it stops creating the division that we all see,” she added.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos