Scottish Labour and the SNP have clashed on immigration after a Home Office minister categorically ruled out even discussing devolving powers over migration or introducing a Scottish visa scheme.
The Nationalists said the snub was “utterly humiliating” for Anas Sarwar, as calls for a bespoke arrangement on visas were a central plank of a landmark report commissioned by the party leader.
But Labour said the attack was “embarrassing and hypocritical” given the SNP’s attempts to push a Bill calling for the devolution of immigration through Westminster while the Scottish Government opposed the power coming to Edinburgh.
While immigration is wholly reserved to Westminster, it is likely to feature heavily in May’s Holyrood election, given the impact of UK Government changes to social care and universities due to come into force in April, and the rise of Nigel Farage’s Reform UK.
Read more
- Labour could still table motion of no confidence in Angela Constance says Sarwar
- ‘Idiotic’: Anas Sarwar snaps as Labour’s Scottish briefing war explodes
- For pity's sake, won't you grow a spine, Prime Minister?
In 2024, net migration — the difference between those arriving in Scotland and those leaving — was 56,400.
A major driver of recent immigration has been international students and their families.
Student numbers from outside the UK hit a record high in 2022–23, with growth concentrated among non-EU nationals following post-Brexit visa changes.
Alongside students, people arrive on work visas to fill skills shortages, particularly in health, social care and agriculture.
According to the 2022 census, 12% of workers in human health and social work activities in Scotland were born outside the UK.
Last year, the UK Government published a new White Paper setting out a number of reforms to the immigration system, including plans to reduce net migration by making it harder to move to and settle in the UK.
Point of view old sick woman in wheelchair in the middle of domestic room alone
The changes are designed to reduce UK-wide net migration by around 100,000 a year. If Scotland experiences a proportional share of that reduction, net migration to Scotland could fall by roughly 5,700 people annually.
Key proposals include tightening eligibility for Skilled Worker visas by removing most medium-skilled roles, ending overseas recruitment for social care workers, raising English language requirements, shortening Graduate visas, increasing charges on employers and universities, and expanding some routes for highly skilled migrants.
The most far-reaching proposals relate to settlement. The Government plans to move from a standard five-year route to indefinite leave to remain to a more complex system with a ten-year “baseline”.
Higher earners, healthcare and teaching staff, and family visa holders could still qualify after five years, while others would face much longer waits.
The Home Office intends to apply the new rules to most migrants already in the UK from April 2026 — just weeks before voters in Scotland go to the polls.
The paper on regional economic development by Professor Sir Anton Muscatelli, published in November and commissioned by Scottish Labour, argues that Scotland’s ability to grow its economy is being held back by a lack of access to skilled labour, particularly in research, innovation and high-growth sectors.
While stopping short of proposing a fully devolved Scottish visa, the academic said the Scottish Government and UK Government must “collaborate on exemptions and incentives to help alleviate the core challenges associated with recruiting and retaining talent in Scotland”.
Labour said Anton Muscatelli's report was independent
In the weeks following the report, the SNP’s Graham Leadbitter tabled a written question in Parliament asking the Home Office if it had “received representations from Anas Sarwar MSP on the potential merits of introducing a Scottish visa since 4 July 2024”.
Migration Minister Mike Tapp replied: “We have no plans to devolve immigration policy, introduce a Scottish visa scheme, nor to discuss such ideas further.
“Previously suggested schemes would restrict movement and rights and create internal UK borders. Adding different rules for different locations would introduce complexity and create frictions when workers move locations.”
Mr Leadbitter said: “Anas Sarwar has been utterly humiliated by his London Labour bosses, who will not even talk to him.
“Anas Sarwar commissioned a report which explicitly recommended a Scottish visa and it has been slapped down by Labour high command in London without even a shrug of the shoulders. Not only has the Home Office ruled out the plan, it has blocked any discussion with Anas Sarwar on the matter. It is nothing other than completely mortifying for Scottish Labour.
“The SNP has long backed a Scottish visa and has led the charge with a Bill in Parliament, but every step of the way the Labour Party has blocked it, including Labour MPs from Scotland who followed orders and voted the Bill down.”
In response, Labour pointed to a Private Member’s Bill tabled by SNP MP Stephen Gethins which seeks to amend the Scotland Act to give the Scottish Parliament legislative competence over immigration matters.
However, Scottish Government internal briefing papers on immigration and migration policy, prepared mainly in response to the UK Government’s Immigration White Paper, released through Freedom of Information, state that the “policy position is not to seek devolution of immigration powers”.
A Scottish Labour spokesperson said: “This is an embarrassing and hypocritical attack from the SNP, and journalists should be more credulous about the SNP’s nonsense.
They added: “The only person who has been humiliated on this issue recently is SNP MP Stephen Gethins, whose proposals for a devolved immigration system were opposed by the SNP government.
“Scottish Labour has consistently called for a migration and skills system that works for every part of the UK and meets Scotland’s needs.
“While the SNP desperately tries to deflect attention from its own woeful record in government, Scottish Labour is focused on fixing Scotland’s broken public services.”
Read more
- Holyrood campaign begins as party leaders set out election pitch
- Holyrood election campaign is underway. But which leader survives the chaos?
- Sarwar refuses to back peerage for Starmer aide who campaigned for Scots sex offender
In his report, Prof Muscatelli pointed to Scotland’s ageing population, low levels of population growth and persistent skills shortages as structural weaknesses that make access to global talent particularly important.
Without intervention, he said, these trends will pose long-term risks to Scotland’s public finances.
Recent analysis by the Fraser of Allander Institute warned that the UK Government’s immigration reforms could have a disproportionate impact on Scotland.
The research said the restrictions on Skilled Worker visas and an end to overseas recruitment for social care workers could exacerbate labour shortages, particularly in health and social care.
Universities were also potentially vulnerable. More than half of postgraduate students at Scottish universities now come from overseas, a higher proportion than across the UK as a whole.
The institute said immigration plays a key role in supporting Scotland’s working-age population and tax base.
“Migrants are, on average, younger and more likely to be of working age,” it said. “Evidence suggests that overall they contribute more in taxes than they receive in public spending, especially before settlement.”
While the reforms will not generate additional funding for the Scottish Government, the briefing warned they could place further strain on devolved services already facing workforce shortages.
Share