Gordon Brown ‘private gain’ warning after Anas Sarwar peerage

 <i>(Image: Getty Images)</i>
(Image: Getty Images)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Gordon Brown has said public office should never become a “platform for private gain” after former Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar accepted a peerage to join Andy Burnham’s government.

The former prime minister said he was “not much in favour of taking honours” as he explained his own decision to reject titles during an event at the University of Glasgow promoting his new book, The Future Starts With Us.

Mr Brown did not refer directly to Mr Sarwar during his answer, but said those entering politics should do so to advance the public good and should continue in public service after leaving office.

It comes as the former Scottish Labour leader officially joined the Lords on August 24 as Lord Sarwar after his peerage was announced on July 22.


READ MORE:


The former PM has long opposed the House of Lords in its current form, and in 2022 chaired a Labour commission which recommended replacing it with an elected chamber representing the nations and regions of the UK.

Asked by an audience member in Glasgow what had influenced his decision to reject an honour, he said: “I think if you go into politics particularly, you can’t go in for any other reason than that you want to advance the good of the public.

“And I think, once you leave politics, you’ve got to try and do your best to keep your public service up in some way or another.

“So I’ve never believed that public office should be the platform for private gain, and I certainly don’t feel that you deserve any honour for what you’ve done.”

Former prime minister Gordon Brown speaks at the University of Glasgow during an event promoting his new book, The Future Starts With Us. (Image: Newsquest)

Mr Brown, who served as prime minister from 2007 to 2010 after a decade as chancellor, said the greatest honour he had received was being elected by the people he represented.

He also called for devolution to go further than transferring power to councils, arguing that communities themselves should be given greater control over local services and public money.

“There’s a lot of talk about devolution, which is devolution down to the local authority,” he said.

“But perhaps we should be talking about devolution down to the local community and empowering local communities to make their own decisions about local services, to make decisions about the allocation of funds.”

Mr Brown suggested governments could establish a capital fund to help people create community organisations and provide more support for training local leaders.

During recent interviews surrounding his book, Mr Brown has turned his attention to the future of the UK. He has said Scotland’s current constitutional settlement is “not satisfactory” while maintaining that independence is not the answer, and has said he believes that, in the long term, Ireland will be united.

His appearance in Glasgow was accompanied by a pro-Palestinian protest outside the venue, with protesters chanting “Gordon Brown, shame on you” and saying the former prime minister was “not welcome here”.

A protester from the Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign told The Herald the demonstration centred on what they described as Mr Brown’s association with the Jewish National Fund, while also criticising his record on the Middle East.

Scottish Labour MSP Paul Sweeney told The Herald afterwards that he had enjoyed the part of Mr Brown’s speech he was able to hear, but said he had missed some of the event because he had been unable to get inside while protesters were blocking the entrance.

Mr Brown acknowledged the demonstration in his opening remarks, telling the audience that Glasgow students had always been “very independent-minded”.

Much of the evening focused on the central argument of Mr Brown’s new book: that the erosion of community life at home is connected to the breakdown of international co-operation and the rise of populist politics.

He also warned that the “public square is dying”, pointing to declining membership of political parties, trade unions, churches, clubs and other civic organisations.

Mr Brown argued that political parties had increasingly become election machines run from the centre rather than organisations rooted in their local communities, creating a vacuum which populist movements had been able to exploit.

Asked about Prime Minister Andy Burnham, Mr Brown said he believed the Labour leader was reflecting a public desire for greater optimism after years of economic and political disappointment.

“I do think he is reflecting the mood of the country that yes, things are difficult, but we’ve got to actually be more optimistic about the future,” he said.

The former chancellor also urged the Government to put a greater emphasis on innovation to boost economic growth, arguing Britain was good at creating start-up companies but “pretty poor at scale-ups”.

He said the UK had world-leading universities and strengths in medicine, technology and the creative industries but too often failed to turn discoveries into successful British companies and jobs.

“My focus would be on us as the innovation nation,” he said.

Mr Brown also repeated his warnings about the increasingly unstable international order, arguing the world was moving away from rules and towards the exercise of raw power by leaders including Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump.

Recalling meetings with the Russian president while he was in office, Mr Brown said Mr Putin’s approach was based on intimidation.

“It’s all threats,” he said, adding that the Russian leader understood strength and would seek to exploit any weakness.

He also renewed his criticism of Mr Trump, pointing to what he described as arbitrary decisions by the US president as evidence of a wider shift from a “rules-based order” to a “power-based order”.

Mr Brown said the world was now in a “dangerous” period, citing Russia’s war in Ukraine and threats against Britain, but insisted there remained public support internationally for countries working together rather than adopting nationalist “country first” policies.

The Glasgow appearance formed part of Mr Brown’s promotional tour for The Future Starts With Us, in which he argues that stronger communities can provide an answer to political alienation, nationalism and the weakening of international institutions.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos