Earlier this week it was announced that Dumbarton Football Club are set to be taken out of administration.
The League One side were plunged into football's favourite mode of existential crisis four months ago by the club's board over a lack of solvency amid internal squabbles with the majority shareholders. It was claimed an overdue payment of £300,000 on a land deal worth £1.8 million was responsible. The owners, Cognitive, claimed the payment was due only on the successful progression of the housing project, which as yet doesn't appear to have gone any further than initial planning, and took out legal action against the club for the decision to put them into administration. They also blamed the financial troubles on the board failing to budget properly.
As a recently promoted side through the League One play-offs and already finding life difficult in the second tier, this immediately sealed Dumbarton's fate in a footballing sense and they've spent the rest of the campaign rooted to the table. Though the majority of the playing squad remained, the mental blow from losing 15 points was seemingly too much to overcome. They also had injury problems to contend with as star player and top goalscorer from the prior season, Michael Ruth, spent a chunk of time on the sidelines, while a long-term injury to goalkeeper Brett Long further hampered a struggling defensive unit that kept only two clean sheets (one of them against Berwick Rangers in the Challenge Cup) until late March.
Fans were asked to raise money just to keep the club afloat until the end of the season and managed to surpass a six-figure amount. Considering the size of Dumbarton, both the team and town, that's an incredible achievement and they should be thoroughly proud of their efforts. It is especially impressive considering the miserable run the team were enduring on the park during that period. Between January 4th and March 22nd, when their relegation back to League Two was confirmed, they played 12 games, picked up just three points, exited the Scottish Cup and didn't win a single game, losing nine of them.
There was eventual reward in the form of back-to-back wins over Alloa Athletic and Kelty Hearts, the latter of which a stunning 6-0 victory which saw the end of Charlie Mulgrew as Kelty boss, but all of this paled in comparison to the most important thing: survival.
When news of the impending exit from administration hit social media, there were two types of reaction. There was the tediously typical need from so many to make this all about the Old Firm, like they do with everything. So yes, 'Rangers died but Dumbarton survived' appeared in various forms. Otherwise, it was all very positive. Folk rejoiced over the fact another one of Scottish football's oldest clubs – indeed, joint-champions of the first ever Scottish league season – would be spared from financial ruin. Unfortunately, Dumbarton fans weren't in the mood to join them in their celebrations.
It was revealed that the deal which administrators Quantuma agreed to was with Pendragon Group Limited, owned by Oxford-based businessman Gareth Phillips. The administrators had previously been in litigation against Pendragon as it was through them that Cognitive got the money in which to buy the land, which sits adjacent to the club's home stadium, as they sought to reclaim the funds reportedly owed to Dumbarton. It has since been stated by the Sons Supporters' Trust that Phillips now controls 80 per cent of shares in Cognitive. So, essentially, as it appears to fans, the club is being sold to the man they were at odds with this entire time.
Phillips has satisfied Quantuma that not only will he wipe the debt – which is the key reason for the administrators taking this deal as it is the best one for the creditors – but there is also a business plan and funding in place for the next three years. However, what happens after that and in the time between remains a mystery.
The fanbase had been hoping that if they were able to endure the pain of administration and ultimately survive then the trade-off would be that The Rock (the widely-used nickname for the Marbill Coaches Stadium due to its location beside Dumbarton Rock) and the club would finally be safe from property investors who, they believed, didn't have the same interests at heart.
They've certainly been put through the ringer over the last 20 years as owners have sought – and failed – to use the land beside the stadium to make a quick buck. There have been galaxy-brained fundraising efforts from the likes of Henning Kristoffersen, who fronted Cognitive, including selling off bits of stone that had fallen from the Rock and making trainers for wholesale with the DFC logo stitched into them.
Bringing further concern was the discovery that a clause in the local development plan (LDP), which stated that housing could only be constructed at the Rock if a new stadium was built elsewhere in Dumbarton, has mysteriously disappeared in the latest LDP refreshment. Local councillors are currently said to be looking into why it vanished in the first place and whether it can be put back in.
Phillips, for his part, has distanced himself from the former ownership and, through a representative of the Sons Trust, says that he decided to take over both the club and Cognitive to try and recoup the money which hasn't been repaid to him. He admits he's not in it for the long term, but reckons he can get the majority of his money back through the club and developing the land, as reported in Herald Sport yesterday. However, the fact that he apparently didn't know that the land didn't include planning permission already sets off alarm bells. And, while this is certainly not personal to Phillips and, who knows, maybe he can make a success of this, there have been too many snake-oil salesmen coming into Scottish football and leaving clubs either homeless or potless that it's very difficult not to be cynical.
Dumbarton fans, to their credit, don't seem to be buying it. They've been sold this story too many times before. A colleague of mine and passionate Dumbarton supporter has had to live with the uncertainty his entire footballing life. He, and the rest of them, are sick of it. They feel they are stuck in the same old story, just when they thought they were going to get out of it.
Dumbarton have managed to escape the worst thing happening to them, but as one supporter on Pie & Bovril put it, this is the second worst outcome that could have happened.
Share