There are many things for which to admire Laura Muir.
Her cabinet-full of major championships medals, including Olympic silver, is one. Qualifying as a vet while, at the same time, competing as a world-class athlete is another.
But perhaps Muir’s most significant moment not only in her athletics career, but her life, came this week.
Muir has waived her right to anonymity regarding a case involving her former coach, who has been banned from athletics for serious misconduct.
For several years, the case against Andy Young has been ongoing.
In August 2023, 39 charges of misconduct were brought against Young and in September 2024, his hearing took place.
Following an appeal by Young, the final outcome was, finally, announced this week, with it revealing that the 48-year-old had been found guilty of 9 of the 39 charges, 7 of which were ruled to be serious.
Young was found guilty of manipulative behaviour, as well as ignoring athlete welfare and medical advice and some of the specific examples of his misconduct are truly distressing.
One incident highlighted in the findings detailed when Young, "following a disagreement, drove at speed with an athlete in his car before abandoning them at the roadside, disregarding their safety and wellbeing".
Other examples included "requiring an athlete to compete against the clear advice of a physiotherapist, threatening to exclude athletes from training or races if they did not comply with his demands, and emotionally undermining those who raised concerns about injuries”.
Young was banned from coaching for five years, backdated to April 2023 but on appeal, his suspension was reduced to three years.
Laura Muir (l) and Jemma Reekie (r) were Andy Young's highest-profile athletes(Image: Corbis via Getty Images)
On finding out quite how abominably Young has behaved, it’s hard to reconcile this with the fact he was, on paper, a hugely successful coach.
His highest-profile athletes were Muir and Olympic finalist, Jemma Reekie, but Young’s training group also included a raft of other exceptional athletes including GB internationalists, Erin Wallace and Eloise Walker.
In Muir and Reekie’s cases, it’s no secret that their partnership with Young came to an acrimonious, and abrupt, end.
Young had developed both women from young athletes with a load of potential into truly world-class runners. But, in March 2023, whilst training in South Africa, the pair quit their camp early and flew home before announcing they had split from Young with immediate effect.
At the time, the news was shocking, particularly the suddenness of the split, but only mildly surprising given the reputation Young had developed within the sport of not being the most likeable individual.
There’s a world of difference, though, between being unlikeable and being found guilty of the charges of which Young has.
Muir, who was coached by Young to Olympic silver in 2021, World bronze in 2022, European golds in 2018 and 2022 plus a host of other major medals, has, clearly, played a significant role in this case, with her decision to waive her anonymity especially significant. Muir is a highly intelligent individual and she’ll be well aware that putting her name to this case adds significant weight.
As Young’s ban was made public, Muir released a statement saying: "I have chosen to waive my anonymity and confirm my involvement in this case. I fully support the decisions reached by both independent panels and I am grateful that the process has been followed through so thoroughly.
"I want to thank those who came forward and those who contributed to the process - it has not been easy, but it was necessary.” She then went onto say she’s now found a “supportive and positive coaching environment” and is looking forward to “putting this difficult chapter firmly behind me.”
This case highlights several things that should be of pressing concern.
Laura Muir has waived her anonymity in the Andy Young case(Image: Supplied)
Firstly, is the power that coaches, and especially successful coaches, yield.
Coaches, or should I say, bad coaches, can often become somewhat drunk on power. Producing a successful athlete is, primarily, down to the athlete themselves but I, and most elite athletes, will have seen coaches who believe their role is the most important factor in any athletes’ success. Which often, then, leads said coach to believe that they know best, whatever the situation, and they must be obeyed.
Whether this was the case with Young, or whether he had always had an abusive streak within him, we’ll probably never definitively know.
But there’s little doubt that the more successful a coach, the harder it is to speak out against them and their practices. Young, don’t forget, was, at one point in his career, being lauded as one of the best athletics coaches in the world and was being showered with awards. He was named Coach of the Year by both Sportscotland and scottishathletics at the height of his success.
What is also extremely concerning about this case is the length of Young’s suspension.
He will, having had his ban reduced from five years to three, be free to coach again in April. That’s in just six months’ time.
Given the severity of the charges Young has been found guilty of, it feels unthinkable that he could be back in the coaching arena quite so soon, although for him to return as a coach, the report has stated he must undertake rehabilitation and pass training courses. Ideally, athletes will stay well clear of Young when his ban is lifted. But sport is a strange profession and Young wouldn’t be the first individual with a stain on his character to re-enter the arena.
This case is a timely reminder that while success in the sporting arena is nice, it can’t be allowed to come at any cost.
Jemma Reekie was coached by Andy Young for several years(Image: Sports Press Photo via Reuters Connect via Beat Media Group subscription)
We’ll perhaps never truly know the damage Young’s behaviour has done to those who were subject to it. Little can be done about what’s happened in the past, but what could have been done is ensure there’s no chance of it happening again. But allowing Young back into sport quite so quickly means there will, very soon, be an individual who has behaved entirely inappropriately potentially returning to athletics, despite the fact the investigation panel stated: “He (Young) is… unlikely to accept responsibility for his conduct going forward and so there seems little prospect that he is likely to act differently in the future.”
I can’t be the only person who’s extremely uncomfortable with having someone who’s described in this way back in sport?
Ultimately, the hope has to be that some good comes of this case. It’s a reminder that producing successful athletes and being a good coach can be two very different things.
And it’s a reminder that, as Muir has done, speaking out can be even more important than winning medals.
Share