Reason VAR hesitated over Scotland vs Morocco penalty

Scott McTominay thought he should have had a penalty against Morocco <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Scott McTominay thought he should have had a penalty against Morocco (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Referee expert Christina Unkel believes VAR official Armando Villarreal may have hesitated in recommending a penalty review for Scotland after a rejected review in an earlier World Cup match.

The American official was on VAR duty for the match between France and Senegal, where he recommended a penalty for a tackle on Kylian Mbappe.

However, referee Alireza Faghani chose not to award a penalty, claiming Mbappe had initiated contact as he awarded a goal kick instead.

The decision was labelled as "rubbish" and "utter nonsense" by former Scotland player Pat Nevin, who was baffled by the referee's call to reject the opinion of the VAR official who had called him to the pitchside monitor to review the incident.

Villarreal did not intervene during Scotland vs Morocco despite huge appeals for a penalty when Scott McTominay looked to be fouled in the box by Neil El Aynaoui.

According to expert Unkel, speaking on ITV, it was a "very clear penalty".

But she admitted the VAR official may have hesitated to intervene due to the recent VAR furore in the previous match and referee Ilgiz Tantashev allowing a hugely physical contest.


Read more:


Unkel said: "There are two angles from behind, one on the lower back and one on the high.

"Even that reverse camera angle shows you the amount of contact you see.

"I still think it is penalty kick.

"And I understand that the referee is known for having more of a higher level of physical contact needed.

"But you don't need a lot for this to be a penalty.

"We are not giving a penalty for the severity of the challenge, we are giving a penalty more for the technical elements of it.

"It's a simple foul. There is contact at the knee, and then there is another angle where one could argue there is a step a bit on that left boot.

"Once you get those two, let alone just that minimal one on the knee, that for me is what I've seen given multiple times as a penalty decision.

"It's also not lost on me that the VAR in this match was the one who recommended the penalty in the France-Senegal game, there might have been a little bit of hesitation from him, too.

"When you have a referee who is not giving a lot of fouls, that some would call simple fouls, I could see the hesitation from the VAR.

"But I do think it's still a penalty."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos