Here we are again, then. Back in a scenario where Scottish football clubs prioritise number one ahead of the greater good and self interest wins the day.
The facts and figures show that young Scottish players don’t see enough first team minutes in the SPFL. Most accept that something needs to be done about that or the supply of talent to the national team will choke and the coefficient will plunge faster than AI stock values.
The collapse of Scotland’s national team in Switzerland suggests the process is already well underway. The average age of the starting eleven was 27.9 years, with four players aged 30 or over. At 22 Luke Graham was the only player under 24. Calls to throw in the kids and start again ignore an inconvenient truth. Take Lennon Miller, James Wilson and Tyler Fletcher from the under-21s and the pool of young talent is as shallow as a Possilpark puddle.
Some of the supporters who called for Steve Clarke’s removal and a more expansive form of football are now calling for Scotland to go back to being sturdy and difficult to beat. Some are being forced to consider the possibility that the former manager did the best he could with the resources he had at his disposal.
While a lack of tactical flexibility on the part of Sebastian Pocognoli is becoming an issue, don’t expect any movement there just yet. The SFA have bigger issues to confront.
At the highest level of the Scottish game there is an acceptance that the resources available to the manager are not as strong as some would have you believe.
Despite a handful of players playing at a high level in the English Premier League and Serie A the goalkeepers, central defenders and strikers available leave much to be desired.
The current situation offers no immediate hope of changing that. At the start of 2016-17 approximately 53% of the players who started the first round of Premiership fixtures were born in Scotland. At the start of this season that figure fell to 28%. Look across Europe and only Turkey offers fewer minutes to homegrown talent under the age of 21 than here. For both the current under fire manager and Scotland bosses of the future, the situation is a ticking time bomb.
Accepting the existence of a problem is one thing. Asking Scotland’s 42 senior clubs to agree on a course of action to do something about it is something else.
Club football is king. Strip away the major tournaments and supporters can take or leave the international game. Like pot holes on roads or loud mouths on trains it’s one of life’s everyday irritations.
Fans of some clubs - like the clubs themselves - don’t especially care if the national team is back in the doldrums. It will never keep them awake at night in the same way as another missed chance for Kasper Hogh or a lapse in concentration from Manny Fernandez.
Celtic have won 14 of the last 15 league titles and, through design or circumstance, already offer first team minutes to young Scots Colby Donovan and Dane Murray. Despite questions over the value for money produced by their Lennoxtown academy, they see no real urgency to change things. They are not alone in that.
Craig Mulholland has had easier weeks than this. Sniping over the data-led process by which Pocognoli was recruited has already begun and now the SFA’s Chief Football Officer is fighting an uphill battle to persuade five Premiership clubs - Celtic, Dundee United, Hibernian, Motherwell and Rangers - to vote for the new proposals to give more first team football for under-21 players.
What looks fine to Stirling Albion or Stenhousemuir is not at all fine to Celtic, Rangers or Hibernian. Where the big two might want some form of B teams back in the conversation, lower league teams treat the idea as an affront to civilisation.
So it is, then, that any attempt to initiate change in Scottish football tends to finish up a half-baked fudge. An unsatisfactory something deemed to be slightly better than nothing at all. A least worst solution they can all sign up to, even if they’re holding their nose when they stick their cross in the box.
Read more
Craig Mulholland to pitch diluted SFA youth proposals after five clubs raise concerns
Dumbarton set to make SPFL history with youngest ever boss aged just 28
At a summit of the 42 clubs in St Andrews in September Mulholland and Chief Executive Ian Maxwell pushed the idea of two under-21 players starting all Scottish Cup and Premier Sports Cup games, with one on the pitch at all times.
In the SPFL Premiership clubs would also be asked to field under-21 players for an average of 60 minutes per game across the season.
The SFA also proposed to commit £1million a year to incentivise clubs across the leagues to play academy prospects.
Following weeks of discussions with clubs it’s now accepted that the plans in original form will not secure the necessary 11-1 majority from teams in the Premiership.
To get something through the proposals have now been watered down. Instead of playing two under-21 players clubs will now be asked to play two under-23 players for two seasons, with a view to reverting to the original plan in future. Time will tell if that passes through a vote either.
Persuading the SPFL’s Competitions Working Group to put a final set of proposals to the 42 clubs is the first step. A meeting to discuss that takes place Wednesday and holds the key to what happens next.
If there is some form of consensus, a vote on the Scottish Cup proposals would be put to the clubs at a general meeting next month.
The league and Premier Sports Cup proposals would require a separate vote in the New Year. Defeat would force the Scottish FA to go back to the drawing board, lick their wounds and consider what, if anything, they can do to change things.
The politics of Scottish football dictate that the carrot is generally more effective than the stick. Incentivising teams with cash for playing young talent might offer more hope of success than trying to impose new regulations. Whether it has any impact at all on the thinking of Celtic - a club with £70million in the bank - is another matter.
The nuclear option for the SFA is a change to the rules on work visas. Scottish clubs benefit from lax, post-Brexit Governing Body Exemption regulations which allow them to overload their squad with cut price imports from Europe and overseas.
Making it more difficult to bring in overseas jobbers would go a long way towards removing the obstacles facing young Scottish players - and might even lead to an improvement in club results in Europe. It would do nothing for peace and harmony between the governing body and the clubs who pretty much rule the roost.
Some take the view that it’s hard enough to be competitive in the current climate without the people running the game making it tougher still. Not all of them appreciate the free advice on how their team should
For Mulholland and the SFA, then, these are difficult, testing days. The future of Sebastian Pocognoli can wait.
Share