REVIEW

What is going wrong at BBC Scotland? I tuned in to find out

BBC Scotland presenter Kaye Adams has been suspended <i>(Image: Archive)</i>
BBC Scotland presenter Kaye Adams has been suspended (Image: Archive)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Testing times at Radio Scotland of late. First there was the suggestion that its flagship news show Good Morning Scotland might be scrapped (a reboot now seems more likely). And then over the weekend it emerged that Kaye Adams, presenter of the station's phone-in show Mornings had been reportedly suspended over allegations of unacceptable behaviour towards younger colleagues (a spokesperson for the presenter has said no complaints have been presented to her). That and the flak coming in for the replacement for the Shereen show on Saturday mornings - all as detailed by Alison Rowat in The Herald - and you’d understand if tin hats were currently part of the uniform at Pacific Quay.

On Monday, Connie McLaughlin was in the chair for the Mornings show and she maybe wished she had a crash helmet given the fractious nature of the debate about Prince Andrew during the first hour of the show. The programme had invited on both Graham Smith, CEO of the pressure group Republic and author of Abolish the Monarchy, and royal commentator Richard Fitzwilliam. Unsurprisingly, they weren’t on the same page.

Frankly, I doubt they were in the same library. Smith called for a police investigation into the allegations of the Prince’s links with sex offender Jeffrey Epstein and the claims published in Virginia Giuffre’s posthumous memoir (which include a suggestion that Andrew saw having sex with her when she was a teenager as his birthright) and an inquiry into what the Royal Family knew and when. Who cared that he wasn’t going to be able to use his titles anymore, he argued?

Fitzwilliam didn’t deny that Andrew had questions to answer - though, of course, the Prince has denied everything - but believed that the removal of titles from Andrew mattered. Because they are part of the British story, he suggested. “Republic would cut us off from our history.” Hmm. Begs the question who is meant by “our” in that sentence, but then I’ve always thought the existence of a monarchy is an infantilising construct of the rigidly hierarchical and unequal social structure in the UK. So, I accept I’m a bit biased.


Read more on BBC Scotland ructions


What followed, though, was a bit of a shouting match, with McLaughlin doing her best to let both men argue their position. There was a lot of heat but I’m not sure there was much light. But that is often my feeling about such phone-in shows.

That said, there was some wonderfully chilly froideur from former BBC Royal Correspondent Jenny Bond, after Smith had accused her of being a royalist. “Graham doesn’t know whether I’m a royalist or not. I have just stated, in fact, that I’m not wedded to the idea of monarchy. Perhaps he didn’t hear that. I’m a journalist and I try to see both sides and put the facts across as accurately as I can." Proof that iciness can burn too.

As an aside, is it just me who thinks playing music in the midst of such shows is a bit of an anachronism? It does seem a bit strange hearing Amy MacDonald in between discussions of Prince Andrew’s possible crimes and the menopause, no? Maybe that’s something else that can be looked at by new head of audio and events at BBC Scotland, Victoria Easton Riley.

As someone who is, at most, a casual listener to daytime Radio Scotland I don’t think a shake-up would be necessarily a bad thing, though I don’t really recognise the description of it as being currently too middle-class. If anything, my beef with Radio Scotland is how couthy so much of it can be (particularly in the way it covers culture; it seems scared of seriousness in this area, unlike sport which it can take painfully seriously, Off the Ball apart).

Prince Andrew is to stop using all of his titles and honours, including the Duke of York(Image: Toby Melville/PA Wire)

Of course, the station faces the same issue as all legacy media; in trying to find a new audience do you alienate the one you already have? How it tackles that question will have a huge bearing on its future.

On Sunday night over on Radio 4 the estimable Illuminated strand offered up a seductive sound profile of the Findhorn community on the Moray Firth. A “mystical Butlin’s” as one vintage commentator suggested.

Sound designer Jonathan Webb’s programme drew heavily on audio archive and was rather taken with the idea that the garden was a place where you might meet fairies or nature spirits.

“Plants may be incredibly sensitive organisms capable of direct telepathic communication with man,” one archive clip states (it sounded very like Magnus Magnusson speaking). “Electronics and elves, might they be the same thing after all?”

There was also much talk of gigantic carrots and cabbages. One contributor who as a kid helped with the harvesting pointed out that “40lbs of cabbage is a lot to eat, I can tell you.”

Ultimately, this was a portrait of a utopian moment that stretched through the 1960s and 1970s. I’m not sure it had much to say about FIndhorn today, but the result was equal parts silly and sweet. There are worse things to be.

Listen Out For: Private Passions, Radio 3, Sunday, October 26, Midday

Michael Berkeley’s next guest is none other than the Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer. The question is, will he choose Orange Juice as one of his favourite pieces of music as he did when he went to Radio 4’s notional desert island in 2020?

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos