The challenge Anas Sarwar has set his shadow cabinet this year is to stop telling the SNP what to do in government.
Instead, they should start talking about how Labour will act in government.
He has just under 16 months to show that he’s not leading an opposition but an administration in waiting.
And on Friday, when he addresses delegates at the Scottish Labour conference in Glasgow’s SEC, he will attempt to gee up a membership that has been battered and bruised by what the former dentist has often referred to as the “teething problems” of Sir Keir Starmer’s first seven months in power.
READ MORE
- Reform UK: Scottish Labour must see us as a threat
- Herald Poll: 'Imploding' Labour to hand SNP victory in 2026
- Water bills in Scotland £113 cheaper than England and Wales despite price hike
Earlier this month, a poll in The Herald on Sunday suggested the party was on course for its worst result since 2021.
That was backed up on Sunday by a new poll for the Sunday Times, which had them on 18%, leaving them tied on 18 seats in Holyrood, far behind the SNP's 55.
(Image: Andrew Milligan/PA)
Those teething problems include Chancellor Rachel Reeves' decision to end the universal winter fuel payment as part of her plan to tackle a black hole in the UK's finances has undoubtedly cost them votes.
They have also come in for fierce criticism for rowing back on commitments to WASPI women and on Grangemouth.
“In the Labour Party, if you give people a chance to focus on the negatives, they will. It's like our natural base inclination,” says one Labour source.
“So a lot of what we're going to be doing is being like, remember where we were a year ago? There were two MPs.
“Government isn't easy, but this is what we've achieved and also there's more to do. We’re only halfway up the mountain."
The party will be buoyed by last week's by-election result for the Kirkintilloch East, North and Twechar seat on East Dunbartonshire Council. While they held their vote, the SNP's dropped by 16 points.
Some in the party think their problems are down to communications.
"Sometimes being the Labour Party, we are very good at focusing on what have been the tough decisions and not celebrating what have been the really good decisions and actually as a Government, we have turned a lot of things around," says Michael Shanks, the Energy Minister and Rutherglen MP.
"I think everybody feels like we now need to be far more enthusiastic about selling a lot of those things."
“This year is where the election is going to be won or lost, frankly,” he adds.
"In some ways, in Scotland, winning the general election was really, really important but obviously, the massive test on the horizon has always been [the Holyrood election].
"We're almost at two decades of the SNP; 2026 is an absolutely vital moment for us."
(Image: Jane Barlow/PA Wire)
Dr Fraser McMillan from the Scottish Election Study thinks it might be too late.
Asked about his prediction for 2026, he told The Herald on Sunday: “I think it will be fairly straightforward. The way I see it right now is the SNP, by an absolute mile, will win and John Swinney is still going to be the First Minister.
“Starmer hasn’t got off to a great start in terms of controversial policies and the SNP still have a residual advantage of a message of standing up for Scotland.
“The likeliest scenario is that both the SNP and Labour will lose seats compared to 2021.”
“Unless Starmer can hand them some significant wins and they can find ways to attack the SNP, it’s going to be very difficult for them,” he adds.
READ MORE
- Neil Gray failed to act after early warning NHS Fife had acted illegally in trans row
- 'I don't want this f*****g condition': How Scottish disabled community are brutalised
- 'Fear and suspicion': The toxic culture at prominent Scots university
Michael Marra, the party’s Shadow Cabinet Secretary for Finance in Holyrood, is more upbeat about their chances. He believes that voters are “genuinely, genuinely, totally sick” of the SNP.
“I think that they are incompetent, that they have lost their way, and they can't be trusted with the public’s money. And so that is the contrast that we have to draw.
“We have to show that people can get behind us for a reason, and that's the kind of change that they want to see in the country.
“If you ask, is Scotland going in the right or the wrong direction, people believe it's going in the wrong direction.”
He accepts that the party has suffered because of the “really challenging decisions” taken by Sir Keir Starmer, but disputes comments made to The Herald on Sunday last month by Professor Sir John Curtice that “the worst thing that ever happened to Anas Sarwar was Keir Starmer becoming Prime Minister.”
“Nothing could be further from the truth. Not only was it necessary to rescue the country from inexorable chaos and decline, but the idea that there was a pathway to Anas becoming First Minister that wasn't contingent on a UK Labour victory in the general election is just nonsense.
“So yes, there are challenges that come from all of that, and we just have to build with that. Scottish Labour MPs are a big part of it. But also, we'd never have got the budget settlement that we got in Scotland, the £5.2 billion, if Anas and myself and others hadn't been working with 37 Labour MPs to make it happen.”
(Image: Jane Barlow/PA)
This conference will be a marked contrast to previous gatherings of the party faithful.
“If you look back three years ago we were just essentially fighting for relevance,” says a Labour source.
“If you look back two years ago we were just trying to remind people why we existed, and what the purpose of the Labour Party was.
“And if you look at last year, it was really just to focus minds on the general election.
”We didn't really have a huge policy offer, or anything like that.
“I think we're all on the same page. We all want broadly the same things, but the stakes are higher at this conference than they have been at anyone previously.
“Now we're preparing to challenge the government and potentially become the government, so people are becoming a bit more invested in it."
This, they added, would mean a slightly “more serious” conference where “everything is electorate focused.”
“It has been a difficult first few months for the Labour government, but I think we all knew that was going to come,” says one of the party’s younger activists.
"But where you’re seeing the polls slip for Labour in the rest of the country, and we’re kind of seeing that in Scotland as well, if you look at the by-elections we have had in councils recently, it’s a different story,” they add optimistically.
“The polls suggest the party is pretty much where it was in 2021, having been through a period of growth and success,” says polling expert Mark Diffley, “They benefited hugely from the UK wide dissatisfaction in the Tory party, particularly during Liz Truss’s brief tenure.
“And then in 2023 they benefited from the implosion of the SNP after Nicola Sturgeon resigned, and the year that Humza Yousaf was in charge, all of which culminated in a sort of even better than expected performance at the General Election.
“That happened over a three year period. The reversal in fortunes has happened much over a six month period. In other words, this has happened really, really quickly, and we know reflects voters' views on the early days of the Starmer Government.
“The government has run out of popularity very, very quickly. And Labour in Scotland is not immune to that.”
There has been no resurgence in the SNP vote, he adds, but rather John Swinney has successfully steadied the ship. It is not back to anywhere near to where it was in 2021 and yet it still seems likely they will be the biggest party again when we go to the polls in May 2026.
“The SNP has recovered slightly, but they’ve not recovered by being dynamic or full of ideas. It's recovered just on the back of doing not very much, but letting Labour implode,” Mr Diffley points out.
“I think Anas would be probably within his rights to be grumpy at what's happening down south.
“The publicly stated strategy of the UK government is to ride out a stormy first couple of years where they’re making difficult and unpopular decisions, and then hope that, economic growth and improved public services kick in in time for the election in 2028/2029.”
For Mr Sarwar, who is facing the polls in just over a year, that timetable is unhelpful
(Image: Andrew Milligan/PA)
Labour has kept about six in ten of the Scots who voted for the party back in 2024, says Mr Diffley. Some have gone to the SNP, but others have gone to Nigel Farage’s Reform UK.
“Your appeal to get ex-voters back who have gone to Reform looks quite different from the appeal you have to make to get voters back who've returned to the SNP.
“It’s not impossible but it does rather highlight the depth of the hole that they're in at the moment.”
For Labour to win next year, Mr Sarwar will need to do more than just point out the teething problems—he’ll need to don his scrubs, pick up his drill, and get to work filling the cracks.
Share