Unspun 🗳️

Third of SNP MSPs stepping down leaves Swinney at crossroads

Humza Yousaf, Michael Matheson and Nicola Sturgeon are among the SNP MSPs stepping down. <i>(Image: Derek McArthur)</i>
Humza Yousaf, Michael Matheson and Nicola Sturgeon are among the SNP MSPs stepping down. (Image: Derek McArthur)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter.


A third of SNP MSPs are standing down, leaving John Swinney at a crossroads.

If you include the expelled John Mason, the SNP will lose 24 sitting MSPs at the Scottish Parliament election in 2026.

While it is not unusual for MSPs to step down at an election, it arguably comes at a crucial time for the First Minister.

Since Swinney entered Bute House, he has had to field off concerns his party is doomed at Holyrood 2026.

Polls were not looking good. And it was only in July that the SNP suffered a disastrous general election result, falling to just nine seats.

Add on top of that an exodus on MSPs and it would have seemed catastrophic for Swinney.

But is the departure of a third of MSPs - so far - really a warning sign for the SNP leader?

Get Scotland's top politics newsletter straight to your inbox.


He has brushed off any fears in interviews with journalists.

But the loss of a score of MSPs can never be good news for a party fighting through its recovery.

Many of the exiting MSPs have been in Holyrood a long time, meaning the SNP will lose a wealth of talent, including seven current frontbenchers.

It leaves Swinney with the tough decision of whether to reshuffle his cabinet sooner rather than later.

That could give the public a chance to get to know newer faces in the party who are ready to step up.

It would also signal Swinney is keen to press on with his refreshed governance of the SNP, which seems to be slowly bringing voters back, according to recent polling.

MSPs quitting at 2026 Scottish election - full list 

SNP MP Kirsty Blackman recently dismissed claims the party was suffering from a "talent drain" with the upcoming retirements.

That is, she says, because the "huge talent" in the candidate list, which includes a couple of current SNP MPs, including Westminster leader Stephen Flynn.

And around 15 former MPs have passed vetting, including Alison Thewliss, Amy Callaghan, Alyn Smith, Tommy Sheppard and Anum Qaisar.


Read more from Unspun:


If elected that will give Swinney the support of faithful party politicians - but can he rely on them to get the votes over the line, especially as so many failed to hold onto their seats in 2024?

Of course, it’s not just the SNP losing MSPs to retirement next year. So far in Holyrood, a total of 30 MSPs won't seek re-election.

That is 23 from the SNP, one independent (Mason), three Tories, two Labour and a Liberal Democrat. And don't be surprised if there's more to come.

Before the 2021 election, 34 MSPs stepped down, including former Labour leaders Johann Lamont and Iain Gray, and Tory leader Ruth Davidson.

The 2016 election meant the Holyrood retirement of 24 MSPs, including former first minister Alex Salmond and former Tory leader Annabel Goldie.

If John Swinney hadn't stepped up to take on the job as First Minister in May last year, it was widely expected he too would step down.

If he is to be first minister again in 2026, his task is navigating through the changing face of the SNP benches.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos