When the final children were moved from Polmont Young Offenders Institution last August, those who worked in the youth justice system breathed a sigh of relief. It had long been acknowledged that the jail was no place for under-18s who - regardless of their offences - would be safer, and more likely to be rehabilitated, in one of the county’s four secure units.
But the success of the new policy, enshrined in the Children (Care and Justice) (Scotland) Act, depended on the secure estate being equipped to look after the number of children it was being required to take. And — despite the Scottish government handing over half a million pounds to help them prepare — this has not proved to be the case. Rather, the system has been in an almost constant state of crisis, with the units bursting at the seams.
Operating at full capacity, Kibble in Paisley, the Good Shepherd in Bishopton, St Mary’s Kenmure in Bishopbriggs and Rossie Farm in Montrose offer a total of 78 beds. On most days since Christmas, however, there has been no more than one free place across the country (and often no free beds at all).
Last month, in a letter to Natalie Don-Innes, Minister for Children, Young People and the Promise, Nicola Killean, the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland, claimed the lack of capacity was creating a two-tier system, with young people referred through the children’s hearing system on welfare grounds being denied a bed to make way for those sent there by the courts.
“I have been told that instead of a placement in a safe and therapeutic environment, with integrated education and mental health support, [these] children have had to be placed in what has been described to me as ‘cobbled together’ provision, with social workers and others trying to find ways of keeping them safe,” Killean wrote.
“Children assessed as meeting the secure threshold via the hearings system are not at any less risk or in any less need of protection [than those detained by the courts.”
Read more in the series:
Inside Scotland's 'life changing' alternative to jail for women
Read all articles in our Scotland's Prisons: Crisis Behind Bars series
Behind the scenes of a 'game changing' female prison - but does it work?
Neither local authorities nor the Scottish government collect figures on those children who meet the threshold for secure care but have been turned away. However, sources within the youth justice system have told me they believe there have been at least half a dozen over the last few months.
“Of course, additional support measures are put in place for those children,” one source told me. “But if keeping them in the community had been regarded as the best option, they wouldn’t have been referred to secure care.”
Another said: “What worries me is that, if a child knows they will be placed in secure care as soon as a place becomes available, they may engage in even riskier behaviour while they are waiting — one last, desperate going-off-the-rails before they are locked up."
Under the new Act it is illegal to send under-18s to Polmont and so — as Killean suggests — children remanded or sentenced by a sheriff appear to be leap-frogging those referred on welfare grounds. But capacity is limited for young offenders, too. One social worker told me of days when three teenagers have been due to appear in court, with bail opposed by the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS), yet there has only been one free bed.
On those days, the social workers have been left crossing their fingers that at least two of the sheriffs will reject the Crown’s submission, and opt for a community disposal. So far, that is what has happened. But such decisions are not taken with pressures on the secure estate in mind. Indeed, there are reports that, in some areas, the number of children being remanded to custody has gone up, as sheriffs feel more comfortable sending children to secure units than they would have felt sending them to Polmont. So it seems inevitable that, at some point, several under-18s will be detained within the same 24 hour period.
You only have to look at the three boys charged in connection with the murder of 15-year-old refugee Amen Teklay to see how a single terrible incident could tip the system into chaos. Only one of the two teenagers who appeared in court on March 5 was remanded in custody, while the third wasn’t charged until March 24. Had all three been charged and remanded to custody on the same day, there would have been nowhere to put them.
While the lack of beds leaves some children under-protected in the community, it also has a detrimental impact on those who are detained. In an ideal world, the placing of a young person in secure care is a considered process. Social workers and those in charge of the units assess the needs of the child in question, together with the needs of the children already in situ, to find the best match. With gangs still a feature of Central Belt life, they also investigate “prior associations”, making sure those with a history of “bad blood” are kept apart.
None of that is possible if there is only one bed available. Moreover, if the young person being detained is in the Central Belt and the only place available is in Rossie Farm (or vice versa), that young person will be moved away from his or her family, and continuity of care will be lost.
How we got into this mess is a complicated question. It is true — as Killean has argued — that the Scottish government and secure care providers should have been better prepared for the increased pressure created by the recent change in legislation.
Don-Innes insisted the Scottish government’s needs assessment had been influenced by a general downward trend in referrals caused by an international consensus that children should be deprived of their liberty only as a last resort.
Unfortunately, she said, they had been met with a series of unexpected circumstances, including a damning Care Inspectorate report on St Mary’s Kenmure which saw its numbers capped at 12 (down from 24), reducing overall bed numbers by a sixth.
Read more:
- How giving every school child a week in the wilderness can transform their lives
- 'Homeless and destitute': the policy driving vulnerable migrants into danger
- 'We cannot allow our social care system to fall into further disrepair'
- Dramatic discovery: rare medal found in bid to name Scottish school after suffragette
- Kevin McKenna: 'This is the most Scottish moment in my entire life'
But there had already been several negative reports on St Mary’s, which had not been acted on.
Other factors — such as the continued renting out of beds to English local authorities (there are still seven young people from south of the Border within the Scottish secure estate) — and Covid provisions which have extended the amount of time all prisoners, including under-18s, can be held on remand — are long-standing, and should also have been taken into account.
On the other hand, secure care is, by its very nature, unpredictable. In the last few months, the system has seen an as-yet unexplained upswing in referrals/court disposals from Edinburgh and the Lothians, alongside an increase in individuals with highly complex and resource-intensive needs who require more than one bed.
One of the challenges in ensuring the optimum provision lies in the way secure care is structured.
All four units are run by separate charitable trusts and have to keep themselves economically viable. This means they have to fill as many of their beds as possible, and explains their reliance on cross-border placements. The units can charge English authorities more than Scottish ones, which, in the past, meant young people were sometimes placed there for financial reasons rather than in their own best interests. Since the death of 16-year-old William Lindsay, who, in 2018, killed himself after being remanded to Polmont because the secure estate was full, the Scottish government has been paying the units to keep some beds free for emergencies; but this is clearly not enough. Furthermore, critics say the fact they are governed by charity law - as opposed to statutory services - has led to a lack of transparency.
Equally problematic is the tension between the long-term goal of keeping children out of secure care, and what is happening on the ground. Secure units are much more therapeutic settings than jails but they remain a melting pot of troubled children with conflicting needs. Some of those children would probably be better cared for in a mental health facility, but these too are under -resourced and over-subscribed. This situation has not been helped by the fact that a BBC Disclosure investigation into “a culture of cruelty” means Skye House — a 24-bed adolescent psychiatric unit in the grounds of Stobhill Hospital — is now the subject of an independent review. Or that the opening of Foxgrove in Irvine — a secure mental health unit for young people — has been delayed by three years after “quality issues with the building were identified, and its initial capacity has been reduced from 12 to four.
As part of The Promise — the Scottish government’s commitment to political and legislative change that will ensure children in its care grow up ‘loved, safe and respected’ — the Children and Young People’s Centre for Justice was commissioned to produce a report Reimagining Secure Care, published last year. Its vision was for a system in which more children currently in secure units would be able to remain within their communities with intensive, wrap-around support, while the units themselves would become more holistic.
Last week in Holyrood, Don-Innes announced that — following improvements — the cap on numbers at St Mary’s Kenmure had been lifted, and that the unit was now trying to recruit more staff so it could start taking more children again. In addition, she said, part of the Rossie Farm estate, which has had very good Care Inspectorate reports, had been “repurposed” to provide four more beds.
This — along with English efforts to increase provision south of the border — should ease the immediate crisis. But pressure will rise again when another section of the Children’s (Care and Justice) Act is finally enforced. This section will raise the threshold for first referrals to the Children’s Hearing System from 16 to 18, and so increase the number of young people eligible for secure care on welfare grounds.
Don-Innes is wary of using money which could be spent on community services to firefight what may be a short-term crisis. Speaking to me after her statement to the chamber, she said: “The cost of secure care is hefty, and we want to make sure those millions of pounds are directed towards providing support for children and young people rather than on unused beds.”
Others are concerned about a twist on Parkinson’s Law: the theory that the number of children in secure care will expand to fill the number of beds available.
Fiona Duncan, independent strategic advisor - the Promise, sees the shift of the last children out of the young offenders’ institution as a missed opportunity for systemic change.
“Outlawing the detention of children in prison and removing all under-18s from Polmont was a chance for the Scottish government to grasp the fact that there are four individual charitable organisations with four separate boards of trustees and four separate chief executives operating in four completely different ways, and to create something which provides congruous governance and care for this very distinct group of children, who often experience care, education, health and sometimes justice simultaneously,” she says.
Duncan believes a marker of Scotland’s success would be a shrinking of the secure estate.
At the same time, you cannot keep children out of secure units until intensive wrap-around support is in place, and the Scottish government has not yet responded to the Reimagining Secure Care report.
“The aspiration is a move towards much more community-based provision, but that doesn’t exist yet,” Duncan says. “Decisions and investment are required by the Scottish government to make it possible — though many voluntary sector organisations who want to support children in this way are ready to and itching to get started."
The danger is that the capacity crisis creates a drive to establish more beds which will jeopardise efforts to reduce the numbers of children in secure care, making it harder to achieve Scotland’s vision.
“This group of children urgently needs the government to work strategically, across portfolios— including care, health, education and justice — and at pace so the focus shifts from counting their numbers to meeting their needs.” Duncan says.
Share