First Minister John Swinney has said the government is reviewing its guidance on mothballing rural schools and nurseries in light of concerns from parents and MSPs.
Mr Swinney was pressed on the Scottish Government's responsibility for protecting rural schools and nurseries and overseeing council decisions about temporary and permanent closures.
SNP MSP Christine Grahame raised the topic during Thursday's First Minister's Questions. She voiced concerns that mothballing, or temporarily closing, rural nurseries makes rural communities less sustainable.
The First Minister said: “Any closure, temporary or permanent, should be considered in consultation with the local communities. We are reviewing guidance on mothballing to provide greater clarity on whether it is an appropriate action to take.
“This will ensure local decisions are based on effective engagement with communities and better reflect the needs of rural families.”
Ms Grahame referenced several nurseries in her constituency in the Scottish Borders, where the council has initiated mothballing procedures and opened a community consultation.
Parents at the affected nurseries spoke out against the council's approach to mothballing, feeling that the council was not transparent about its plans and had not adequately consulted with communities about the impact the temporary closures might have.
Ms Grahame and other elected officials raised concerns that the council was not following the correct procedures, and had previously asked the council to pause its decision until she was able to get clarity on the legal guidance around mothballing.
She said that many of the affected rural nurseries receive added educational and social benefits by being attached to primary schools. Closing these could have long-term consequences for rural communities, she warned on Thursday.
“It's my belief for educational and social reasons, as well as sustaining that primary school and wider community, in these circumstances these particular nurseries require added protection.”
Read more:
- Council admits it could have done better as parents left unconvinced by process
-
Council to begin consultations for mothballing seven nurseries
-
Council accused of attempting to ignore government guidance on nursery closure
She asked if the First Minister would consider adding "additional criteria" to govern the mothballing procedures in rural areas.
The First Minister said: "At the heart of the reforms on early learning and childcare, the government has been working with our local authority partners to ensure that young people are able to get the best start to their early years education.
"We will reflect on the points that Christine Graham has made because I think they are substantial considerations in making sure we have this provision available in all communities in Scotland."
Conservative MSP Stephen Kerr also asked about a recent decision to close Blackness Primary School in Falkirk Council, which was opposed almost universally by the affected community.
Mr Kerr said that parents felt the council had provided misleading information during the process and that the strength of opposition from parents should have carried more sway in the decision-making process.
Mr Kerr asked if the Scottish Government would step in to investigate how consultations are carried to “ensure the voices of parents and families are not just heard but respected".
The First Minister said there are "very strict elements of legislation in place around any question of rural school closure" and invited Mr Kerr to write to Education Secretary Jenny Gilruth about the matter.
Share