John Swinney has insisted next year's Holyrood election will give voters a “crystal clear” choice on independence.
Speaking at The Herald’s Unspun Live at the Fringe, the First Minister said: “Nobody will be under any illusion what voting for the SNP means on 7 May 2026."
There would, he added, be "no humming and hawing."
The SNP leader also rejected calls from within his own party to use the election as a de facto referendum.
Summerhall's dissection room packed full as Brian Taylor interviews John Swinney at the Herald Unspun Live at the Fringe (Image: Gordon Terris/NQ)
He said only an agreed vote would deliver a legitimate route to independence.
He confirmed the SNP would enter the May 2026 Holyrood election on a single, unambiguous pledge: that a majority of SNP MSPs would constitute a mandate to hold another referendum.
“There’ll be no mucking about,” he said.
“It will be absolutely crystal clear, because I want the clarity from the people of Scotland to be able to make sure their wishes are delivered.”
“There will be no mucking about” if the SNP win a majority at Holyrood next year when it comes to FM’s plans that this would secure a mandate for an independence referendum.
— Hannah Brown (@HannahMargBrown) August 5, 2025
John Swinney speaking to Brian Taylor at @heraldscotland Unspun Live at the Fringe this evening. pic.twitter.com/wL5m96xl7K
Mr Swinney's strategy has proved controversial, with rebels set to attempt to amend it at the party’s October conference.
READ MORE
- Curtice: ‘Most extremely unlikely’ SNP will win majority of MSPs in 2026
- Kate Forbes hints at possible political return in 2046
- John Swinney, Donald Trump and the £4m whisky question
One change backed by 43 branches would make a majority of list votes for pro-independence parties in 2026 a mandate for independence negotiations with the UK Government.
Mr Swinney told the audience in Edinburgh’s Summerhall: “I do not think that is an argument that would have any legal force at the end of it, because it is not an agreed process.
“It might be what we would like to do, and I would love Scotland yesterday, today, but it is not going to deliver that agreed process of Scotland becoming an independent country.
“Look at the situation that has emerged in Catalonia without an agreed process. Catalonia tried to secure its independence, and it did not succeed.”
The FM said there would be no mucking about at next year's election (Image: Gordon Terris/NQ) Asked by The Herald’s Brian Taylor if he was only raising independence because his party was in “some degree of trouble”, the First Minister said it was about his phases.
Phase one was ensuring the SNP “could get a hearing” and was considered “credible in the eyes of the public”. Phase two was about the constitution.
Asked what would happen if he fell short, his plan B, Mr Swinney said: “Well, I am going to go for my aim, and then we will see.”
On Monday, at [[The Herald]]'s Unspun Live, Professor Sir John Curtice said he thought the [[SNP]]'s chances of winning a majority of seats was "extremely unlikely."
Asked if not winning a majority of seats would mean a referendum was off the table, Mr Swinney said: “I am just simply putting forward my point of view.
“And also an important constitutional point and a substantial point about who we are as a country — this country is being denied, under the current arrangements of the actions of the United Kingdom Government, the right to decide.
“By the way, on the point of a generation, while I am on this question, by 2030 a million people will be in Scotland who were not eligible to vote in 2014, if you want to start talking about what a generation looks like.”
Mr Swinney also ruled out any co‑operation with Reform UK, describing the party’s values as “anathema” to his own.
“I just think the value system and the outlook of the Reform leadership is anathema to what I represent in my politics. I am not going to do a deal with Reform,” he said.
By contrast, he expressed willingness to work with other parties on specific issues, pointing to agreements with the Scottish Greens and Scottish Liberal Democrats on this year’s budgets.
“When I became First Minister, in my acceptance speech, I said that I wanted to try to rebuild the ability of Parliament to work properly across parties, because I thought it had become too fractured, too polarised.
“When it got to the budget, four parties voted for the government’s budget.
“Alex Cole‑Hamilton, immediately before I became First Minister, said his votes were available to bring down the government and force an early election.
“Three months later, the Liberals were voting for the budget.”
Brian Taylor turns to the audience for a question at Unspun Live (Image: Gordon Terris/NQ)
Asked about criticism from consultancy EY that Scotland’s higher overall tax burden could deter investment, Mr Swinney rejected the claim, pointing to net migration into Scotland as evidence to the contrary.
“I do not take that view,” he said. “We have got to invest in our infrastructure and services. We are seeing net migration levels into Scotland which are higher — that is an indication that tax is not putting people off coming here.”
He said there would be no changes to tax policy before the next election but called for an “open debate” on how to fund public services in the long term. “We have to strike a rational balance,” he said.
Mr Swinney also reflected on his recent encounter with former US president Donald Trump, who was in Scotland earlier this year.
“I had a very pleasant and courteous exchange with President Trump and valued the opportunity to set out the views of the people I serve,” he said. “In the conversation, he made it abundantly clear to me that he adores Scotland.”
The First Minister presented Mr Trump with a framed copy of a handwritten 1853 marriage record from Lewis relating to the President's mother’s grandparents, and a 1921 census entry showing his mother aged nine.
“He seemed deeply touched,” Mr Swinney said. “I later found out most governments give him golf clubs."
READ MORE
- Network Rail teams 'working tirelessly' to repair railway after Storm Floris damage
- Police probe launched after man dies days after being found injured in Aberdeen
- Kate Forbes on exiting Holyrood: hear her story at Unspun Live
Brian Taylor interviews John Swinney at the Herald Unspun Live at the Fringe (Image: Gordon Terris/NQ)
Responding to Mr Swinney's comments on the constitution, Scottish Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie said: “[[John Swinney]] sounds like a broken record.
“He does not have anything new to say, so instead he has turned to the old SNP playbook by talking up independence and marching activists up the hill."
She added: “John Swinney arrogantly takes the public for granted by assuming the SNP will be returned as the largest party at Holyrood before a single vote is cast.
“And yet just this week, even his Deputy First Minister has decided to abandon ship.
“The people of Scotland will not be fooled by this latest desperate attempt to distract from the SNP’s dismal record after 18 years in government.
“Only Scottish Labour has vision for Scotland, by restoring our public services and offering Scots the chance to take a new direction.”
Share