John Swinney has said a resolution on independence which SNP rebels hoped to debate at his party's conference this autumn will not work.
The First Minister was speaking after activists drew up a motion which differed significantly from his independence strategy.
Under the rebel plan, first revealed by The Herald this month, a majority of list votes for pro-independence parties in 2026 would secure a mandate for independence negotiations with the UK Government. A total of 43 local branches backed the proposal.
But it is at odds with Mr Swinney’s plan, which contends that a mandate is only achievable if the SNP wins a majority of seats at Holyrood.
READ MORE:
- 'I'm seething': John Swinney faces backlash as SNP block rebel indy plan debate
- Rebels in secret indy plot ahead of SNP national conference
- Swinney rules out SNP rebels’ plans in 2026 election
- Analysis: Is Scottish independence the politics of yesteryear?
Asked by STV in an interview on Monday night about the grassroots proposal, Mr Swinney said: "I don't agree with it and I don't think it will work."
The rebel resolution was blocked by the SNP's conferences committee from the party's draft agenda for the annual conference to take place in Aberdeen in October.
Members now intend to summit an amendment to Mr Swinney's resolution.
The conferences committee will decide after September 5 whether to accept the amendment for debate.
Asked about whether it should be heard, Mr Swinney said: "It will be up to the conferences committee to decide."
He was asked if he would be prepare to debate the grassroots plan, Mr Swinney replied: "Of course I would be. I am a democrat. I lead a democratic political party and I have debated many important choices with my party over time.
"But I don't think it will work because we had that in 2016 and 2021 and it didn't break the log jam and the issue is having a route which results in Scotland becoming independent....If Scotland is to become independent there has to be domestic and international legitimacy for an independent Scotland. We had that in 2014 because all the rules were agreed."
The rebel resolution, which argues this threshold should be lowered and include votes cast for Alba and the Scottish Greens, was proposed by members in Oban and Lorn, Tweeddale, and Helensburgh.
The group submitted the following motion for approval by the SNP's conference committee: “Conference instructs the Party to prioritise obtaining a mandate from the sovereign Scottish people to deliver independence. This will be possible by achieving a majority of the popular vote on the sum of the Independence Supporting Parties’ List Votes in the 2026 Scottish parliamentary election."
After the rebel resolution failed to make it on the party's draft agenda for the party's conference, one activist, who supported the proposal, told The Herald:"I am absolutely seething. I have never known a resolution with so much backing which has been so unceremoniously put to the side."
Share