SIR TOM DEVINE

Historian Tom Devine, a Catholic, mourns demise of Church of Scotland

Sir Tom Devine keeps all his works in a modest bookcase <i>(Image: Gordon Terris)</i>
Sir Tom Devine keeps all his works in a modest bookcase (Image: Gordon Terris)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

'The Church of Scotland has not always in the past been kind to people like me who are Roman Catholics,' says historian Sir Tom Devine but he believes its demise has robbed the nation of a set of values with which to lead a "decent way of life"


A small book-case sits in a corner of Professor Sir Tom Devine’s front room in Hamilton, partly hidden by a settee, as though put there in a ‘we better find some space for this’ afterthought. It’s only after you’ve looked at the two framed family photographs which dwarf the ones of him receiving his knighthood that you come to inspect the contents of the cabinetry underneath.

It comprises almost all of Sir Tom’s life work, a cluster of more than 40 histories and collected essays which, if they belonged to some other households, would be back-lit and form the centre-piece of a chamber that was designed around it. There would be bronze inscriptions.

No-one who has known this man could ever accuse him of false modesty and so you’re left to wonder why the grandest, end-to-end chronology of the Scottish nation at every stage of its jaggy modern evolution sits on three low shelves where you’d normally put your football annuals. The great ones are all there, of course: Scottish Nation, Scotland’s Empire and The Ends of the Earth, but it’s one of his later works which, I think, helps us to understand what drives his purpose.


Read more


Recovering Scotland’s Slavery Past, published in 2015, shone a torch on the nation’s dirty little secret: that Scotland was active at all levels in the Caribbean slave trade, hitherto regarded by historians as mainly an English malevolence. In editing these essays he’d readily admitted that they rebuke his own failure to include Scotland’s role in slavery in his first book, The Tobacco Lords, published 40 years earlier.

In other works he’d also challenged persistent Scottish shibboleths such as the extent to which landlordism was held to be responsible for the Highland Clearances and that the Clearances extended south to the Scottish Borders. Later, he would attract some anger in our own tribe by concluding that anti-Irish Catholicism in the 21st century was not as prevalent in modern Scotland as many of us had been too ready to believe.

Even as he’s bringing the curtain down on his writing career, he’s re-examining what makes modern Scotland and looking for clues. Large sections of his work are informed by his Catholic faith and Irish heritage seen through the prism of a lowland Scottish, working-class identity and culture. Even so, it’s his thoughts on the importance of the Church of Scotland in shaping Scotland’s character which are the most compelling.

We’re both united in our admiration for Kate Forbes and the grace with which this young member of the Free Church of Scotland handled the campaign of slander and abuse orchestrated by her own party leadership. He believes Ms Forbes is the outstanding example of how the separation of church and state ought to work in an enlightened democracy.

Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes will stand down next year (Image: Jeff J Mitchell)

“From post 1945 to the present, you’re always reflecting on the main changes in Scottish society in this period,” he says. “The obvious ones are the emergence of a commitment to Scottish independence as the prevailing political force and then there’s the transformation of the economy, but next comes secularisation. There had been no evidence of it until about 1960. We were still locking down the swings on a Sunday.” He suggests that later, this was most obviously evident in the virtual and swift collapse of the Church of Scotland. And that this was linked to the accompanying collapse of Sunday schools which he describes as “the necessary foundation for preparation of the new generation of Christian life in adulthood”. The fire-sale of churches is further evidence of it.

“Has this been bad for Scotland,” I ask. “The Presbyterian history of Scotland since just after the Reformation and especially in the absence of a parliament, has been the main sociological and cultural factors shaping modern Scotland,” he says. “It’s had this since the 16th century in education, welfare and how we ordered family life and now it’s gone. I personally believe the demise of the Kirk has had a negative effect on us as a nation, mainly because I believe the values upheld by the Kirk and its ethos has been good for Scotland in promoting what you might call “a decent way of life”.

“This ethos was rooted in self-help; anti-materialism, an honest work ethic and recoiling from ostentatious displays of wealth of the type you see in celebrity culture. The next generation is encouraged to see these as role models, when actually they’re being exploited by them. It’s an ideology of self, though I accept too that such an attitude may simply be reflecting my age. And I accept that at certain times in its history the Church of Scotland has not been kind to people like me who are Roman Catholics.”

Kevin McKenna talks to Sir Tom Devine in his Hamilton home (Image: Gordon Terris)

When I suggest that outside of Scotland we’re regarded as possessing natural defence mechanisms against extreme capitalism and ostentatious wealth: caution, reserve, natural rectitude, he agrees. “The Kirk was the biggest influence in shaping our values and so it follows that its collapse has caused those national attributes and characteristics that once defined us to recede, although I don’t want to exaggerate this as some aspects were not acceptable. It was about achieving a balance.”

Today, the values of the Scottish Enlightenment, the great flowering of intellect, science and philosophy in the 18th and 19th centuries, seem to be under threat in those academic institutions which once fostered them. “I began to see it in my last 10 years at Edinburgh University and in particular of colleagues who began to face intolerance because they’d “given offence”. Sadly, the universities have been slow to defend them.” He cites the case of the Aberdeen University academic who was accused (and cleared) of transphobia and bigotry for playing Harry Potter music in his classes.

“An anthropologist friend of mine at Edinburgh went through this too, yet it had been non-existent for the vast bulk of my academic career. People who are caught up in this tend to be involved in the Humanities, the areas that deal with human behaviour. There’s a mind-virus consciousness at play.”

He returns to the treatment of Kate Forbes, the most gifted and smartest politician of her era. She’d been a post-graduate student in his Scottish Centre for Diaspora Studies at Edinburgh University. “This reinforces what we’ve been talking about,” he says. “When such attitudes are allowed to prevail and high-quality people get hounded, it’s to the detriment of Scotland’s collected wisdom.”

Yet, even after all of this, he’s reluctant to change his 2014 position in support of independence “though, I’d need to give it a lot of thought, were another chance to present itself,” he says. “But I’d have to consider if it had a reasonable chance of success. My suspicion is that the Unionists will be very reluctant to cede a referendum until a series of polls is reaching towards the 60s. Plus, there hasn’t been a lot of time since the 2014 referendum.” He then provides his stock response when asked to predict likely outcomes: “The future is not my period.”

He tells me he’s tried to make sense of polling conducted over the last two years which has continually indicated a preference for independence, despite the manifest failings of the Scottish Government. “You also have to consider the fact that there has been a very significant increase in the power of Scottish identity compared to all others. The plural identities of the past seem to have diminished, and the Scottish identity is now much to the fore and especially among the generation of those in the 18 to 40 age categories.


Read more


“The other week, I was listening to Runrig’s last live concert, and of course the final song was ‘Loch Lomond’. My God, it was like a religious meeting on a very large scale.”

In “Independence or Union” he records the experiences of some people who are “of the Unionist persuasion” coming to recognise that they're living in a different country compared to 20 years ago. “There are fascinating quotes from people talking about attending children’s events and fundraising events and being greeted by pipe bands and the saltires appearing everywhere. There was a common theme: it was like living in a Scotland that had already become independent.

“It reinforces the view that many people still regard the SNP, whatever its flaws and faults, as the greatest defender - at least in terms of the availability of what's there as alternatives - of Scottish interests. I'm not suggesting that this is the correct analysis, but it's the only one I can come up with. And the other thing, of course, is that the competition isn't very appealing either, except unfortunately, the siren voices of that other party.”

In the course of our two-hour discussion he can’t quite bring himself to say the name of “the other party” out loud. It’s as though it’s an anathema to his Scottish, Irish Lanarkshire, working-class soul and the principles of his calling.


Kevin McKenna is Scotland's Feature Writer of the Year

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos