Brian Donnelly

New homes in Scottish city centre abandoned for hotel plan

'Much-needed' new homes in Scottish city centre replaced by hotel plan <i>(Image: Ediston/NQ)</i>
'Much-needed' new homes in Scottish city centre replaced by hotel plan (Image: Ediston/NQ)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A plan for new homes in a Scottish city centre has been abandoned for a hotel development.

The proposal for 50 new homes in the city currently mired in a housing emergency looks to have been superseded by the hotel giant’s plan.

The site at the bottom of Dundas Street in Edinburgh will see the demolition of two office blocks.

The earlier proposal for "much-needed" houses attracted criticism from heritage watchdogs and the hotel plan is expected to have the same level of scrutiny.

Sitting on the edge of the Edinburgh New Town World Heritage Site, the former Centrum and Bupa offices were earmarked to be razed to be replaced by 50 new homes.

The previous plan. (Image: Google/Morgan Architects)

However, a new planning application is to be lodged for Dakota Hotels to take over the site.

The location is directly opposite the Scottish capital’s largest gap site, which itself is currently in limbo.


Read More:


There, a proposal for hundreds of homes that was shelved amid concerns of rent controls meaning investment could be loss-making was revived with the inclusion of student housing.

However, the council’s development management sub committee voted against the massive new development citing density concerns.

The hotel looks similar to the housing. (Image: Morgan Architects)

Speaking as a neighbour, I do not share the councillors' concerns.

The proposals at the former Royal Bank of Scotland site involving Ediston and Orion were changed after an initial target of around 400 homes.


Read More:


We told how RBS initially brought forward redevelopment proposals in 2016, before abandoning those proposals and selling the site to Orion Capital Managers in 2019.

It is expected that the New Town Quarter plan will go to appeal with the Scottish Government. Mairi McAllan, Housing Secretary,  visited the 5.9 acre site in September with senior development figures to launch construction works.

How the New Town Quarter would look. (Image: Ediston)

The new proposals now include plans for 315 new homes, including 108 affordable homes and 591 student beds to be operated by “one of the country’s leading student housing providers”, Fusion Students.

A spokesperson for the development said earlier: “The partnership between Orion Capital and Fusion has been essential to deliver viable housing-based proposals.

“The proposals have been developed over many years and have evolved in the face of huge upheavals in the economy and construction market since the site was vacated.”


Read More:


Ross McNulty, the development director at Ediston Real Estate, which is managing the development process, said before the rejection: “This is one of the last major brownfield sites in the city and we’re determined to make sure that the proposals do no less than make this high-quality neighbourhood one of the best places in Scotland to live in and visit.

“This is the largest housing development in the city centre for more than a decade and can help reverse the decline in housing delivery in recent years to deliver more homes, more quickly.”

He said: “These proposals will deliver a more inclusive, and a more vibrant and thriving neighbourhood that strengthens the heart of the city.”

Part of the argument for new student housing is that it frees up homes around the city in multiple occupation.

The spokesperson said: “The student housing proposals will also help to free up some of the flats occupied by 27,000 students according to Edinburgh University’s latest report on student housing needs.

“That report highlights the continued need to invest in and deliver more and higher quality housing for students alongside investment in mainstream housing.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos