Exclusive

Temporary classrooms costing hard-up councils millions

Councils are spending millions of pounds on temporary classrooms at a time when budgets are under severe pressure. <i>(Image: Damian Shields)</i>
Councils are spending millions of pounds on temporary classrooms at a time when budgets are under severe pressure. (Image: Damian Shields)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Cash-strapped councils are spending millions of pounds on temporary buildings in an attempt to address a lack of capacity in their schools, The Herald can exclusively reveal.

Information secured through the use of Freedom of Information (FOI) requests shows that the majority of local authorities in Scotland are making use of non-permanent or modular structures at their schools.

The body representing Scotland's councils says that it has been lobbying the Scottish Government in an attempt to secure more cash for capital investment.

The Herald recently revealed that despite long-term improvements in the country's school estate, thousands of Scottish pupils are still attending crumbling, unsuitable, and overcrowded schools.

The number of schools not in good condition dropped significantly between 2007 and 2011, and has continue to decline at a slower rate since then; however, around 7.5 percent of the school population – equating to more than 50,000 young people – are still educated in buildings rated as being in ‘poor’ or ‘bad’ condition, and thousands more are sent to schools that are physically secure but not regarded as fit for educational purposes.

In addition, more than 85,000 pupils go to school in buildings that have either reached or even exceeded their planned capacity.


Search our database containing information for every school in Scotland


In an effort to address these issues, some councils have installed temporary or modular structures in some of their schools.

As part of The Herald's investigation, all Scottish local authorities were asked to confirm which schools currently host temporary buildings, how many pupils are accommodated within them, who has provided them, and how much they cost.

The current total cost for all councils is more than £20 million, which is equivalent to the salary of at least 350 teachers. However, the true figure could be significantly higher as some councils failed to provide the requested information.

The councils with the highest temporary building expenses to date are Aberdeen (£2.4m), North Ayrshire (£3.6m), and West Lothian (£3.7m), although in the case of the latter some of the cost is being covered through the contribution of local developers.

The £2.3m bill for Renfrewshire Council includes a spend of more than £1.7m for the purchase of three temporary classrooms at Dargavel Primary School, where botched official calculations left the area short of up to 1,000 pupil places.

Other councils with bills exceeding £1m are East Dunbartonshire (£1.4m), Falkirk (£1.2m), Fife (£1.3m) and Moray (£1.8m).

In its response, Edinburgh Council provided a monthly figure of £26,577.31 for the cost of temporary buildings at 6 schools

A total of seven councils – East Renfrewshire, Inverclyde, Midlothian, Eilean Siar, Perth and Kinross, South Lanarkshire, and West Dunbartonshire – reported that no temporary buildings are in use.


READ MORE


Some councils claimed not to know whether they are using temporary buildings or how much they cost, while others tried to withhold some of the requested information.

Aberdeenshire Council advised that it has temporary units at 20 schools but that it doesn’t know how much this has cost.

North Lanarkshire Council has temporary buildings at 16 schools, providing space for more than 1000 pupils, yet officials claimed that they do not know the cost so far, the expected total cost, and in most cases even the provider of the structures.

South Ayrshire Council said that “modular” buildings have been installed at three nurseries, but claimed that they “do not hold information on temporary installations” beyond this.

Scottish Borders Council responded that it does not know whether temporary buildings are in use or how much is being spent on them, simply stating that it has “no known units on hire for Education purposes.” The council maintained this position even after reviewing its response to the original FOI, but conceded that “there may be value in holding such information about the school estate in the future.”

Fife Council eventually confirmed that it is using 44 temporary buildings across 33 schools, but only provided cost information for four schools, giving a total figure of  £1,134,770.71. For all other schools, officials stated that the data is "not available" because it is not held in a "recorded format."

The response from Highland Council was also in breach of the legal deadline and only arrived after The Herald contacted the council’s press office about this article.

Officials at Glasgow City Council claimed that its “modular” buildings were not covered by the request as they are now permanent fixtures. When told that this was a misinterpretation of the FOI, the council decided to open an entirely new request and is yet to issue a response.

Councils were also asked to confirm the planned removal date for temporary buildings, and the expected total cost of their use at this stage, but in many cases were unable to provide this information. Responses from some councils made clear that total costs are expected to continue rising – for example, East Lothian Council has so far spent £580,000 on two temporary units, but expects this to rise to more than £1m by 2030.

Not all temporary buildings are rented, with various councils including Renfrewshire, Dumfries and Galloway, Moray, and South Lanarkshire confirming that they own a number of units in use across their school estate. In some cases the use of council-owned temporary buildings is long-standing: three of Shetland’s schools currently have ‘temporary’ structures that were installed in the 1970s.

Information provided by councils confirms that the temporary structures currently in use are typically deployed as classrooms, providing space for thousands of young people who cannot be accommodated in the main body of the school: Fife Council alone has temporary buildings with a total capacity of over 1600 pupils.

In some cases, however, the buildings are needed for other purposes, with a number of schools – including Northfield Academy in Aberdeen, Queensferry Primary School in Edinburgh, and St Joseph’s Primary School in Dumfries and Galloway – using them to provide toilet facilities.


READ MORE


In a few cases, councils are making more extensive use of temporary buildings.

For example, St Kentigern’s Academy in West Lothian currently has a pair of two-storey units providing a dining and assembly hall, changing rooms, four music classrooms, four music practice rooms, and 2 graphic design rooms. In addition to this, another single-story unit provides four individual classrooms and a multi-purpose space for us to 60 pupils.

Falkirk Council has a total of nine temporary buildings in use at Maddison Primary School, which is currently being rebuilt after major construction flaws were discovered.

The company most commonly cited by councils as a provider of temporary buildings is Portakabin, but others have been sourced from firms including Sibcas, RB Farquhar, Elliots, Wernock, Modular UK, and Jarvie.

Responding to The Herald's findings, Scottish Conservative education spokesperson Miles Briggs MSP said that schools "should not be operating under these circumstances" and that "taxpayers should not be shouldering these costs."

He continued: “Given councils with a large number of schools in their area failed to respond taxpayers are likely to be left to foot an even higher bill.

“However, the SNP’s failure to fully provide the support and funding for the school estate has left many councils with little option but to use these buildings.

“Jenny Gilruth should stop focusing on government quangos and provide schools with the resources they need to stop pupils being taught in temporary accommodation going forward.”

Willie Rennie MSP, education spokesperson for the Scottish Liberal Democrats, highlighted the "huge sum of money" involved in the use of temporary school buildings, adding:

"All pupils, staff, and parents in Scotland should know that their school buildings are safe and are kept to the highest possible standards. They also need to be fruitful and productive places to learn.

"For pupils to go a significant proportion of their school lives based out of temporary structures does raise questions about whether they are getting that high quality education that they should be entitled to.

"I would like to see ministers work with councils to identify the schools where this is a persistent problem and to assess what changes to school estates need to be made."

Scottish Labour education spokesperson Paul O’Kane MSP said that the "stark" figures uncovered by The Herald show that "too many kids are being left in limbo by the SNP’s lack of progress upgrading schools."

“Temporary buildings do have a role to play, but these eyewatering sums suggest too many kids are spending too long without a proper classroom.

“The SNP must upgrade Scotland’s schools with the urgency needed and ensure that these projects run on time and minimise disruption for pupils.

 “There has been a vacuum of leadership from the SNP on education and kids are paying the price – but Scottish Labour will step up and give Scotland the education system it deserves.”

A spokesperson for COSLA, which represents Scotland's 32 local authorities, told The Herald that it has been working to secure more money to tackle school quality and capacity:

“COSLA continues to lobby for an increase to the capital budgets made available to local government which have diminished over recent years.

“We have been engaging recently with Scottish Government to improve investment in the school estate and how that links to the wider strategic objectives of local and national Government.”  

In response, a Scottish Government spokesperson said:

"In 2007, just 62.7% of schools were in a good or satisfactory condition. Today 92% of schools are in a good or satisfactory condition, thanks to direct investment from the Scottish Government. 

"The £2 billion Learning Estate Investment Programme has announced 47 projects, benefitting tens of thousands of pupils. This follows the successful £1.8 billion Schools for the Future Programme which delivered 117 school projects. 

"Additionally, the 2026-26 Budget provides Scotland’s councils with record funding of almost £15.7 billion. Scottish Government funding is intended to add to – not replace – councils’ own investment in their schools. School buildings belong to local authorities - who we expect to use funding from central Government to maintain and improve their own school estate." 

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos