Constituency profile

Scottish election area 'most difficult to call' according to pollster

Fort William, in Lochaber. <i>(Image: Colin Mearns)</i>
Fort William, in Lochaber. (Image: Colin Mearns)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

IT has been held by the SNP for the past 15 years but could this be about to change?

The Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch constituency was created for the 2011 election, mainly from the former Ross, Skye and Inverness West seat plus part of Inverness East, Nairn & Lochaber.

The first SNP MSP to win the seat was Dave Thompson.

Kate Forbes replaced him in 2016 and retained it in 2021, with the party increasing its majority over time.

She has been a popular figure in the area, credited for helping drive forward long-delayed plans to replace the crumbling Belford hospital as well as being popular within the business community.

Kate Forbes MSP pictured during an interview with Herald journalist Caroline Wilson (Image: Colin Mearns)

The six candidates vying for the seat are; Andrew Baxter (Liberal Democrats), Helen Crawford (Conservative), Eilidh Munro (SNP), Isla McCay (Labour), John Whitton (Reform UK) and Laùra Hänsler the Alliance to Liberate Scotland.

All of the constituents who spoke to The Herald believe it will be a close contest between the SNP and the Liberal Democrats, a party which once dominated the area.

Charles Kennedy served as the Lib Dem MP for the Ross, Skye and Lochaber constituency (and its predecessor seats) from 1983 until 2015.

Charles Kennedy, who died in 2015. (Image: PA)

The SNP's Drew Hendry had been the favourite to win the Inverness, Skye and West Ross-shire constituency in the 2024 UK general election.

However, Angus Macdonald secured the new seat with a majority of 2,160 votes.

One local man, who is predicting either an SNP or Lib Dem win, said: "The other parties have not much going for them. Reform has a very narrow appeal here.

"The SNP need to put in a lot of work to compensate for losing Kate Forbes.

"She was held in high esteem and rightly so, seen as hard working, smart and full of integrity.

Many believe it will be a fight between the SNP and the Lib Dems (Image: Newsquest)

"The replacement is from the same background and will appeal to the more traditional Highland population."

However, he said the "highly publicised ferry fiasco affecting people here" and "their policy of centralisation to Inverness" could hamper the SNP's efforts to reclaim the seat.

The CalMac ferry 'fiasco' has affected local people in the constituency (Image: Getty Images)

He said: "They [the SNP] hardly bothered to campaign here during the general election, which puts a lot of people off.

"Personality does still count here and we haven't really seen much of the SNP contender.

"The Lib Dems have a very strong party machine and the new candidate comes very much in on Angus MacDonald's coat tails."

He added: "There is no Green candidate so it will be interesting to see where those votes go."

Another local resident said that Andrew [Baxter] "has a wealthy backer."


Read more:


A Lochaber constituent said he wouldn't be voting for the Lib Dems, on the back of historical policies.

He said: "We can’t forget what they did in going in to coalition with the Tories to bring in austerity economics, selling off the post office and reversing their pledge not to impose tertiary education fees as well as opposing Scottish independence.

"So we are not voting for the LibDems."

What issues matter to people in the constituency?

Skye, Lochaber, and Badenoch is characterised by an aging population, with a significant projected rise in residents aged 75+.

While Skye has seen recent growth, the wider area faces a decline in working-age residents.

Kinlochleven in Lochaber (Image: Colin Mearns)

The area has no data zones in the 20% most deprived in Scotland, but faces issues with rural deprivation, with, for example, 6.8% of the population in Badenoch and Strathspey identified as income deprived.

Recent surveys indicate that for many Highland voters, the cost of living, health and social care, and immigration are higher priorities than the question of Scottish independence. A fairly slim majority of people in Highland voted no in the 2014 referendum - 87,739 and 78,069.

"Living here means you pay tourist prices for food, drinks etc," said one Fort William-based constituent.

"Everyone seems to presume it's cheaper to live here than in the cities. It categorically is not.

"Fort William is entirely set up for tourism now.

Fort William, in Lochaber. (Image: Colin Mearns)

"The season has expanded, except the infrastructure isn't there to support it. A call needs to be made on this before the house of cards it all sits on falls.

"Either they take steps to curb the reliance on tourism (my work has tried twice to appoint a manager and failed twice to appoint their preferred candidate because they could not find housing) or they need to propose a plan to expand capacity and infrastructure with proper thought and spending."

He expressed some doubt that funds generated by the new Highland tourist levy would find their way back into local communities.

He said: "Unless something drastic is done, this area will become unrecognisable as well as it being impossible to justify living here."

Professor Sir John Curtice, Britain's leading polling expert, said: "My advice to everybody is that the place that is going to be most difficult to call is the Highlands and Islands.

Professor Sir John Curtice (Image: Agency)

"We saw in Inverness in the Westminster election the most oddball result.

"The Liberal Democrats demonstrated an ability there and to be able to win back the seat they lost in 2015.

"It's no secret that they want to get the seat back [Lochaber].

"It is an area where personal popularity matters. I point out to people Bob Maclennan I think is the only MP who has managed to represent the same constituency uninterruptedly for four different political parties.

"That does mean none of us know.

"I think certainly the fact that Kate isn't standing will make life more difficult for the SNP.

"It depends how strong the Liberal Democrat's ground campaign is and how embedded he is in the community because those are the kinds of things that matter in that part of the world.

"My understanding is that the Lib Dems are pushy and they've pushed Angus [MacDonald] before. It's the kind of thing that people like myself should just admit, we don't know.

"The two parties who probably can do most damage to the SNP's electoral prospects if there is a significant change in the current polling, it's not Reform and it's not Labour, it's the Liberal Democrats and the Conservatives because it's the Lib Dems and the Conservatives who have the local strength."

Prof Curtice said it's possible that voters will go for the SNP on the strength of Kate Forbes' popularity.

"In the Highlands yes, very definitely, always been true," he said.

"Why I think the Liberal Democrats can do so well in that territory is that they are able to pick up the idea that we stand up for the periphery of Scotland."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos