Entering Castle Huntly Open Estate certainly doesn’t feel stepping inside a prison.
As I approach the grounds the first thing I notice is that are no high walls, guarded gates, or even particularly conspicuous security cameras. The entrance road passes a sign that feels as though its purpose is to convince people that they really are approaching a prison, followed by a cluster of perfectly normal houses, before coming to a single car barrier which, so far as I can tell, is the only dividing line between the prison grounds and the outside world.
I press a button on the intercom, give my name to the voice on the other end, and then I’m in, following a short one-way system around some buildings and then up onto the hill on which the Castle Huntly itself stands. Having parked in a normal, unsecured car park, I then walk unescorted across the grounds and up to the front door.
Upstairs I meet George Ferguson, the prison governor, and Barrie Simpson, his acting deputy. Both are, as would be expected, knowledgeable and professional, but they also seem open, honest, and genuinely interested in doing their best for the men imprisoned here, who are of course, regardless of their history, now under the care of the staff at Castle Huntly.
First, we clarify a few points about Castle Huntly and its status as an ‘open’ prison. It certainly isn’t the case that those held here are free to come and go as they please, but there is an expectation that prisoners will spend much, if not most, of their time during weekdays off-site. The goal is to help the men through the process of reintegration into society, with learning, employment, and participation in the community at the heart of that process.
Castle Huntly offers a range of support services for those placed there. (Image: Gordon Terris / The Herald) It sounds positive, but coming to the open estate can, I’m told, be the most difficult period of an individual’s time in the prison system, and it’s not uncommon for issues that have been “buried for years” to come to the surface in the first few months. For all that the environment here might look much easier to cope with than a high security setting, it can also present a significant challenge.
“We want people to take responsibility and autonomy,” Mr Ferguson explains. “We’re putting the responsibility onto them, but that’s a big, big change.”
Every prisoner transferred to Castle Huntly has undergone a thorough risk assessment in an attempt to ensure that they can cope, and be trusted, with the freedoms and challenges that they will experience here, and that process continues throughout their time here.
“It’s about giving people chances”, Mr Simpson says.
From there we head back outside and walk down towards the other buildings that make up the site. Our first stop is the Links Centre, which acts as the primary hub for a range of services available to those imprisoned here.
This includes provision to support those struggling with addiction, access to social work, and a significant amount of assistance to help people into work – a step that is considered especially important when preparing people to leave the prison system.
At any given time there are up to 120 placements available, with prisoners able to apply to work with one of around 70 different participating employers; on the day of my visit, the placements noticeboard showed vacancies in areas such as joinery, catering, landscaping, warehousing, maintenance and car valeting.
The Link Centre is where prisoners can access a range of different services and opportunities. (Image: Gordon Terris / The Herald) The Link Centre offers education services to prisoners, although the provision is, I’m told, a bit different from other prisons – largely because, at Castle Huntly, there are far fewer individuals around during working hours on an average day. Nonetheless, in 2023-24, the prison recorded an average of 10.6 qualifications per prisoner, which is by far the highest rate across the entire estate.
In the area set aside for education, a large proportion of the floor and wall space is dedicated to art, which I’m told has traditionally been, and remains, a very popular area of interest for prisoners. Prisoners from Castle Huntly regularly enter the Koestler Awards, and several pieces of work produced here were featured in a 2023 national exhibition of prison-based creative artwork.
While visiting the centre, I also had the chance to speak to Chris, who has spent time in both Kilmarnock and Barlinnie prisons before being approved for transfer to the open estate. He and I are the same age, and grew up not that far away from one another.
Chris tells me that he left school at 15 to go work for his cousin. His time in education hadn’t been a total disaster, although he says that he was certainly a “disruptive” pupil at times. But he doesn’t blame those experiences for him ending up in prison – instead, he wants to use him time here as well as possible.
Chris spends most of his week working: four days are spent at a local golf course, and he also helps at the prison gym.
“It’s like we’ve lost the trust of society,” he tells me, “and here we’re getting a chance to earn it back. If you’re positive about it, you can leave this place a better person, physically and mentally.”
He also talks about his family, and explains that having his children visit him at Castle Huntly, where they aren’t subjected to sounds of heavy doors slamming shut behind them, is “massive” as he works towards his release.
Read more in the series:
-
Revealed: the qualifications achieved by individuals in all Scottish prisons
-
'Children with very negative school experience more likely to end up in jail'
-
Inside Scotland's 'life changing' alternative to jail for women
In addition to the Link Centre, Castle Huntly also has a dedicated Lifeskills unit that, for some, is a vital step in their journey towards release. Participants begin by completing an eight-week, classroom-based course looking at things like budgeting, online shopping, meal planning and more.
At the end of this period, they then move from their usual accommodation into the unit itself, which has dedicated rooms and communal areas that are only accessible to those taking part in the programme. Here, they put their learning into practice, developing and demonstrating skills that they might never have developed before entering the prison system.
This means, for example, planning and cooking meals, and as this is being explained, it is pointed out to me that the kitchen in which they work is just like any other – including the presence of knives. That might seem dangerous, particularly when some of those working through the Lifeskills programme have been imprisoned for knife-related offences, but like everything else at Castle Huntly, when you’re standing in the middle of it, this feels like a complex but perfectly reasonable balancing of risk, reward and reality.
Back outside, standing next to a remembrance garden that is entirely managed by prisoners who have been part of the armed forces, Governor George Ferguson tells me that, for those who come there, Castle Huntly is supposed to be the last, and “probably the most important”, part of their journey, and one where the whole focus is on getting back “back into the community".
Art programmes are popular at Castle Huntly and prisoners' work has been entered for competitions and exhibitions. (Image: Gordon Terris / The Herald) And then the visit was over, and it was time for me to get back in my car and head back to Glasgow. While driving I thought Chris and his kids, and some of the other stories I’d heard about prisoners who had been successfully helped back into society.
But then I started thinking about numbers.
Castle Huntly holds fewer than 200 prisoners – the average in 2023-24 was 161 – which makes it one of the smallest prisons in Scotland, but that makes sense. In fact, during my visit I very much got the feeling that this model works because it is operated on a small scale, which allows for far more holistic, meaningful engagement and support.
There are other numbers we could add to the equation. Holding people here costs less than the alternatives, and Castle Huntly’s success rate for former inmates remaining out of prison is approaching 90 percent.
But the number I just couldn’t, and still can’t, get over is this: one.
That is the number of open prisons like Castle Huntly in the whole of Scotland, and I cannot for the life of me understand why that is the case.
Share