Time for a radical shift in attitudes to the licensed trade

Should licensing laws be standardised across Scotland? <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Should licensing laws be standardised across Scotland? (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

I NOTE an excellent article by Annie Scott on our restrictive licensing laws ("Restrictive Scottish licensing laws are strangling our pubs and clubs and urgent action is needed", The Herald, December 31). We’ve lost the whole principle of alcohol licensing and forgotten it’s about selling alcohol responsibly, in safe, clean and well-controlled premises. All other aspects of alcohol consumption that may lead to criminal behaviour or alcohol abuse cannot be laid at the door of those who sell alcohol alone.

The lack of police on the beat and the lack of law enforcement they can apply has led to some terrible scenes on our streets. This is not the fault of licensees.

Various governments have tried to appease the anti-alcohol lobby whilst trying to protect the enormous revenue stream the Treasury and the economy earn from the licensed trade in Scotland.


Read the col now: Time for a radical shift in attitudes to the licensed trade


Like so many issues nowadays we treat the symptoms, not the root causes. Licensing laws should be standardised across Scotland. There is no reason why one business in Postcode X should be treated differently from Postcode Y. Let the market dictate when the owners wish to open or close. Let the owners decide if they want to invest in outside areas and the like.

This is the case for almost every other type of retail business, so why not licensed premises? Over the past 25 years we have experienced a dramatic shift in the growth of café bars and food-led pubs. The days of huge pubs selling only alcohol have almost disappeared.

A vibrant, exciting, safe nightlife is what attracts tourists to our cities as much as anything else. Don’t let poor legislation prevent this.

Simplification is essential, uniformity would help. Accepting and adapting to market forces is the role of business. Helping businesses grow and raise revenue for the Treasury is the Government’s role.

Let’s get back to basics please.

John Gilligan, Past Chairman of the Scottish Licensed Trade Association, Ayr.


Read more letters


Alba flourishing despite sad loss

I READ Andrew Learmonth's piece ("Can Alba survive without founder Salmond?", The Herald, December 31) with interest – the headline might have somewhat misled people as overall I thought the article was positive and an accurate reflection of how hard Alba has worked to keep key issues in focus whilst unionist parties engage in meaningless slogans and sound bites.

We were the first to seize upon the so-called tough decision of Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves to strip pensioners of the winter fuel allowance, a petty and mean-minded action if there ever was one, and as you mention, one of Alex Salmond's last acts was to encourage the Fannings of Coatbridge to take their case against both governments. You rightly highlight Ash Regan's cross-party Holyrood achievement on prostitution though she also took the very courageous stand over gender self-ID and joined our ranks. And at Westminster Neale Hanvey was flying the flag for both independence and sex-based rights and Kenny MacAskill has been in solidarity with the unions over Grangemouth since day one.

So in summary it appears that it's Alba that is keeping vital issues in the limelight. We will always miss the larger than life, hugely talented politician we were lucky enough to work so closely with: a man who could see the political game six steps ahead of everyone else like an athlete who "sees space" and knows where the ball will be before it gets there, or a chess player thinking several moves ahead, but that is our inspiration and our raison d'etre. Like Moses and Martin Luther King, he led us to the mountaintop where we could glimpse the Promised Land; he may not be getting there with us but he is in our hearts and we will get there soon.

Marjorie Thompson, Alba NEC member, Edinburgh.

• THE anti-trans sect Alba will wither away, though whether that is a good thing depends on what causes that. If Alba's gender fundamentalism, where women are reduced to their genitals and 150 years of feminist theory and struggle ignored, continues to be rejected by voters then great; but if Alba's tiny support base is outflanked by even more fundamentalists in Nigel Farage's Reform UK then clearly that will be a dire result for Scotland.

Brian Dempsey, Dundee.

Dangerous times in our politics

REPORTS that Reform UK is rapidly increasing its membership and electoral support in Scotland, if accurate, undermine the view that Scots are more left-wing and less susceptible to right-wing populism than the UK population generally ("Reform UK membership jumps 10% in Scotland as party aims to overtake Labour, The Herald, December 24).

What is even more surprising is that a party funded by domestic billionaires, and perhaps in the near future foreign billionaires, can pose as anti-elite and the voice of ordinary people. A party led by an individual who courts, and is in turn courted by, a US president-elect who is a convicted felon, and someone who attempted to overthrow his country's constitution.

No doubt the reasons for Reform's rise are complex but it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that its policies and its leader have hardly been subject to intense scrutiny over the years. (This of course applies also to its previous iteration, the UK Independence Party, Ukip). It is widely held for example that a necessary reform of the British political system relates to electoral reform. Does this party think that allowing foreign plutocrats to fund political parties represents a democratisation of the electoral process?

One of the biggest, most radical, changes (or reforms) of the post-war period has been the UK's withdrawal from the EU. This is widely regarded as disastrous, yet right-wingers are allowed to get away with glib statements about not yet taking advantage of "Brexit freedoms". This get out of jail card on Brexit is not helped by the Labour Government's craven position on the issue.

This is a dangerous moment in British and Scottish politics. People who reject the politics of division and who refute the view that the country's long decline, evident over decades, is all down to immigration must see it as such.

Brian Harvey, Hamilton.

Alba is facing up to life without Alex SalmondAlba is facing up to life without Alex Salmond (Image: PA) Rugby referees have faith in SRU

I NOTE your recent report ("Scottish amateur rugby referees are walking away from the game", heraldscotland, October 30), which references an article in Scottish Rugby News. As President of the Scottish Rugby Referees’ Association I acknowledge a well-researched article with what looks like an impressive range of sources. However I feel compelled to challenge some aspects of these reports.

The point about "death threats" implies this happens regularly. This is misleading, with serious episodes extremely rare. I am not complacent about incidents and obviously we could all do without them, but the evidence does not suggest any significant increase in recent times.

The relationship between referees and the vast majority of clubs up and down the country is mutually forgiving and rewarding. I think that if coaches, players and spectators acquainted themselves with the Playing Charter and Spirit of the Game sections within the Laws, the incidence of misunderstandings would reduce. In addition all should recognise that the average referee on a Saturday or Sunday does not appear "equipped" with two assistant referees, a fourth official to regulate substitutions, a timekeeper and a television match official. Referees remain key to facilitating players to achieve their aims and in promoting and fostering the values of the game, and I commend their role as a worthwhile pursuit for anyone with an interest in rugby.

As an association, we believe that most match officials have every confidence in the SRU’s disciplinary process. Association representatives meet periodically with SRU discipline staff to exchange ideas and discuss concerns.

The number of referees moving on is broadly comparable with, perhaps even lower than, previous seasons. Many of these experienced people stay connected to the game, becoming club volunteers and even coaches.

I do not believe there is any complacency in referee societies or at the SRU, with the average referee more than competent, and the development pathway as strong as I can remember it.

David McNair, Bearsden.

• YOU report serious abuse of rugby referees.

His playing days over, a friend took up refereeing rugby matches and was assigned to an Ayrshire local derby which turned out to be more than vigorous and involved several controversial decisions. Meeting the home club's chairman after the match, my friend was invited to have a cup of tea. Explaining that he had to get up the road, said friend was told: "That's the best decision you've made all afternoon."

Perhaps the good old days did have something to be said for them.

David Miller, Milngavie.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos