There is no option with Kanye West but to separate art from artist

How do you solve a problem like Kanye West? <i>(Image: AP)</i>
How do you solve a problem like Kanye West? (Image: AP)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Can you separate the art from the artist? Why this remains a discussion is a mystery.

Yes, you can. And yes, you should. Separate it all from the imperfect hands of its creator. Take from flawed humanity the creation from whence it came. Conflating artist into art in the age of hyper-information, of public and direct communication, is a fool's errand of heartbreak and naivety.

This topic reared its ugly head yet again when Kanye West dived into an extended Hitler-loving tirade, again. Every line he was looking to cross, he crossed it. This time, however, felt different, where even the most hardcore of supporters conceded that the excuses and defences for the formerly talented but now creatively washed rapper and producer had finally run out. The crash out is loud, stunning, and desperately sad.

But, as much as the art he makes reflects his ego, the separation between this person and what they have produced remains, still. The ethical and moral transgressions of West as a person cannot change the history that has taken place, the context in which it took place, or any former artistic glories. The “but he made Graduation” meme is so popular because it stands as the only feasible response to be reasonably mounted as some sort of defence for all this heinous behaviour. 

Read more:

Architects hate acclaimed film The Brutalist… who cares what they think?

Everyone’s relationship to art is different, and the ways we engage with it are vast and numerous and tailored to our own sensibilities. It is not difficult for me to wrap my head around enjoying and finding value in the work of the serial killer rapper or the church-burning extreme metaller. What an interesting place to create from, whether I question and judge the life decisions of those creators or not. Why a refusal to engage when the arts offer a convenient safe space to handle such toxic, dangerous people?

And that does not serve as a reflection of belief, nor does it alter any sense of self. It seems weak-willed, pathetic perhaps, to be so swayed or influenced by an artist and their work to where any of that is shaken. Any fan of West who allows the far-right to infect their soul because of his nitrous oxide-fuelled ramblings is obviously an idiot.

Go into the arts from before the age of global information, the painters and writers of centuries past. Forget it. Figures of art history are hopelessly stuck in moral quandary, their work recontextualised into the standards of now. Not only do we know a lot more about those living but also those of the past, as more of their biography and story and how they were as people come to light and become re-assessed.

A titan of twentieth-century art, Pablo Picasso, was known for abusing his partners, his muses, and the other women in his life. That this biographical aspect is now assessed and put into focus is vital for establishing what standards should be expected, from artists, from men to women, from human to fellow human.

However, there is room for separation between this repulsive aspect of the personal and what Guernica means as an anti-war statement born from the Spanish Civil War. The painting exists outside Picasso’s slimy hands, and thankfully so.

Guernica, Pablo Picasso's 1937 anti-war statement (Image: Museo Nacional Centro de Arte Reina Sofía) As rightfully as we strive to rid ourselves of the immoral or the unethical, it is strange to assume art created by its instigators should by proxy be silenced or go unconsidered.

It is valid and not necessarily a suspicious comment on character to assess, and even enjoy, an artist who behaves outside of our own moral framework. Depending on one’s own disposition, that moral framework differs, shifts, and is rife with contradiction. It’s not a very effective way of seeing the creation before us and making a rational and sound judgement, that can have the nuance of acknowledging the real-life context with what’s put in front of us.

An approach to art that fundamentally operates from a moral or ethical basis is inherently limiting. It is an emotional reaction, dependent on the transgression perceived and our personal relationship to that transgression. And sometimes that is a completely fine basis to operate from. If our personal relationship to a particular transgression effects the relationship of the subject and the source, then refusing to engage in that instance makes sense. There is no real pressure in that regard.

Read more:

‘Think of all the great art we’ll get from a Trump win…’

But the issue lies in dictating and controlling that freedom to engage with art created by nefarious figures, that the process should in any way be restricted. The sins of the artist and their work should not be transferred to those who choose to engage with it in a long-winded game of guilt by association. This only serves to reduce the pool of artistic consideration to an arbitrary standard and contributes to a monoculture where the safest and blandest survive and thrive.

West has never been shy in revelling in people's anger, of being intentionally off-putting and divisive. It has contributed to his own mythology, his artistic character. It has contributed to his reputation as an early creative genius of the twenty-first century. Clearly, that time is over, and what we are left with is the sad scene of pining for former glories. But you do not have to allow the problematic creator to take all those beautiful creations away from you. It no longer belongs to them.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos