Rosemary Goring ("Make drivers of monstrous SUVs pay for pothole repairs", The Herald, April 12) makes a compelling argument about the alleged damage to roads caused by SUV-type cars.
However, I think that she has failed to consider the effects of all really large road vehicles from tractors, which she does mention, to buses and heavy multi-axle trucks and very large articulated vehicles that include long multi-axle trailers.
During my working life I often had to drive on our motorway network and noticed that the nearside and middle lanes (of three-lane motorways south of the Border) had a set of two double grooves or ruts worn into the road surface. These were caused by the double tyres of the wheels of trucks and buses, not cars.
On rural and suburban roads over a number of years, roads when being resurfaced have, on and near bends, had an application of a so-called anti-skid material. This acts like an industrial sandpaper. When HGVs and buses travel around these surfaces the double tyres on each rear wheel grinds this surface and it does eventually, but sooner rather than later, break up the road surface underneath. Large potholes occur and on one occasion the car that I was driving hit one of these at low speed and £558 later I had a new spring and shock absorber and tyre. This made me look more closely at this type of road surface and the evidence is there to be seen.
Near where I live there are a number of farms and one in particular has three entrances onto the main road. If time is taken to look at the road, it can be seen that the bulk of the damage to the road surface has been caused by tractors and other heavy vehicles turning on to the main road and the grinding effect of the tyres has dug into the Tarmac and opened up the surface, creating potholes enlarged over a few winters by frost damage.
I'm sure that SUVs and heavier EVs have contributed as Ms Goring says, but not to the extent that she implies.
Ian Gray, Croftamie.
Read more letters
• Rosemary Goring makes the case that since SUVs are heavier than the average car they cause more damage to roads and should pay more tax. But SUVs are not a significant cause of damage to roads.While a heavier axle load does have an increased impact on the road structure, the relationship is not linear, it is exponential. The impact on the road is proportional to the fourth power of the axle load. So a vehicle with twice the axle weight has 16 times the impact.
The typical axle weight of an SUV is around 20% greater than for other cars which, in terms of impact on the road, is about double that of a standard car.
In contrast, a single HGV axle typically carries around 10 to 15 times the weight of a car axle and, by the fourth power law, a fully-loaded HGV has more than 10,000 times the impact on the road compared to a car axle.
All passenger cars, including SUVs, are very light in terms of axle load and cause minimal road damage.
It should also be noted that the principle for the tax charged to a vehicle to be linked to that vehicle's impact on the road is already established. Vehicle Excise Duty for HGVs increases with the weight of the vehicle.
George Rennie, Inverness.
• I fully support Rosemary Goring's appeal for stronger measures against the huge and dangerous vehicles taking over our streets and causing damage to roads, pavements and people. Many are too big to park in our standard spaces, and elevated drivers have limited sight of vulnerable pedestrians and cyclists from on high. Those that aren't electric are belching unnecessary emissions. How are they now 33% of all car registrations ?
Taxing them highly in whatever ways are practical along with strong publicity for the reasons why would add shame and embarrassment that might also restrain their uptake in the way that Elon Musk's enthusiasm for Donald Trump has cut the sale of Teslas.
Susan Lane, Edinburgh.
Scotching the myths
I agree wholeheartedly with Alan Fitzpatrick’s disdain for the ridiculous so-called "tasting notes" that afflict most Scotch whiskies these days (Letters, 12 April). Most of the flavours mentioned can not possibly be present in whisky and it is pretentious – not to say deceitful – to claim otherwise.
I was born and raised a mile from the The Glenlivet distillery, and served my compulsory apprenticeship in whisky tasting at an early age and in scarcely legal circumstances. After eight decades of practice, my maxim these days is simple; don’t let anyone try to tell you what your dram is going to taste like, just enjoy it for what it is. Also, life is too short for blended whisky.
Iain Stuart, Glasgow.
Are whisky tasting notes pretentious? (Image: PA)
When Science meets Arts
Recent correspondence on the inclusion of Psychology as a university course of study (Letters, April 8, 10 & 12) has prompted my memory.
As an Arts undergraduate at Edinburgh (1960-64) I had to include a Science subject in my Arts degree. I chose Psychology. It was also chosen by Science students as an Arts subject. I attended Professor Dreever's lectures alongside my then boyfriend (later husband) with us each wearing our different undergraduate hats.
A versatile subject, indeed.
Olive Bell, Dunbar.
For the love of dogs
Keith Swinley's moving, elegiac letter about the family dog (April 14) brings memories of the late R Russell Smith's letter in which he described how he aspired to be the sort of person his dog thought he was.
As I write, eight-year-old Ruby stares eagerly, awaiting arrival of her loving dog-walker. Age brings lack of mobility to dog owners, too.
David Miller, Milngavie.
Give us back our Oysters
The humble ice cream Oyster shell has disappeared from ice-cream vendors' menus. I have visited several only to be disappointed and have to settle for a plain cone. It is not good enough I say, and they agree. Who do I write to? Well there is one obvious very famous snowball manufacturer who has all the ingredients for Oyster shells.
Please, please, Mr Tunnock, can you save the day and help our national ice cream delicacy? Some nougats too if you can – or is that a wafer too far?
Denise Brown, Stewarton.
Share