John McLellan

Edinburgh needs Scottish Government support if trams are to expand

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.
Close Icon

What is the Public Notice Portal?

The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.

Search the Public Notice Portal

Put down the placards, close the petitions, bring out the bunting: the Battle of Roseburn is won. The only part of the pipe dream to expand the Edinburgh tram network that minimised disruption will be ditched because not enough councillors approve.

When the scheme to run a spur from the current single line from Roseburn to Granton along the old railway track bed comes up for a decision next month, it is widely accepted that the campaign to preserve the route as a cycle path and walkway has been successful, to the delight of the Lib Dems and, oddly, the SNP, both of whom backed the opposition.

With the Conservatives objecting on justifiable cost grounds, and the Greens confused if it does not come with a keffiyeh or a trans rights sticker, the issue has come down to straightforward local pork-barrel politics, at which the Lib Dems and SNP are past masters, with parties supportive of tram expansion in principle turning their backs on what is easily the most deliverable element of the entire network.

The Roseburn Path has been clearly marked in the Local Development Plan as protected for a tram route, not wood pigeons and foxes, since it was included in the original legislation 20 years ago. As veteran rail campaigner and former Labour councillor Lawrence Marshall pointed out this week, the path preservation campaign is a relatively new phenomenon, rising in parallel with the militancy of environmental and “active travel” campaigning.


Read more:


For any councillor to recommend, as the SNP group does, that the city back the hideously expensive and entirely unnecessary alternative of putting a track across the historic Dean Bridge and down Orchard Brae is, frankly, a dereliction of what should be a duty, on pain of disqualification, to protect the public purse. If SNP councillors sincerely believe residents should foot what could easily be an extra £1 billion for that option, then their members should replace every single one of them at next year’s election with candidates who are serious about the public interest.

Unusual though it may be for me to agree with ex-Labour group leader Cammy Day, he had a point this week when he argued that a tram link from Granton to the rest of the city was an important part of the vision for a new district built around parkland on the old gasworks site and the new gallery depositories, to which it is hoped thousands of new flat-dwellers will be drawn. Such is the housing shortage that they will still arrive, but its attractiveness, and therefore the marketability of the market-priced homes, will be diminished.

But there is no escaping the basic fact that the city does not have the money, and it never will until the Scottish Government recognises that investing in demand in Edinburgh is an essential element of a national strategic plan. It will take a departure from the previous position of regarding transport projects within the city boundary as purely local schemes, which the council alone should fund, to accept that Edinburgh’s growth is an economic priority for the whole of Scotland. The same can be said for transforming Glasgow Airport’s Third World transport connections.

It therefore remains a contradiction, best explained by a seat-by-seat approach to electoral tactics earlier this year, the old pork barrel again, that the Scottish Government seems to have no qualms about funding a detailed feasibility study into the tram-train expansion of the system along the South Suburban line, which is still in use for rail freight.

Described as a breakthrough, Transport Scotland will work with Network Rail on the basis that it will help produce a wider examination of public transport demand across the South East, something that is long overdue, particularly given the poor connections for the housing estates currently being thrown up in East Lothian.

'The only part of the pipe dream to expand the Edinburgh tram network that minimised disruption will be ditched because not enough councillors approve' (Image: Agency)

One significant development, although it creates new headaches, is the reluctant acceptance by campaigners behind the tram-train concept that crossing the main railway line at Murrayfield to hook up with the existing tram line heading into the city centre is a non-starter.

Instead, it is suggested that the trams follow the westward spur where the line splits at Gorgie and feed into the tram system at a new junction at Stenhouse Drive, where the tram line lies south of the railway, having crossed from the north side over a bridge at Carricknowe Golf Club.

It would allow travellers from south Edinburgh to take a tram from, say, Morningside to Edinburgh Park and on to the airport, but would need the construction of about a mile of new track alongside the railway through Balgreen. The cost of that element alone would leave little change out of £200 million.

It might be nice for Southsiders flying off on a weekend city break, but there must be serious question marks over how much demand there would be for such a service. Then again, the game changer might be the transformation of Edinburgh Gateway and its tram interchange into a proper east-west rail station like Haymarket. As I have argued here before, all that is needed is for Network Rail to build the Almond Chord, a short stretch of track just north of Kirkliston, and all sorts of possibilities open up.

It is not so much the tram-train feasibility study that matters, but the wider examination of regional transport demand and the need to carry that forward into a coherent vision for the capital region that the Scottish Government buys into, on paper anyway.

But while the SNP at Holyrood stares into a £5bn black hole for which, according to Auditor General Stephen Boyle this week, it has no detailed plan to fill, investing more in transport infrastructure is a non-starter while ministers work out how to meet a spiralling welfare bill that they have repeatedly prioritised.

Higher taxes are only a question of by how much, not if, and there is more chance of pigs flying into Turnhouse than of trams to the Royal Infirmary or tram-trains to the airport. Now, when is the next bus to Granton?


John McLellan is a former Edinburgh Evening News and Scotsman editor, now director of the Scottish news publishing trade association, Newsbrands Scotland. Brought up in Glasgow, McLellan has lived and worked in Edinburgh for over 30 years, and was a City of Edinburgh councillor for the Scottish Conservatives from 2017-22

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos