As investigators and loss adjusters prowl round the charred remains of the Debenhams' store on Edinburgh’s Princes Street, it was initially thought only to be a matter of processing the paperwork before the building was declared kaput.
But no, it appears now that the Grade B listed façade can be saved and it’s just a question of propping it up and everything can get back to approaching normality. Similarly, more of the interior can be preserved, with the old staircase and stained glass window intact.
Glad tidings for the Cockburn Association and lovers of Victoriana, but whether it’s such great news for everyone else rather depends on taste and fear of the unknown of what might have replaced it – plans for replacing the West Port’s ugly Argyle House, for example, will divide opinion.
Council insiders insist there was no choice but to make every effort to save the Debenhams building, and that’s probably fair, but the need to work around delicate listed features certainly complicates the project. But no-one is going to shed a tear if it costs the current owner, billionaire property tycoon Asif Aziz, a few bob more to turn it into Scotland’s first Zedwell hotel. And paper hankies won’t be required if he sells up and his company, Criterion Capital, achieves a lower price than might have been achieved from a vacant site.
Read more
- Historic building on Edinburgh’s Princes Street gutted by fire
- Scotland betrayed once more by Scottish Labour and their supine 'leader' Sarwar
- Ann Widdecombe's death exposes a toxic intolerance towards Christian beliefs
Ownership and sale price aside, to get the site back into profitable use as quickly as possible, it might have been better had the whole building burnt to the ground; after all, it’s not as if it was an architectural treasure much loved by locals and visitors alike and most people are looking at the other side of the street as they walk by. Glasgow’s School of Art it is not, yet more of the Debenhams’ interior looks set to be restored than at the Rennie Mackintosh masterpiece.
For now the engineers are in to work out how to support the frontage, and when the propping up is done and the hoardings are in place, maybe Princes Street will look as “fantastic” as Glasgow’s Central Station, as an upbeat Deputy First Minister Jenny Gilruth described it after her visit to the scene of the Union Street fire this week.
In fairness, even a devastating blaze can’t make that part of Glasgow worse so the loss of the landmark dome aside, it’s an opportunity for something exciting. Meanwhile, that stretch of Edinburgh’s most famous highway will probably resemble the shambolic George IV Bridge hotel renovation for years to come.
As for the transport network, it took weeks for trains from Central to get back to normal, and it looks like the Festival season could be over before Edinburgh’s engineers are satisfied the façade won’t topple and tram and bus services can resume. Weeks, not months, say insiders, but it still means buses and coaches snaking their way round from Charlotte Square to Frederick Street along George Street, and it poses legitimate questions about the long-term implications of pedestrianising George Street if it’s the main relief route should other problems arise.
The issue was raised by Conservative group leader councillor Iain Whyte in a recent column in the Edinburgh Evening News, but the city’s Labour leader Jane Meagher went on the offensive, complaining that “people view this as an opportunity to score cheap political points.” Apart from making political points being what politicians do, it hardly seems unreasonable to ask what might happen in similar circumstances if there were significant changes to the way Edinburgh’s city centre road network operates. The £35 million (April 2025 prices) George Street revamp which would limit road capacity is currently on hold because councillors voted against spending tourist tax revenue on the project, but it is not dead.
Neither is the City Mobility Plan, with its vision of reducing cross-city bus journeys on Princes Street, so what is being experienced now is a taste of what might happen in adjacent streets, like Queen Street, if bus access was reduced. But as has too often been the case in the past, the council leadership’s response to valid scrutiny of transport policy is sticking fingers in their ears and shouting climate change, active travel, la la la.
One of the most repeated claims from Edinburgh Council’s political leaders is that lessons were learnt from the first tram debacle and that the completion of the delayed three-mile line from York Place to Newhaven for £207 million set new standards for public infrastructure investment.
Read more
- Edinburgh in August: Five festivals, thousands of shows. Which 10 do you have to see?
- Discovering the new Clyde Riviera: 20 places you need to visit 'doon the watter'
- No holds barred take on the Scot who inspired Robinson Crusoe will shock some readers
Less so the subsequent management, with the former Edinburgh Trams’ managing director Lea Harrison being handed a £327,000 severance package in January this year, after the tram and buses management were merged, on top of his regular £187,000 annual salary and benefits.
Apart from the fact the budget rose from £160 million from when the decision to press ahead was taken, and that the hardware and rolling stock has already been bought, it was indeed a surprise that the budget appeared to have been hit, virtually to the penny.
Now there appears to be some mystery over “stabling” facilities over an extra 60 metres of track beyond the Newhaven terminus, secure storage for trams if they couldn’t return to the Gogar depot, and an amenity block for crews. The track was laid but the facilities never built, the space “descoped” in April 2024 and seeded over instead.
Officers insist the cost of the facilities was not included in the £207 million budget and was for the tram operator to build if it was deemed necessary, but if Edinburgh taxpayers have paid for something which has not been delivered, they need to know. The next transport committee is not until September 10, so there is time to erect a fence and drop off a couple of Portaloos.
But maybe it’s not enough time to come up with a plausible excuse for handing the old MD a golden handshake worth nearly two years’ money, apart from a ludicrously well-upholstered contract.
John McLellan is a former Edinburgh Evening News and Scotsman editor, now director of the Scottish news publishing trade association, Newsbrands Scotland. Brought up in Glasgow, McLellan has lived and worked in Edinburgh for over 30 years, and was a City of Edinburgh councillor for the Scottish Conservatives from 2017-22
Share