In the wake of the brutal murder of Charlie Kirk, the war on free speech threatens democracy and freedom on both sides of the Atlantic, writes Herald columnist Mark McGeoghegan.
Charlie Kirk was many things. He was a misogynist who called on women to “submit to your husband”. He was a racist who opposed the US Civil Rights Act that ended racial segregation, and said of Michelle Obama that she did “not have the brain processing power to be taken seriously – you have to go steal a white person’s slot.” He was a far-right firebrand who made a litany of outrageous and reprehensible statements throughout his life, from endorsing stoning homosexuals as “God’s perfect law” to advocating the use of “lethal force” against immigrants.
He was also a champion of free speech. As much as he supported his own right to say these things and advocate policies that most of us would find atrocious, he supported the rights of others to hold the polar opposite view, even if he loathed that view. I don’t say that to paint Mr Kirk as a paragon of virtue, far from it, but to point out the incredible, if unsurprising, hypocrisy of MAGA Republicans who are exploiting his horrific assassination to justify cracking down on the American left and to silence their opposition.
Free speech is under attack on both sides of the Atlantic. That is a reality that anyone opposed to the rising tide of authoritarianism in the collective West should recognise.
Read more:
- Israel is out of control – and the West is to blame
- The far right may try - but they won't manage to steal the Saltire
- Scotland can't afford to continue without local government reform
- Is independence possible in Donald Trump’s new world order?
The latest wave of crackdowns in the US has seen government, university, and even some private sector employees fired for quoting Mr Kirk’s own words on social media. Jimmy Kimmel has been taken off-air “indefinitely” after the Chair of the US Federal Communications Commission, Brendan Carr, threatened broadcaster ABC over Mr Kimmel’s criticisms of President Trump’s response to Mr Kirk’s assassination. Mr Carr had previously, in 2023, characterised such censorship as “the authoritarian’s dream”.
Guest-hosting Mr Kirk’s podcast earlier this week, Vice President J.D. Vance interviewed President Trump’s Deputy Chief of Staff, Stephen Miller, about his plans to channel the anger generated by Mr Kirk’s assassination to “uproot and dismantle these terrorist networks”, by which he meant left-wing think tanks, NGOs, and other organisations. As the Democratic Governor of California, Gavin Newsom, pointed out, Mr Miller has routinely characterised the Democratic Party as one such “terrorist” organisation.
Mr Miller’s pronouncements are chilling, but should not be surprising. President Trump’s war on free speech did not begin after the assassination of Mr Kirk. It started as soon as he won the 2024 Presidential Election and has progressed throughout the first year of his second term. He has sued media companies for billions for opposing him in that election, has used antitrust law to bring American big business to heel, has intimidated American universities and used the threat of withdrawing federal funding to force them to fire staff and change curricula, and has had foreign students grabbed off the streets by masked federal agents for writing in their school newspaper.
This is the new authoritarian playbook, one we have seen play out across other nations governed by self-styled strongman leaders, like Russia, Hungary, and Turkey. In President Trump’s America, free speech is absolute up to the point that you disagree with him or his cronies. Mr Kirk’s assassination merely offered up a perfect excuse to accelerate through that playbook.
This should concern us greatly in the UK. Political trends that start in the US increasingly find their way across the Atlantic, and the weaponisation of free speech is no different. We are currently where the US was a few years ago. The far right claim to be the defenders of free speech against an oppressive state, but when you examine those they hold up as martyrs, like the confessed criminal Lucy Connolly, it becomes clear that the only right they want to defend is their own to inspire violence and attack those they see as their enemies.
Let’s remind ourselves of what Ms Connolly wrote, as crowds attacked hotels housing asylum seekers across England: “Set fire to all the fucking hotels full of the bastards for all I care.” Nigel Farage might present himself to American Congressional Committees as a devotee of Voltaire, but he has little interest in defending speech he disagrees with while standing in the corner of people whose incitement to violence is so blatant that even Charlie Kirk would struggle to defend it as legitimate free speech.
Where the right to free speech was once a unifier across the mainstream of British politics, undergirding our democracy and way of life, it has become a polarising, partisan football as that mainstream has collapsed. Instead of understanding freedom of speech as an inalienable but not unlimited right, to be exercised responsibly in balance with other rights, growing flanks of the British body politic view their own speech as something they have an unrestricted right to and the speech of their opponents as something to be controlled and, ultimately, stamped out.
It would be easy to “both sides” this issue. After all, ‘cancel culture’ originated on the left, and there are pockets of the online left that celebrated Mr Kirk’s assassination. In the words of his alleged assassin, “I had enough of his hatred. Some hate can’t be negotiated out.”
But the reality is that it is not the left that is responsible for the crackdowns on free speech we are currently witnessing in the US, but the far right. It is not the British left that wants to withdraw us from the European Convention on Human Rights and scrap the Human Rights Act. And on neither side of the Atlantic have left-leaning governments used the power of the state to oppress their opponents in recent years, regardless of the absurd claims that Ms Connolly was a “political prisoner”. Being held accountable for criminal acts is not, in fact, state repression.
No body politic can survive without a shared understanding of the rights we enjoy and the duties we owe. The far right is at the forefront of eroding that shared understanding, precisely because the erosion of those rights and the dereliction of those duties empower them. If we cannot regain a balanced footing on the question of freedom of speech, a shared understanding of the limits of that right, and mutual respect for each other’s right to free speech as well as our own, we are headed down a very dark, authoritarian path.
Mark McGeoghegan is a Glasgow University researcher of nationalism and contentious politics and an Associate Member of the Centre on Constitutional Change. He can be found on BlueSky @markmcgeoghegan.bsky.social
Share