Mark McGeoghegan

Time to act – Trump’s strategy threatens to fracture Europe

'President Trump’s National Security Strategy is a blueprint for breaking the transatlantic alliance structure' <i>(Image: Matt Rourke)</i>
'President Trump’s National Security Strategy is a blueprint for breaking the transatlantic alliance structure' (Image: Matt Rourke)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

President Trump’s new National Security Strategy is a manifesto for undermining democracy and carving up Europe – it’s time the government acted to protect our interests from our most unreliable ally, writes Herald columnist Mark McGeoghegan.


While it’s most closely associated with Samuel Huntington’s 1993 article in Foreign Affairs, the concept of a clash of civilisations has a long pedigree. Albert Camus used it in 1948 to make a very similar argument to Huntington’s, suggesting – wrongly, as it turned out – that the “Russo-American problem” would soon be superseded by a clash of civilisations between colonised and colonising nations.

That concept now sits at the heart of President Trump’s new National Security Strategy, at least as it pertains to Europe, which the document alleges is on the verge of “civilisational erasure” because of immigration. The Trump Administration “want(s) Europe to remain European”, as it were. But the real clash here isn’t one of civilisations, it’s within Western civilisation, between the authoritarian ethnonationalism of MAGA and European liberal democracy.

All in all, the document is absurd from a European perspective. It pairs pivoting away from Europe with a commitment to reshape Europe in a Trumpian image. It proposes a world of sovereign states while simultaneously looking to interfere in domestic European politics. It is deeply hypocritical, rooted in the tension inherent in trying to couch this dramatic shift in US foreign policy in the language of traditional democratic and liberal values.

Far from a recipe for a peaceful, thriving world, President Trump’s National Security Strategy is a blueprint for breaking the transatlantic alliance structure, ending over 75 years of European integration that has secured peace among the European Union’s member states, and ultimately carving Europe up into spheres of influence between the United States and Russia.

Indeed, the first of the priorities the Strategy sets out for Europe is “re-establishing conditions of stability within Europe and strategic stability with Russia.” As we have seen in the Trump Administration’s recent negotiations with Russia, in practice, that means ending the war in Ukraine on Russia’s terms and leaving Eastern Europe vulnerable to further Russian aggression.


Read more:


The Strategy is highly hostile to the European Union. While it does not explicitly call for the EU to be broken up, its position that the EU is part of the source of Europe’s impending “civilisational erasure” is in line with the views espoused by other right-wing American figures, most notably Elon Musk, who have gone so far as to call the EU the “Fourth Reich” and call for its abolition. Breaking up the EU would be instrumental in carving up Europe, and to another of the Strategy’s priorities: “opening European markets to US goods and services.”

The Strategy’s aims for Europe are to be achieved by “cultivating resistance to Europe’s current trajectory within European nations.” In other words, by directly interfering with European politics to boost far-right movements whose politics and goals align with the Trump Administration’s, circumventing established transatlantic alliances in favour of populism and ethnic nationalism.

There is already a playbook for this kind of political interference, most extensively used by Russia to fracture European unity and sow discord. State-controlled media like RT and Sputnik, fringe websites, social media influencers, and troll farms push narratives and amplify anti-establishment sentiment. Existing, divisive issues are exploited to inflame cultural tensions and increase polarisation. AI-generated images and videos create convincing fake content, such as fabricated videos of politicians accepting bribes or criticising allies, to damage their credibility. A deluge of conflicting opinions is used to drown out reality and foster a general distrust in mainstream media and facts.

All of these tactics, and more, are available to the US to undermine Europe. They can also exert political and financial pressure, funnelling funds to far-right parties and lobbying organisations. We already see US private interests engaging in this behaviour, including funding conservative Christian causes – like anti-abortion protests – through bodies like the ironically titled Alliance Defending Freedom.

If we aren’t careful and reassess how we insulate our democracies from such activities, our supposed closest ally could quickly undermine our social and political cohesion. This evolving dynamic compels European nations, including the UK, to view the US through a lens of scepticism. It now sits, in relation to Europe, somewhere between an unreliable ally and a potential adversary, and we should treat it as such.

Since the start of President Trump’s second term, Sir Keir Starmer has behaved like there will be a return to the status quo of the ‘special relationship’ when that term ends. He has kept his predecessors' policies, hoping to minimise US tariffs, keep the US in NATO, and keep US support for Ukraine. He has continued to position the UK as the leading European military power and a transatlantic bridge to the US.

But President Trump’s National Security Strategy should be the final nail in the coffin for this approach. We cannot rely on the US to help defend the West and its values. US involvement in Europe will be transactional going forward, and not necessarily to the benefit of liberal democracy. Perhaps there will be a return to something like normality once President Trump is out of office, but the experience of swinging from President Trump to President Biden and back should put paid to any sense that such a return would last. We need to quickly dismantle 80 years of dependence on the US, in partnership with our allies on the continent, to avoid becoming isolated and dependent on the whims of American Presidents.

We also must step up and intensify efforts to insulate our politics from foreign interference. The last government and this one have already taken some steps, including new offences for foreign interference, schemes to register foreign agents operating in the UK, and limits on overseas campaign spending. But these steps are not sufficient, as the collapse of the prosecution of two individuals accused of spying on MPs for China proves, as does the continued flow of ‘dark money’ into UK politics.

The government should now act quickly to implement the political finance reform recommendations of Transparency International and the Electoral Commission, particularly a profit test to prevent shell companies from being used to funnel illicit funds into British politics and impose limits on individual donations.

And in Scotland, with a Holyrood election coming up in May, we must steel ourselves for the impact of foreign interference on our own politics and be aware that not every political actor is acting in good faith, or in Scotland’s best interests.


Mark McGeoghegan is a Glasgow University researcher of nationalism and contentious politics, an Associate Member of the Centre on Constitutional Change, and an incoming Research Associate at the Centre for Public Policy. He can be found on BlueSky @markmcgeoghegan.bsky.social

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos