There’s long been a conspiracy of silence at Holyrood. If Vigil’s DI Kirsten Longacre had John Swinney locked in an interview room with a bare light bulb and rubbish coffee, he still wouldn’t sing.
The big issue politicians fret over, exactly when there should be a second independence referendum, has a clear answer which you sense the key players all know but don’t like to say. It’s this: there should only be a vote if and when support for Scottish independence is consistently around 60 per cent.
You can argue about the exact figure, but it’s clear we need to be close to settled-will territory. Support for having a Scottish Parliament was in the mid to late 60s for a long time before there was a referendum in 1997. That delivered an uncontestable result. Support for independence should be around 60 per cent, for an extended period, for two key reasons: because then we would know that people did actually want a vote, making the upheaval and turmoil of a campaign worthwhile; and, secondly, it would be likely to deliver a decisive result.
Unless and until those tests were met, holding a referendum would simply create bitterness and division. For the SNP, a badly timed poll could even be fatal.
The parties all know this, but for their differing reasons, aren’t explicit about it. When Andy Burnham set hares running three weeks ago by seeming to suggest his government would agree to a second referendum if there were majority support for one (before rowing it back), he was giving us a glimpse of Labour’s private thinking. They know that if support for independence reached the high 50s to early 60s over an extended period, blocking a referendum would be both unprincipled and counter-productive. They just don’t want to get drawn into arguments about the exact polling numbers or be seen as soft on the constitutional question.
Read more:
- Pick the right leader, Labour, or we'll have the SNP in power for ever
- Good news for car drivers - here comes the £2 bus fare
- What we need now in Holyrood is grown-up politics, but is anyone listening?
- Scotland's public services are struggling – and you may have to foot the bill
The hints aren’t hard to read though. Last week, Scottish Labour joined with the SNP and Greens to back a motion at Holyrood saying Scotland had the right to decide its own constitutional future. New leader Michael Marra said there had always been a route to another referendum: “Build a consensus – the settled will of the Scottish people – and make it overwhelming.” Being specific about a polling figure would get him into hot water.
This isn’t comfortable territory for the SNP leadership either since admitting that support for independence is far below where it needs to be underlines how distant the prospect of indyref2 actually is. The polls have been stuck at around 50/50 for six years. To admit that support needs to be close to 60 per cent for Yes to feel confident of winning would infuriate impatient activists who want to force the electorate’s hand as quickly as possible, but it’s surely where the SNP would like to be.
John Swinney has always been more interested in growing the Yes vote than plotting unrealistic routes to an ill-timed poll. He came into the role of First Minister two years ago saying that his priority was to “build support for independence”. Alluding to Burnham’s comments, he noted approvingly it was the first time since 2014 that a Prime Minister had admitted there should be a referendum “when it is likely that people would vote for independence”.
This focus on not just wangling a referendum but winning it well may be why he set the bar for a second independence referendum so high going into this year’s Holyrood election. He said a majority of specifically SNP MSPs (without the Greens) should be enough to trigger negotiations on a fresh vote. He knew he’d be unlikely to get it and, you suspect, didn’t really want it. His party’s lacklustre result underlined what he already knew: there’s no public impatience for another referendum.
Even if he could get one, the conditions aren’t right. The Brexit experience may be fading a little in the public consciousness but no sensible SNP leader would want to emulate it. Leave won the vote by a whisker, following a campaign that hugely exaggerated the supposed benefits, none of which have materialised. Poll after poll since 2016 has shown how decisively public opinion has moved against Brexit. The most recent, in June, showed that 65 per cent thought it had badly impacted the economy and 52 per cent thought it had had a negative effect on immigration. Ten years on, the question is still not settled, with more than half the population saying they’d like to revisit the vote.
A Scottish referendum now would be sickeningly divisive because the polls are so close and a campaign might not change the numbers very much. In key ways, the arguments for independence have got harder to make, particularly on defence, due to the worsening global security situation, and the economy, with the SNP’s proposal for EU membership creating the prospect of a trade border between Scotland and England. John Swinney may claim for the cameras that “the moment has now come” for a second referendum, but his tactics tell a different story. He doesn’t want to be the First Minister who wins by a whisker and plunges the country into political gridlock, any more than he wants to be the First Minister who loses a second independence referendum and sets back the cause by a generation. Those are his two options unless support for independence grows substantially.
It should be said that it may never reach 60 per cent. The impact of so-called demographic change, the passing of older, more union-minded voters to be replaced by younger, more pro-independence ones, was much discussed five years ago but was overstated. There’s been no lasting movement in the polls. But that doesn’t mean it would ultimately benefit the independence cause to push for a referendum regardless.
Referendums are a terrible way to decide things, reducing complex questions to almost meaningless binary questions. Have the arguments first to build consensus, then vote later. That’s how a referendum should be run, not the other way round.
It looks increasingly as if, behind the posturing, Holyrood’s key players are of a similar mind: let’s not do this unless we can confidently predict the likely result. That’s the right place to be.
Rebecca McQuillan is a journalist specialising in politics and Scottish affairs. She can be found on Bluesky at @becmcq.bsky.social and on X at @BecMcQ.
Share