Judy Murray’s words on men in women’s sport shame us all

Judy Murray on centre court on day four of the 2024 Wimbledon Championships at the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club, London. <i>(Image: Mike Egerton)</i>
Judy Murray on centre court on day four of the 2024 Wimbledon Championships at the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club, London. (Image: Mike Egerton)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

In the digital age, journalists must exercise a measure of caution when judging the levels of response to their work. We have all learned to discern which subjects and issues are most likely to elicit high volumes of engagement online. This can carry a risk of reducing the range and depth of the subjects we choose to address.

This is why, for instance, I have always admired and valued the work of my Herald colleagues Mark Smith and Alison Rowat, who often chivvy out topics which, while important, will probably not occupy any of the slots on the main television news platforms.

I knew that if I did my job properly, my two-part interview with Judy Murray at the weekend was bound to evoke a healthy response. I’ve interviewed literally hundreds of people across Scotland, the UK, Europe and America, hailing from a wide variety of professional and social backgrounds.

Even so, the response from around the UK and abroad to her words – overwhelmingly from women expressing gratitude for her bravery – was humbling.

Ms Murray was one of the most eloquent and smartest of all those I’ve interviewed. She had matters she wanted to address, including the abject failure of our feckless sports bodies to build on the unique and generational legacy bequeathed to them by the world class feats of her sons, Andy and Jamie.


Read more


It was her thoughts though, on the increasing encroachment of male-born athletes into women’s sport that were the most compelling. Ms Murray has spent most of her adult life coaching boys and girls; women and men how to play tennis to a competitive standard. She said: “I’m more than aware that when children reach puberty, the boys begin to pull away from the girls hugely because they obviously become bigger, stronger and faster.

“The advantages that accrue from being born male once puberty is reached is why I absolutely believe in bringing back the swab test. Those who are born male should only compete in male categories. And I feel the same way about our spaces in general. Yet, as soon as you speak out about this you get jumped on by some trans activists who will accuse you of being transphobic, which I’m certainly not.”

Understandably, it was these thoughts that elicited the biggest online response than any other article I’ve written in recent years. Yet, it was what she said after this that seemed to paint an even bleaker picture.

“I think it’s a challenge for any woman in the public eye to speak about this and in sport it’s usually the old guard who are speaking out about it. This is because they’ve gained maturity and don’t have anything to lose any more. Younger female athletes, understandably, are very cautious about this because of the social media onslaught that can come with it and how it could affect sponsorship and team funding.”

Ms Murray made these observations as members of England’s international women’s team were being pressurised to make a public announcement about the Football Association’s endorsement of male-born players competing in women’s football.

Gregg Wallace has been accused of inappropriate behaviourGregg Wallace has been accused of inappropriate behaviour (Image: free) Those sporting authorities which have succumbed to demands that biological males be permitted to compete in female events have exploited the lack of agency that young female athletes have in this matter. It’s a form of bribery: speak out about this and we’ll ensure that your career never gets off the ground. Earlier this year, A UN Report found that 600 female athletes had lost nearly 900 medals to transwomen in more than 400 events across 29 different sports.

This is why a band of heroic women such as Judy Murray, JK Rowling and Joanna Cherry have chosen to speak out about this. In the sporting realm the presence of male-born athletes translates into lost titles and years of training and sacrifice wasted. In other areas, such as women’s prisons and rape crisis centres, the presence of men among traumatised women is potentially catastrophic.

Some of their detractors will say that Ms Rowling’s wealth and Ms Cherry’s formidable legal and political brain make it easy for them to speak out. This though, is precisely the point. They’re doing so because younger women and those subject to the whims of corporations anxious to wash away their capitalist avarice with the passing virtues of the day have been cowed into silence.

This also needs to be said: no amount of money can mitigate the damage and sense of fear that JK Rowling and her family must have experienced through the death threats and the unspeakably evil threats of sexual violence. Joanna Cherry’s status as the SNP’s most effective MP at Westminster didn’t protect her from five years of unrelenting misogynistic abuse, some of it orchestrated by a cabal of her much less gifted colleagues.


Read more


And when younger women learn what happened to the SNP MSP Joan McAlpine and the poet Jenny Lindsay for standing up to the intimidation, it’s little wonder that they may be reluctant to speak out.

How we’ve arrived at this place in liberal, progressive Scotland is perhaps told best in Ms Lindsay’s book, Hounded: Women, Harms and the Gender Wars; and The Women Who Wouldn’t Wheesht by Susan Dalgety and Lucy Hunter Blackburn.

As a late middle-aged West of Scotland bloke with all of the imperfections and weaknesses associated with that wretched state, there are many aspects of this that are beyond my comprehension. Chief among them is how older feminists and lesbians, who gave decades of their lives to the cause of equality, are now routinely disparaged by the Scottish government and all the public sector agencies that rely on its largesse.

There is another cadre of middle-aged men, mainly to be seen in the media, who in a pathetic attempt to appear relevant, like to undermine and mock these women. They identify as edgy and radical, but their left-wing values are measured in herbal infusions and soy lattes. They are fakes, but they are bullies too.

Many of those in Scotland expressing outrage at Gregg Wallace’s alleged inappropriate conduct in recent weeks have been much more reticent about something similar closer to home. They’ve all chosen to remain silent when “middle-class women of a certain age” have been routinely threatened and then silenced for their gender-critical beliefs.

Scotland is a liberal and enlightened democracy. It’s the reactionary and illiberal elites running the country who are the problem.


Kevin McKenna is a Herald writer and columnist. He says he is at the ‘knowing occasionally when to shut up' stage of his feminist education


 

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos