Mark McGeoghegan

Is independence possible in Donald Trump’s new world order?

Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Presidents Trump and Putin will meet at a summit in Alaska today, the first meeting between President Putin and an American President since Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022. Mooted as a summit to end the war, it may end as the latest Trump-era American action to undermine the rules-based international order and threaten the sovereignty of smaller states.

We already know that President Trump admires authoritarians like President Putin. Indeed, he wishes he could rule as one – his domestic policies are a clear effort to turn the US into a more authoritarian state. He also sees international relations as an arena of great power politics, in which the only states that matter are those with immense hard power, and, as Thucydides put it, “the strong do what they can and the weak suffer what they must.”

Just as his domestic policies threaten to transform the US into an authoritarian regime, his foreign policy threatens a return to an older form of international order, which we thought had been put to bed by international institutions like the United Nations.


Read More:


In this old (or new, depending on how you look at it) order, states like the US, Russia, and China carve the world up into spheres of influence in which they exercise power without external intervention. They control the smaller states around them, dictating how those smaller states act to their advantage, always with the threat of force behind every diplomatic overture. When the interests of those powers conflict, they sit around a table and hammer out a deal. Whether that deal is acceptable to smaller states or not is irrelevant – they are coerced into compliance.

That is precisely how Presidents Trump and Putin see the Alaska summit. A meeting between the leaders of two great powers, hammering out a deal, the interests of Ukraine and wider Europe be damned.

There was speculation that Ukraine’s President Zelenskyy would also be in attendance, but such speculation – fuelled by the Trump Administration – was misguided and likely an effort to blunt early criticism of the summit. President Putin does not see Ukraine as a legitimate, sovereign nation-state, and does not see President Zelenskyy as a leader on par with himself. He would never have agreed to a summit in which President Zelenskyy participated as an equal. And, frankly, President Trump shares that worldview.

When President Trump spoke earlier this week about territory swaps as part of a peace deal, he was talking about carving up Ukraine without the input of the Ukrainians. He was talking about a return to a Europe in which borders can be changed by force, without the consent of any European leaders – consent that will never be forthcoming. He was talking about abandoning US allies to a sphere of influence notionally dominated by Russia.

The motivation behind this is obvious, beyond President Trump’s apparent infatuation with President Putin. At today’s summit, he is also scheduled to discuss areas of potential economic cooperation. Business interests around President Trump have been clamouring for an easing of sanctions on Russia for some time, and a peace deal – regardless of terms – would enable that.

A deal between the US and Russia, which Ukraine and other European nations are coerced into accepting, would be rooted in the short-term and shortsighted self-interest of American capital, not in the interests of a sustainable peace. In turn, it would threaten that peace further by legitimising the territorial gains made by Russia in this war, and send a clear signal that the US will no longer act as a backstop for the rules-based international order.

The consequences would extend far beyond Ukraine. President Xi Jinping of China, for example, would look at such a deal and lick his lips at the prospect of capturing Taiwan. Around the world, larger states with territorial disputes with their smaller neighbours would be popping champagne corks. President Trump would have given the green light to a new era of state consolidation.

Since its inception, the state system has gone through periods of state consolidation – when the number of states declines as a result of empire-building – and state birth, when new states emerge as a result of processes like imperial collapse or decolonisation. In the latter case, decolonisation was facilitated by the existence of the UN and American backstop to international law enshrining self-determination and the sovereignty of self-governing nations.

Sovereignty is, as Stephen Krasner put it, “organised hypocrisy.” It exists only insofar as states, collectively, recognise that it exists. Without a system to enforce such recognition, no state can be sovereign, and all states become subject to the whims of their larger neighbours.

If the Alaska summit points to another move back to the old international order, in which existence for small states was, to quote Thomas Hobbes, “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short”, new questions of state survival will be posed not just to existing small states, but to secessionist movements seeking to become independent in such a world.

Not only must such movements find a way to become an independent, sovereign state – no easy feat itself – but they must also have a strategy to maintain that sovereignty. Post-WWII, that was all but guaranteed by the rules-based international order. In the world that Presidents Trump and Putin envision, there is no such guarantee.

The SNP have come a long way from the days of opposition to NATO membership, but they continue to harbour a strain of pacifist-adjacent opinion that is strongly opposed to being a full part of the Western alliance system – even as polling repeatedly shows strong support among Scots for being such.

If there is another independence referendum, the question will have to be asked: how will Scotland secure and defend its sovereignty should it be won? In 2014, a recently passed mentor of mine, Professor Brandon Valeriano, was asked by a TV journalist how an independent Scotland would defend itself from Russia. He laughed off the question, and at the time, he was right to do so.

But the world has changed, and is changing. It is being shaped and reshaped by strongmen and dictators, undermining democracy, liberty, and sovereignty. If the Alaska summit presages a return to an older, more anarchic form of international order, we will all have to confront challenging new realities.

Mark McGeoghegan is a Glasgow University researcher of nationalism and contentious politics and an Associate Member of the Centre on Constitutional Change. He can be found on BlueSky @markmcgeoghegan.bsky.social

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos