Nigel Farage’s unwillingness to reject President Trump’s false assertion that paracetamol use during pregnancy is related to autism shows that he is not fit to be Prime Minister, writes Herald columnist Mark McGeoghegan.
When my wife fell pregnant this summer, it was a moment of elation for both of us. It had taken a long time, involving going through IVF, to get there. We had spent a long time contemplating pregnancy, and so I thought we were well prepared for what she would go through. But nothing could have prepared us – no offence to pregnant women everywhere – for just how fundamentally weird pregnancy is.
One of the consequences of that weirdness, whether it’s organs shifting to accommodate the growing womb or constant congestion and nose bleeds, thanks to increased blood volume, is pain. The symptoms pregnant women experience vary from woman to woman and pregnancy to pregnancy, but the one constant is that pregnancy is painful. So believe me when I say that I found Nigel Farage’s prevarication over the non-existent link between paracetamol use during pregnancy and autism not just personally offensive, but outright grotesque.
Paracetamol, also known as Tylenol in the United States, is the only off-the-shelf painkiller and antipyretic (meaning it reduces fever) that pregnant women can take. A whole host of other painkillers, from non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) like ibuprofen to medications containing codeine, like co-codamol, can have harmful side effects during pregnancy. NSAIDs can cause kidney problems in the baby, and codeine use can lead to breathing issues and even opioid dependence in a newborn.
Read more:
- Charlie Kirk’s death and the erosion of free speech
- Israel is out of control – and the West is to blame
- The far right may try - but they won't manage to steal the Saltire
- Scotland can't afford to continue without local government reform
As a result, pain management during pregnancy isn’t a straightforward exercise. When my wife fell ill with sinusitis during the first trimester, she usually would have self-medicated using Sudafed or another medication containing pseudoephedrine. But pseudoephedrine, too, is unsafe to take while pregnant, especially during the first trimester when it can restrict blood flow to the placenta and has even been linked to birth defects. So she had to push through it, only occasionally taking paracetamol when the pain was unmanageable otherwise.
It is no exaggeration to say that paracetamol is a lifeline for pregnant women, and not just in terms of pain management. We will shortly be entering flu season, and while pregnant women are eligible for a free flu vaccine, not all will get one, and its efficacy is far from 100%. Fever can be extremely dangerous for an unborn child and can often lead to complications like preterm labour. Being able to manage it is crucial, and paracetamol is one of the few antipyretics pregnant women can use.
Undermining trust and confidence in paracetamol among pregnant women will have two effects. It will lead to far more women having far more painful pregnancies, and to some women who could use paracetamol to manage fevers not doing so, putting both them and their babies at risk.
And for what? Let me be absolutely clear: the link between paracetamol use and autism is not “unproven”, as many media outlets have characterised it; it is nonexistent. While Robert F. Kennedy Junior’s report in the US cites a handful of studies that might have suggested a correlation between paracetamol use and autism, the best-quality, systematic studies of that suggested link have found that it simply does not exist.
Two recent studies, conducted in Sweden and Japan, are notable examples. They tracked millions of children over several decades and employed a sibling-comparison design to control for genetic and other factors. Both found no link between paracetamol use and autism.
When asked about Mr Kennedy’s report and President Trump’s support for it, Nigel Farage prevaricated. He told LBC’s Nick Ferrari that “when it comes to science, I don’t side with anybody, right?”, and compared the scientific consensus on the safety of paracetamol to the Thalidomide scandal.
Well, when it comes to science, I do personally side with somebody: the scientists. Modern science operates based on falsification, testing hypotheses in an effort to disprove them. The hypothesis that paracetamol use during pregnancy is linked to autism has been repeatedly tested and repeatedly disproven using the best methods available.
I don’t agree with him on much, but I have to applaud Wes Streeting, the Secretary of State responsible for the NHS in England, for coming out so strongly against Mr Kennedy’s report and President Trump’s comments on it. He stated that the British public should not “pay any attention whatsoever to what Donald Trump says about medicine”, and rightly so. When the health of the nation is threatened by this sort of disinformation coming out of a deranged US administration, it is the responsibility of our own politicians and leaders to stand up for scientific truth. And I applaud the First Minister, John Swinney, for doing likewise and also criticising Mr Farage’s comments.
Healthcare, and especially the healthcare of pregnant women, is far too important for politicians to umm and ahh over scientific reality. When they do, they put our well-being at risk. In this case, Mr Farage is putting the health and even the lives of pregnant women and their unborn children at risk.
He has done so because he genuinely believes what he said, thinks there is a constituency for this kind of nonsense in the UK, or is too afraid of upsetting his friend, President Trump, to stand up for the truth. He is stupid, craven, or cowardly. Or a combination of all three.
In any case, if he hadn’t already demonstrated this, he has now shown just how unfit for office he really is. Mr Farage wants to be Prime Minister, and the polls suggest he has a good shot at winning that office at the next general election. But we cannot afford to be led by a man who has no respect for scientific truth and who is happy to imperil the well-being of pregnant women and their children in exchange for votes and the approval of a man on the other side of the Atlantic.
I wouldn’t blame any pregnant woman for erring on the side of caution and avoiding taking paracetamol if they’re unsure of what to believe. That’s born out of a desire to do what’s best for themselves and their baby, and is entirely understandable. That’s also the reason why we need more politicians like Mr Streeting and Mr Swinney, who are willing to stand up for scientific truth, even if it creates political headaches, and fewer craven cowards like Mr Farage. The health of the nation depends on it.
Mark McGeoghegan is a Glasgow University researcher of nationalism and contentious politics and an Associate Member of the Centre on Constitutional Change. He can be found on BlueSky @markmcgeoghegan.bsky.social
Share