Mark McGeoghegan

Trump’s peace deal is real — but he shouldn’t win a Nobel

US President Donald Trump poses for a photo during the Sharm El Sheikh Peace Summit in Egypt. <i>(Image: PA)</i>
US President Donald Trump poses for a photo during the Sharm El Sheikh Peace Summit in Egypt. (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The Israel-Hamas ceasefire is a significant achievement for President Trump, but he will remain undeserving of the Nobel Peace Prize even if it holds, says Herald columnist Mark McGeoghegan


In the two years since October 7th 2022, over 67,000 people have been killed, around 80% of whom have been civilians and a quarter of whom were children, in addition to the more than 1,000 Israelis murdered in the biggest act of violence against Jews since the Holocaust. Gaza is in rubble, and the Israel-Hamas war has been defined by a litany of war crimes and human rights violations committed by both sides.

For this reason alone, President Donald Trump deserves credit for having achieved a ceasefire between the two sides, as do the cast of supporting figures, from the President’s envoy, Steve Witkoff, to our own Prime Minister’s National Security Adviser, Jonathan Powell. The surviving hostages have been freed, as have thousands of Palestinian prisoners, the majority of whom had been detained without trial, and a ceasefire is in place as phase one of the peace plan progresses. This is a significant achievement, even if the ceasefire doesn’t last.

The plan is not, of course, singularly of the Trump Administration’s making. It is very similar to the deal the Biden Administration had been working on, and the fingerprints of luminaries of the Northern Ireland peace process, like Mr Powell and his former boss, Sir Tony Blair, are all over it. But President Biden’s kid-glove handling of Israel’s Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, was never likely to get him to agree to a ceasefire unpopular among the far-right elements of the Israeli government.


Read more:


I wouldn’t have thought that it would be President Trump – belligerent, capricious, and excessively egotistical – who would provide the push needed to get a peace deal over the line. But here we are, reminded that sometimes paradox is a political virtue. After all, only Nixon could go to China.

But there is a real risk that, in our haste to welcome a ceasefire in Israel and Palestine that we go to far in praising its ultimate architect. There have been plentiful calls for President Trump to win the Nobel Peace Prize, but he would still be far from a deserving recipient, for multiple reasons.

Firstly, there is a world of difference between what is proposed in the deal and a real peace process of the kind we saw in Northern Ireland. There are no plans for any process to ensure reconciliation or the establishment of equal rights for all peoples in the region. Peacekeeping forces, investment in rebuilding infrastructure, and a return to democracy under the Palestinian Authority would all be welcome, but without reconciliation between the Palestinian and Israeli peoples and a guarantee of equality between them, peace will be extremely difficult to establish and maintain.

In the wake of war, the subsequent “peace” is very often defined by residual violence. This is the norm, not the exception, and is much more likely to occur without a process of reconciliation. Assassinations, low-intensity attacks on civilians, and bombings against both civilian and military targets become normal. This violence is often committed by militias and other armed groups that formed during the war but can also be the result of lone-wolf reprisals. Not only are there no provisions in the deal to prevent these, but settler violence in the West Bank continues and without an end to settler activity, no stable Palestinian state can form.

And the ceasefire itself is on a shoogly peg. At some point, Hamas will be required to disarm and disband, something the group has shown no intention to do, much as they have no intention to give up control of Gaza. Since the start of this week, dozens of Hamas and rival Palestinian fighters have been killed in internecine fighting, including a public execution carried out and filmed by Hamas. On the Israeli side, the IDF have already begun planning to destroy the remaining Hamas tunnels in Gaza, an action Hamas is likely to resist.

But even if the ceasefire holds, and even if it develops into a sustainable, lasting, true peace that involves equality for Israelis and Palestinians and the realisation of a two-state solution, the Nobel committee would do well to pause before awarding the Peace Prize to President Trump.

His foreign policy reflects the “madman” theory of international affairs associated with President Nixon, which consists of convincing ones partners and opponents that you are capable of anything, making them easier to coerce out of fear of an unpredictable and potentially irrational response. Unlike President Biden, Mr Netanyahu couldn’t be sure that President Trump wouldn’t withdraw support for Israel if he didn’t go along with this plan.

Unlike President Nixon and his Secretary of State, Henry Kissinger, who deployed madman theory in a rational way, President Trump follows it because it suits his personality and, crucially, because he enjoys it. Like I wrote above, President Trump is belligerent, capricious, and egotistical. He wants to be a strongman, and so unlike previous American Presidents, he has no qualms with swinging the big stick that is American economic and military power.

The same qualities that made him suited to pushing Israel and Hamas into this ceasefire deal, which still has a minefield to navigate before it can be considered a lasting success, are the qualities that lead to him deploying the military in American cities. They are the traits that lead to armed, masked goons kidnapping civilians off the street. The traits that lead to his administration engaging in extrajudicial killings, blowing up civilian boats in other nations’ waters.

President Trump is not a man who wants lasting peace in the world. He is a man who wants the world to kowtow to him, and who will use American power to force it to.

The Nobel Peace Prize is meant to be awarded annually for outstanding contributions to peace: arms reduction, international cooperation, organisations contributing to peace, and human rights contributions to peace. President Trump’s foreign and domestic policies do not fall into those categories, despite the significant achievement of the Israel-Hamas ceasefire. Too often, his policies lead to greater violence and suffering, both at home and abroad.

It wouldn’t shock me if the Nobel committee do end up awarding President Trump. They will come under significant diplomatic pressure to do so and have made controversial picks in the past. But taken in the round, President Trump is not a leader deserving of a Nobel medal.


Mark McGeoghegan is a Glasgow University researcher of nationalism and contentious politics and an Associate Member of the Centre on Constitutional Change. He can be found on BlueSky @markmcgeoghegan.bsky.social

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos