MARK SMITH

Charging to see Glasgow city chambers is the right decision

Glasgow city chambers
Glasgow city chambers
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Glasgow Council is proposing a charge to visit the city chambers. They should go much further, says Mark Smith


All good artists, writers, musicians, you name it, are the same: you’ve got to put in a bit of effort to understand them and to love them and that’s certainly true of Tracey Emin. A retrospective of her work has just opened at the Tate Modern and the review in The Times said of the show that Emin “has a way with words, often mangled to great effect”, which I thought was very good and spot on. You’re never quite sure what Tracey’s saying but you get the feeling that it’s, possibly, quite important.

So it is with her remarks this week on galleries and museums. Speaking at the opening of the Tate show, Emin said the British Museum, of which she is a patron, had a “terrible colonial past” and needed to move “fast” into the 21st century but that “you can’t just give things back” because “you don’t know that it is going to be looked after”. Emin didn’t explain what moving fast into the 21st century means or what she means by terrible, but she did appear to be urging caution over the return of “stolen” items, which is good news. The trendy view is ‘give it all back’, so good on Tracey for resisting trendy, if that is what she was doing.

Her views on museum funding are a little more mangled. We know what we’re dealing with don’t we: the Tate has got a deficit, the National Gallery has got a deficit, everybody’s got a deficit, so the conversation is starting to turn towards whether entry to museums and galleries should still be free. The policy dates from the days when Oasis were number one and there was money to spend; 25 years on, Oasis are doing gigs again but the country, and many of its institutions, are broke, which means we should, need to, talk about whether a policy from 2001 is still fit for purpose.


Read more

A bra in the face and skiving Scots: The wisdom of a comedy genius | The Herald

Glasgow has changed us. But we may need a new law on drivers | The Herald

The CCA and an Israel boycott – the alarm bells are ringing | The Herald


Emin’s view on the subject is that museums should remain free because “the longer it stays free the better it is for everybody”. But she also said this: “If you are someone like me, you should join the membership for every museum you go to, or you should tap and make a donation every time you go there and that would make a hell of a difference. People in responsible positions should start getting memberships not just for one museum but for every one that they visit.”

To some extent, I get where I think she’s coming from: memberships and donations are vital to the sector and more of them would be good. But memberships are voluntary and for every person who takes one out or makes a donation, hundreds, thousands, hundreds of thousands don’t and continue to visit museums for free. The idea, of course, is that it widens the audience and reaches folk who can’t afford to pay, but that’s not what generally happens. What happens, in the words of Nick Merriman, who ran English Heritage until recently, is “you just get more middle-class people going”.

Senior figures in museums, like Merriman, are starting to realise this is a problem. Mark Jones, former director of the V&A, has described universal free entry as regressive and inequitable which is entirely logical: his point is that taxpayers on modest incomes are subsidising tourists who can generally afford to pay and the same goes for the middle classes, the ones that generally go to museums. In fact, the principle applies to everything that’s universally free: the well-off are being subsidised by the less-well-off, a concept the Scottish Government in particular cannot seem to get its head round.

This would all be perfectly fine, I guess, if public finances were in a great way and long-term public funding of free museums was affordable and sustainable (although many of us would prefer taxes to be kept as low as possible by asking those who can afford it to pay for services). We know, however, that public finances are in a bad way, which is why museums are starting to ask questions about free entry. Every other country charges for its museums – the only way you’ll get into the Louvre for free, for example, is if you shimmy up a ladder and break in through a window – so why are we still waving them in for free in the UK?

Tracey Emin with one of the works in Tracey Emin: A Second Life at London's Tate Modern Picture by Yui Mok/PA Wire

Glasgow provides a good illustration. The council has many free museums but has a huge spending gap – £36m – and will be paying £56m in the next financial year to pay for accommodation for the homeless (around half of the demand is from refugees). The disproportionate effect the refugee crisis is having on the city may be fixed at some point – I hope so – but until then financial solutions will have to be found and part of it will be turning the screw on taxpayers – council tax is to rise by 5.9%. But the council, like the government, still doesn’t appear to have made the connection between the scale of the funding crisis and free services for everyone, including those who can afford to pay (free schools meals are to be extended to all children in primary seven).

There is a glimmer of hope though, just a glimmer. The council budget that was passed last week proposes charging people to tour the city chambers. This would appear to be a recognition from the council that it needs to, and should, generate revenue from its assets and the city chambers is certainly one of those. I was in it the other day and that staircase, tons of marble upon tons of marble, really is one of the most remarkable in the world. Another part of the council’s search for revenue will be renting the place out for more external events and about time too.

But accepting that the principle of free stuff for everyone is no longer sustainable will be an uphill struggle now people have got used to it. You may remember Glasgow council proposing charges to visit the Kibble Palace, but such was the uproar from the middle-class people who use it – exactly the sort who should be helping to pay for it – that the council backed down. And despite the desperate need for income, there’s a chance the same thing would happen again with the city chambers and that if a furore built over the charges, the council would back down again and that would be that.

Perhaps I’m wrong. Perhaps the council will stick to its guns. Perhaps they’ll look at charging for their other museums and buildings too; I hope they do because the principle at stake is that public money should be targeted at those who need it most. Tracey Emin’s view is that free museums are better for everyone. But isn’t the opposite true? Isn’t it in everyone’s interests to find a long-term, sustainable way to fund museums and galleries? The reality, Tracey, is that free actually comes with a cost, for taxpayers, councils, museums, all of us. Free isn’t free at all, is it?

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos