Everyone wants to tackle child poverty. When John Swinney made it his priority on day one, he couldn’t have picked a more unifying cause.
Everyone knows too that he and his ministers are a bit short right now, to the tune of a billion and a half. That funding gap is having an impact on every decision ministers make. Unfortunately there isn’t a National Lottery for governments which could deliver a poverty-blasting windfall. The super-wealthy tend to prefer super yachts and space rockets to ensuring children don’t go to bed hungry, so there’s no point expecting them to hand over their spare billions.
So how is the Scottish Government to meet its target of reducing the numbers of children in relative poverty to 10 per cent by 2030? With epic difficulty, obviously, but overhauling our unjust council tax system could be a part of the answer.
“It’s a regressive tax that takes up a much larger proportion of low-income households’ budget than better-off households’,” the Joseph Rowntree Foundation reminds us, in its latest warning to the Scottish Government about its vanishingly small chances of reaching the 2030 target. It describes the council tax system in Scotland as unfair by design, outdated and desperately in need of reform.
Read more Rebecca McQuillan
- Let’s have indyref2 when support reaches 60%
- Labour right to reclaim patriotism for the left
- Pick the right leader, Labour, or we'll have the SNP in power for ever
This is another thing everyone agrees on. Council tax isn’t working. If you reformed it, not only could you reduce what people in struggling households had to pay but you could, depending on how you did it, increase the overall tax take – a double benefit. It would imply that those in the largest homes paid a bit more, but some adjustment is undeniably overdue.
It takes a brave government to do that, though, and the SNP have shied away from it, though they’ve made some helpful tweaks. In 2017, they raised council tax levels for more expensive properties and are now committed to introducing two higher council tax bands, I and J, for properties worth over £1m and £2m.
All good stuff, but existing bandings A to H still rely on property valuations from the year the Soviet Union collapsed and Sam Mitchell eloped with Ricky Butcher on Eastenders. In 1991, people in the most expensive bands paid three times more than the least expensive, while their properties were worth eight times more; now the difference is far greater. Due to rising house prices over the last 35 years, the Scottish Government’s modelling shows that Band H homes are worth, on average, 15.5 times more than Band A ones, but they pay only 3.67 times more in council tax. That’s not to say their income is 15 times greater or that they should pay 15 times more – or anything like it, – but some increase would be reasonable.
The reason it hasn’t already been reformed, in spite of the shared view that it’s an embarrassing mess, is partly down to politics. Scottish Government ministers have blamed their inaction on a lack of consensus in parliament about how to change the existing system. The SNP reiterated this in their May manifesto, saying “we will set a high priority for the next parliament of seeking early cross-party agreement on reform”.
Is that really necessary though? Andy Wightman, the land ownership expert and former Green MSP, writing in his blog, wonders wryly why consensus is required for this but only a simple majority for every other bill in parliament. For “consensus”, perhaps read “political cover”. You could spook a lot of people in the process of reforming council tax. But if you are serious about eradicating child poverty, then you have to be just as serious about redistribution of wealth.
It has to be fair, though. That’s the really tricky bit. If politics is one reason for the foot-dragging, then the other is working out how to avoid hurting people who have wealth tied up in property but a tight income. The Scottish Government carried out a consultation last year, asking for views on things like revaluation and whether the system should be designed to make it progressive so the wealthier pay more.
The results show that while respondents favour revaluation and about half favour making the system more progressive, there are concerns. In particular, people worry about how certain groups would cope with bill increases, such as pensioners on fixed incomes, the disabled, young people in low paid work and single parents. They might add people struggling with rising mortgage costs and energy bills.
Any changes to any tax throw up questions of fairness; there will have to be mitigations for groups who could be thus affected. But so unfair is the current system, sticking with it endlessly is no longer an option. Anti-poverty campaigners aren’t impressed with the shilly-shallying, the Joseph Rowntree Foundation stating in the spring that “a lack of perfect consensus is not a reasonable excuse,” saying it “allows politicians to duck a difficult conversation about housing wealth and inequality with the most affluent people in Scotland”.
Read more
- 'This is a masterclass' - Kevin Bridges’ tour is as good as stand-up comedy gets
- Scotland is responsible for some terrible inventions - this could be the worst yet
- Are we living in a computer simulation? Scotland's Astronomer Royal gives her answer
So let’s have that conversation and let’s anchor it in the fight against poverty. The JRF is right: there is indeed an “increasing disconnect” between what the Scottish Government says it will achieve on child poverty and the measures it has put in place to achieve it.
There is no alternative to radical action if those extremely difficult targets are to be met. The poorest benefit the most if local services are well funded, but local government is not well funded. Fees and charges for services are going up due to funding shortfalls from central government. The Scottish Government has committed to expand whole-family support to prevent families falling into crisis and it can make a huge difference, but the level of support is “wholly inadequate”, say campaigners.
The biggest component of council funding is money from the Scottish Government – around 60 per cent – and that funding is insufficient. The Scottish Government has turned the sofa upside down, though, and there’s no spare cash to give. So we have to look at council tax, even though it only accounts for 17 per cent of local government budgets. Reforming it would bring instant budget relief to many of the worse-off households.
Politicians who set radical targets should be prepared to follow through. Otherwise we’ll start to wonder if they really mean to meet those targets at all.
Share