If anyone elsewhere in Scotland doubts a thriving Edinburgh is good for the rest of the country then a study presented to city councillors this week should put them straight.
An investigation by the London-based economics consultancy Metro Dynamics estimated that if the Edinburgh city region – the Lothians, plus the Borders and Fife – grew at the same rate as the rest of the country then by 2040 the Scottish economy would be £12.3 billion smaller than if the area was able to grow at the same rate as it has done since 2013, the Covid years excepting.
The paper makes the case for a stronger regional partnership between the six local authorities, building on the work done under the Edinburgh City Region Deal since its inception eight years ago, but since it was commissioned the work has been overtaken by the Scottish Government’s hazy plan for local government reform, which has thrown the whole council system up in the air.
By contrast, Metro Dynamics has outlined a programme for continued growth driven by regional coordination, but without the need to spend millions on setting up new authorities, and losing time while other regions in the UK and beyond get on with the job of competing.
Read more
- Scotland is holding Edinburgh back - and that has to stop
- Edinburgh’s tourist tax risks damaging the city’s world-famous festivals
- Edinburgh tram expansion will remain a pipe dream without Scottish Government funding
Now, £12.3 billion a year is a lot to put at risk, but that’s a likely effect if the vague plan to create up to 160 community authorities from the break-up of the existing councils, and to plonk between six and ten new regional councils on top of them, results in the paralysis of decision-making when it comes to planning and important investment decisions.
As the Metro study shows, the framework for better regional administration is there, but where it falls down is its failure to address the lack of leadership which makes the current Edinburgh city region meaningless as a political entity to the average voter, in contrast to instantly recognisable English regional mayors. After all, it provided a launchpad for one to defenestrate a Prime Minister, but Metro explicitly rules out elected mayors, presumably to avoid scaring their paymasters.
The SNP’s intervention on local government reform may yet render the Metro plan redundant, and as was pointed out at Edinburgh’s policy and resources committee on Tuesday, the three months the SNP government has timetabled for the initial consultation is far too short for local authorities to draw up and approve their responses, as well as include these proposals.
Of course, the SNP’s council group can see no problem with their superiors’ approach, and local leader Lesley Macinnes was indignant − she is rarely anything else – because other parties had the temerity to disagree. There was never any chance she would go along with a Conservative motion which called for the application of SNP-led legislation to hold a local referendum on any council boundary changes – such is her tribalism she would find reason to oppose the Tories if they called for independence – but at least there was comedy value in a senior Nationalist opposing a referendum.
However, Cllr Macinnes is not so loyal as to ignore the impracticality of breaking up Edinburgh Council, as suggested in the brief government consultation paper, and she called for a discussion with the public reform secretary Ivan McKee about “the retention of Edinburgh as a unitary council”.
But in alliance with the anti-growth Greens, the SNP sought to slow up adoption of Metro Dynamics’ proposals so they could have more opportunity to stick in their noses. Self-interest is a powerful thing.
Courting trouble
Last week’s column predicted the saga of doomed, asbestos riddled, Westfield Court in Gorgie was set to run for years, and so it transpired at Monday’s housing committee, but not in the way I thought.
I should have remembered that when faced with difficult decisions the default for too many politicians is to duck, because they just want to be liked. The cost of putting the block right is estimated at £48 million, and who in their right mind would spend half a million on repairing each of the 94 homes, when Rightmove estimates the average price of a flat in Gorgie is £238,367? And that’s if they can find a contractor willing to take it on.
I know one of the city’s best qualified experts for this sort of work, who has examined the building in detail, and his considered professional opinion was “it’s absolutely f***ed.”
But that didn’t stop cloth-eared Green, SNP and Lib Dem councillors voting to send council officers away to re-examine a repair job instead of demolition, leaving residents stuck with valueless properties and still not knowing what kind of offer, compulsory or otherwise, the council can make to buy them out because elected cowards paid £26,000 a year can’t face up to their responsibilities.
Standards nonsense
More fun and games with the Standards Commission, and once again a recommendation from the ethics Gestapo under Commissioner Ian Bruce to censure a councillor, this time Edinburgh’s Labour education convener James Dalgleish, was thrown out.
Cllr Dalgleish had received a “strongly worded” email from an Edinburgh University staff member, Angela Chitzanidi, after she was infuriated about a decision about single sex toilets and transgender children in Edinburgh schools. His “crime” was to forward it to her employer because it was sent from a university account.
It strikes me that Cllr Dalgleish was indeed a bit of a twerp for trying to get her into trouble, but then Ms Chitzanidi is every bit as bad for making a counter complaint to what Mr Bruce described as “retaliation.” Maybe they deserve each other, but is this really a standards matter? Should public money have been wasted staging a hearing into this rubbish?
As I have written here before, the ridiculous councillor code of conduct is easily weaponised by political opponents, because far too often the system, and Mr Bruce’s interpretation, puts elected representatives through the mill on spurious grounds. And guess what, Ms Chitzanidi’s partner is the serial Labour rebel councillor Ross Mckenzie who has since joined the Greens.
Share