Rebecca McQuillan

Andy Burnham is right about Brexit – Britain needs an honest debate

'Burnham is inviting a discussion knowing the public mood has moved against Brexit' <i>(Image: PA)</i>
'Burnham is inviting a discussion knowing the public mood has moved against Brexit' (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Brexit was stressful, wasn’t it? Not in a losing your job or your home sort of a way, but in the sense that we woke up on June 24, 2016, and learned our future had just been entrusted to certain utter charlatans who wouldn’t recognise the truth if it came to their front door with a passport, driving licence and a reference from David Attenborough.

Ten years ago, facts and expert opinion were famously treated by Leave campaigners as if they were elitist fetishes, to be sneered at like veganism or Radio Four. Warnings from pretty much the entire UK community of economists, predicting a detrimental impact on the UK, were ignored or treated with contempt. Remember all that Johnson guff about how Brexit would unlock our “buccaneering spirit” and allow for glittering international trade deals that would stuff the Bank of England’s vaults with more gold than Donald Trump’s bathroom? Remember how it was going to drive down immigration and boost youth employment?

Instead, it has stymied growth, driven business closures, led thousands of businesses to stop trading with the EU, reduced the tax take and created labour shortages. Prominent studies say growth is between six and eight per cent lower than it would have been without Brexit. Immigration was not reduced (it soared to unheard-of levels three years ago) and there are nearly one million 16- to 24-year-olds now classed as Neets.

Brexit has hampered everything from international academic research to sending parcels to Europe. The bitter irony of Brussels-phobes like Nigel Farage creating in Brexit a job creation scheme for bureaucrats (so many parcels to check and border checks to conduct) underlines the problem: we didn’t have an honest debate before we voted.

We had a good deal as an EU member, with a rebate on our contributions to Brussels and no pressure to take on the euro, and David Cameron blew it. For the last two years, between 55 and 60 per cent of British voters have consistently told pollsters it was wrong to leave the EU.


Read more:


That’s not quite the same as saying they’d like to rejoin, though. On what should happen next, there is no such clear consensus. What we can say is that a clear majority favour one of two options: either rejoining or having a much closer relationship. There is very little enthusiasm for what we’ve got and none for distancing ourselves further.

Enter Andy Burnham, who seems to sniff an opportunity. He’s expressed his personal desire to see the UK re-enter Europe within his lifetime and is now inviting debate about free movement (a prerequisite of reversing Brexit or entering the single market). He thinks Brexit has weakened the economy and not worked out the way Leavers promised, particularly on immigration.

He highlights greater difficulties in returning people who cross in small boats and a change in the nature of migration, from people coming temporarily to those applying to stay permanently (the so-called Boris Wave).

Importantly, he is not committing to anything. This is the beginning of a conversation about Britain’s future that could last years. He said yesterday that he would “never move ahead of the British public when it comes to Brexit” and wouldn’t propose bringing back free movement without a referendum, but he is starting to lay out, calmly and rationally, the alternative to the unloved status quo.

He wants, he says, an “honest discussion” – the discussion we should have had 10 years ago, which politicians have been too scared to have since.

Wow, what a political backlash there will be. You can see already that Reform feels it is back in its comfort zone, wailing about immigration. Richard Tice, not Reform’s greatest asset, even came out with a good line on the radio, saying that he and his party looked forward to a debate on whether Britain should “rejoin a rioting, failing European Union”. Some Labour MPs in red wall seats are said to have the jitters.

So is Burnham getting it wrong? Kemi Badenoch thinks so, attacking him for supposedly putting his foot in his mouth.

He hasn’t, though. This is thought through. Burnham is inviting a discussion knowing the public mood has moved against Brexit. Plenty of Labour MPs will be pleased, knowing that this discussion will help them see off the Lib Dems and the Greens. It will also pose a challenge to the SNP.

This is about consolidating the anti-Brexit vote, but it’s also about putting Labour firmly in the same quadrant as majority public opinion. If the Tories, Reform and Restore want to fight public opinion – opinion born of how people have directly experienced Brexit – they can. Mr Burnham doesn’t seem to mind one bit.

Prime ministers can only be effective if they confront challenges. The UK’s interests are not served by the current dysfunctional relationship with Europe. Putting the country on a firmer, more prosperous footing means moving closer to Europe, either by joining a customs union, the single market or the EU itself.

Some prime minister, at some point, had to have the guts to say so. Current economic challenges are so significant and the public so scunnered that he can risk saying it now. It’s brave, perhaps, but certainly not stupid.

For the SNP, it’s a double-edged sword. If the UK is in the single market or on the way to rejoining it, it could make one aspect of the independence prospectus easier to sell, by resolving troublesome border issues that would arise if Yes were campaigning for Scotland to be independent inside the EU while the rest of the UK stayed outside it.

But Brexit has also been a big driver of support for Scottish independence. The UK moving closer to Europe again will probably weaken the appeal of independence for Remainers. On balance, it’s not terribly helpful to the SNP.

Labour does need to start talking about this now if there’s to be any realistic prospect of putting rejoining the EU or the single market in the next manifesto. Support for that proposition then needs to be consistently around 60 per cent before a referendum is actually called, since the last thing anyone wants is another close-run thing that’s endlessly contested.

This could take many years, but it’s long overdue. We tried Brexit; it hasn’t worked out. Now there might be a chance of doing something better.


Rebecca McQuillan is a journalist specialising in politics and Scottish affairs. She can be found on Bluesky at @becmcq.bsky.social and on X at @BecMcQ.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos