Ardrossan battling to save its own lifeline ferry

L to R: Allan Smith, Frances Gilmour chair, Cll Jean McClung, Matthew McGowan sec of Save Ardrossan harbour and Norrie Hunter.Picture Robert Perry 21st December 2024 <i>(Image: Robert Perry)</i>
L to R: Allan Smith, Frances Gilmour chair, Cll Jean McClung, Matthew McGowan sec of Save Ardrossan harbour and Norrie Hunter.Picture Robert Perry 21st December 2024 (Image: Robert Perry)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A handful of bureaucrats (identity unknown) in an unknown location to a set of indicators unknown beyond ‘cost-effectiveness’ is presently deciding the economic fate of one of Scotland’s oldest towns.

Ardrossan, the 1000-year-old North Ayrshire port town, is fighting to save its lifeline harbour.

The future prospects of dozens of businesses and hundreds of employees in this place rest on whether or not the Scottish Government decides to invest in an essential upgrade of the harbour which provides the main North Ayrshire ferry link to Arran.

The townspeople thought the decision had been made in their favour seven years ago. Since then though, not a shovel has been swung. A ‘business case’ for funding the improvements has taken so long that it will soon have its own coat of arms.

The overall cost is estimated to be around £90m, but no-one really knows for sure.

The local campaign group, Save Ardrossan Harbour, has been told by Peel Ports, the harbour’s owners, that there have been eight drafts of the business case and that a ninth iteration may currently be underway, but no-one knows about that for sure either.

Read More: Judy Murray’s words on men in women’s sport shame us all

Peel Ports, along with the local Council and Transport Scotland are the three main stakeholders.

The campaigners have been told that the firm already has a substantial amount of cash set aside for the harbour improvement.

The local authority has been discussing it – as you’d expect – and the region’s eight MSPs and one MP all say they want it to happen.

But no-one is telling the locals anything specific.

No matter what happens, you can be sure that Scotland’s multi-billion-pound civic and corporate caravan will move on and shake Ardrossan’s dust from their shoes.

You can also be sure that when the decision is made, the town’s 11,000 residents and the campaign group fighting on their behalf will be the last to know.

Last night, a spokesperson for Transport Scotland indicated only that the eighth (or ninth) draft of the fabled business case was “substantially complete”.

How much longer it would take and what the timescale was for making an announcement, no one was willing to say.

“The Scottish Government remains committed to ensuring the Arran ferry service is fit for the future, and to find a solution at Ardrossan that can be delivered in a cost-effective way, reflecting the needs of all partners involved.

Read More: As our politicians back 'assisted dying', beware the Codger Catchers

“We acknowledge the call for a commitment to Ardrossan and understand the views of the communities in favour of retaining it as the mainland port.

"This has been laid out in the draft business case. The case-work and overall delivery of the project needs to be supported by the financial packages from each of the main funders.

“It’s imperative therefore that these and the legal agreements are clearly defined, are affordable and ensure value to the public purse. The business case is substantially complete, and project partners continue to work on this as quickly as practicable.“

A meeting of the Task Force will be reconvened soon after the business case and cost exercise review has been submitted to Ministers for a decision.”

Local people wonder why they’re still talking about ‘the business case’ seven years after they’d been assured it has been made.

Around 350 of them filled the town’s largest civic space to support the campaign to save their harbour with hundreds more having to be turned away.

“They know that if the harbour loses the ferry service to Troon it will effectively sound a death knell for Ardrossan,” said Matthew McGowan from the campaign group.

On Saturday afternoon, in the shadow of the giant ferry terminal, he and four of his fellow campaigners met me in the Seahorse Bookshop.

There was a palpable sense of resentment and frustration not only at the seven years they’ve had to wait for an upgrade, but also that they’ve been kept in the dark at every step.

“Whoever’s been compiling the data for the business case hasn’t deigned to speak to any of us, or to the businesses which will be affected,” said Norrie Hunter.

Read More: 'Without food there is no wealth': Kevin McKenna at AgriScot 2024

“We’ve repeatedly asked for a meeting with the Transport Minister, Fiona Hyslop, but haven’t even had the courtesy of a response from her department.”

Matthew McGowan expressed a growing suspicion among the group that Troon – 16 miles down the A78 – is already being prepared as the main ferry link to Arran.

“We’re in North Ayrshire and Troon is in South Ayrshire,” he said and moving the ferries there would make the simple treat of a day trip to Glasgow for the Christmas markets impossible.

Hospital appointments on the mainland for Arran residents would also be much more difficult.

The impact on the community would be massive. Allan Smith highlighted the impracticality of making Troon the main ferry link.

“We have a train here drops you off at the actual ferry. If you go from Brodick to Troon, the connection is nowhere near within walking distance.

“I did that walk a couple of days ago at a brisk pace and it took me 15 minutes from the train station to the front gate and another 10 to get from the front gate to the terminal building.

“For an elderly person or a traveller with luggage, it’s more. Our Facebook users are telling us they simply won’t be going to Arran if the ferry were to leave from Troon.”

Gordon Murray is the owner of the Seahorse Bookstore, located in the town’s former shipping office.

“I bought this building in 2021 confident that a new, fully-functioning complex with a range of facilities would become part of the larger re-development of the area.

“We really hoped that this was going to bring Ardrossan back to life. The harbour is a vital part of our economy and we have faithful customers from Arran who we really miss when the ferries aren’t operating.”

Greg Peters owns the newly-opened Rendezvous Cafe and Bistro in the town.

He said: “I’ve made a substantial investment in the cafe and soon, a new takeaway business. We have a regular clientele going back and forth to Arran and also those who find their ferry cancelled.“

“All the businesses in the town are seriously concerned about the current situation. We all support the efforts of the Save Ardrossan Harbour campaign team.

“Taking the ferries away will take the lifeblood from the town.”`

Read More: This Scots town is cheapest to buy a house in UK. So what is it like?

At the root of this episode is a tale familiar to other mainly working-class communities across Scotland.

It speaks of a callous contempt for real communities; their futures, their families and their shared sense of cultural, multi-generational identity.

All of it is reduced to workings in the margins of a balance sheet before someone decides whether or not they are worth the financial outlay.

The people of Stranraer know what this looks like. In 2011 the Northern Ireland ferry terminal was removed from the second largest town in the Dumfries and Galloway region to the tiny village of Cairnryan six miles up the coast.

Stranraer’s economy shrank virtually overnight by 26 per cent and has since reduced annually by three per cent.

The area is served by dozens of local and national politicians and copious numbers of public sector agencies and task forces, yet Stranraer has been left to twist in the wind.

A local chip shop owner and the entrepreneur who runs the Stranraer Oyster Festival have achieved more than all of them. These places don’t get to feature in Visit Scotland campaigns.

Nor do they have many political options. Cross-party support carries little leverage with governments: if they lose some seats then so will the other lot.

If you want to know why many working-class people across the UK are moving in their droves to a cowboy outfit like Reform then look no further.

In the Seahorse Bookshop on Saturday afternoon, Matthew McGowan said: “The new Glen Sannox ferry runs on LNG Gas, but there’s nowhere suitable at Troon harbour to install a gas tank. T

"They’ll have to fill it by tanker truck. So, the truck has to drive up and everything has to be timed perfectly for it to be there for the boat arriving. The turnarounds would take much longer.”

And here’s another thing. Troon is more affluent than Ardrossan.

Do the douce citizens of this golf town want tailbacks of haulage trucks passing through their perjink neighbourhoods?

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos