Insight

Dumfries & Galloway mental health services under strain

Frank Ritchie and his son Alan <i>(Image: Frank Ritchie)</i>
Frank Ritchie and his son Alan (Image: Frank Ritchie)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A decade after losing his son to suicide, one father says mental health services in Dumfries and Galloway are not improving - with families facing long waits, poor transport and cuts to community care.

On a summer evening in June 2015, Frank Ritchie’s life changed forever. His son Alan, just 31-years-old, took his own life at Lockerbie railway station. 

Ten years later, Frank’s grief is still there.

“My heart is broken. I’ve lost my son,” he says. “I sometimes think that when I get older I will think about it more. Right now I’m able to distract myself. I fear that time will run out on that.”

Alan had battled with mental ill health for most of his life, taking antidepressants since he was a teenager. 

But like many in Dumfries and Galloway, the services he needed were far away. Each counselling session meant a 146-mile round trip to Edinburgh and back.

On the night of his death, Alan’s train pulled into Lockerbie station at 5pm.

He didn’t make it home. 

Sometimes the trauma of the loss has resurfaced without warning in Frank’s life. 

Once, he spotted a man standing on a railway bridge in Lockerbie. “I thought, ‘This is it, this is happening’,” he says. He pulled over, only to discover the man was a train spotter. 

“It was the first time since Alan’s death that I came across that situation. When Alan did what he did, it was half past five at the station and there would have been people about," he said. "He had been there for twenty minutes. So I don’t want to ignore anyone who could be going through that.”

Even in ordinary routines, memories linger. Frank and his wife still live in Lockerbie, where she tends the flowerpots at the station — the place where Alan died. “I don’t shy away there,” he said. 

With no local bereavement service nearby at the time, Frank travelled to Carlisle to attend Survivors of Bereavement by Suicide (SOBS) and sought help from the charity Cruse. 

The loss shattered Frank and, after Alan’s death, he saw only two options. 

“I either follow Alan, take to my bed, take to drink — or try to use his death as something I could help to those who were like Alan,” he says. “I couldn’t prevent his death but I could help others.”

Frank began fundraising and campaigning for mental health charities across the region, turning his grief into action.

“It’s helped me with my bereavement and it’s given me purpose where in the early days there was no purpose, it’s just a disaster.”

But even after a decade of campaigning, he says the system hasn’t changed.

Asked if he has seen any improvements to mental health support, Frank said: “No. I get the impression it’s actually getting worse. There’s definitely more campaigning and the need is getting greater but I don’t see the improvements.”

Frank’s story is deeply personal, but it echoes across Dumfries and Galloway.

Suicide rates here are rising: 19 probable suicides were recorded in 2023, up from the 16 the year before.

For Nick Ward, CEO of Change Mental Health, Scotland’s largest mental health charity working in the region, those numbers reflect a system under severe pressure.

“Every single suicide is a preventable death,” Mr Ward tells The Herald. “With the right support in place, lives could have been saved. We are incredibly concerned that the rates here are getting worse, not better.”

Nick Ward, CEO of Change Mental Health.Nick Ward, CEO of Change Mental Health. (Image: supplied) Public demand for mental health support has increased in Dumfries and Galloway with support requests rising by nearly 40% in the last year.

It is understood this is largely driven by an aging population and increasing numbers of dementia or learning disability cases as the upsurge is mainly due to a rise in guardianship requests. 

There have been concerns there are too few Mental Health Officers (MHOs) to meet the need and officials said in June this year they are “just” managing to cope with demand. 

Geography makes everything harder. Dumfries and Galloway is vast, with scattered communities and limited transport links.


Read More:


“There are some real challenges to having an area which is so vast,” Mr Ward explains. “Communities and services are not close by, and that distance can create isolation. It makes relationship building incredibly difficult.”

The same sense of strain is felt in farming communities across the region. 

The National Farmers' Union,(NFU) has warned that mental health is a growing concern in Dumfries and Galloway’s rural communities, where isolation, long hours, and financial pressures take a toll. 

A NFU Scotland spokesperson told The Herald: “Mental health remains a serious and growing concern within our rural and farming communities, particularly in areas like Dumfries and Galloway where isolation, financial pressure, and long working hours can take a real toll.

"We know from speaking with members that the pressures are real and that breaking the silence around mental health is vital. Farmers are often expected to be resilient, but that should never come at the cost of wellbeing.

"It’s important that those struggling know they’re not alone and that support is available from various organisations.”

The Herald has launched an investigative series on Dumfries and Galloway. The Herald has launched an investigative series on Dumfries and Galloway. (Image: Damian Shields) Even reaching Change Mental Health’s hub in Stranraer can be daunting. 

“If you’re struggling with your mental health, getting on a bus is huge,” Mr Ward said, “And then, if there are very few services, all you can think about is not missing the bus back. That massively affects your ability to access support.”

The lack of cars in lower-income households worsens the gap.

For those needing in-patient care, the only psychiatric hospital, Midpark, is in Dumfries — 75 miles from Stranraer.

“If you don’t drive, you’re completely isolated from loved ones in a part of the region you don’t even know,” Mr Ward said. 

Technology could bridge the distance — but access is unequal. Some areas enjoy strong broadband, others don’t. And beyond signal strength, poverty plays a role.

“Poverty and class play a huge part in how digitally savvy people feel,” Mr Ward said, “If you’re mentally ill, being asked to access support digitally can be quite a terrifying experience.”

The result, he warns, is a vicious circle of poor transport, weak digital infrastructure, and overstretched services. 

“There’s a phrase that goes, ‘Cancer is a full-time job.’ Well, for people in Dumfries and Galloway, being mentally unwell is a full-time job," Mr Ward said, "And that’s just not fair.”

Local MSP Oliver Mundell has described Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS) in the region as being “in crisis.”  Families, he said, are repeatedly contacting him because they can’t get help.

Oliver Mundell, MSP for Dumfriesshire Oliver Mundell, MSP for Dumfriesshire (Image: supplied) The longest waiting time for CAMHS support for children who started treatment in Dumfries and Galloway this year has been 126 days. Out of all Scottish health boards, however, this was one of the lowest waits. 

There have been improvements to waiting times for CAMHS in the region. A total of 100% of young people had treatment within the government's 18-week target as of March this year, compared to only 64.1% the previous year. 

However, Mr Mundell still believes the waits for young people are unacceptable. 

“The fact that we think it’s acceptable to ask a young person in a mental health crisis to wait 18 weeks is shocking,” he says. “Sometimes in a region like this a sole consultant is left carrying an overwhelming workload. Recruitment is difficult because many trainees in the central belt simply stay there. Professionals here are under huge pressure.”

Both Mr Mundell and Mr Ward believe the answer lies in reshaping how Scotland treats mental health.

“We’ve been giving people antidepressants for fifty years and the situation has got worse, not better,” Mr Ward said. “Drugs can be hugely powerful for those who are mentally ill, but for the majority of people, they’re not the answer. Services that work individually with people — talking therapies, community support — are the way forward.”

For the MSP, the answer lies in less medication and more community support. 

Mr Mundell said:  “Too often we medicalise mental health provision. Informal, local support networks can help people manage day-to-day life, employment, and build social connections. That would free up NHS capacity for those in crisis.”

Scotland’s mental health services have faced significant financial pressure, with real-terms budget cuts and freezes in recent years, raising concerns that essential support and early intervention programs are at risk across the country. 

Mr Ward added: “The Scottish Government made a really brilliant pledge a couple of years to increase NHS frontline spending on mental health up to 10%. It’s still not go there. We’re coming up for an election and it’s time to look at that.”

He also wants to see third sector organisations become first responders to mental health calls: “When you’re having a mental health crisis you don’t want the boys in blue turning up, you don’t want sirens. You want people who can come and calm and settle you and right now in Scotland that’s not being provided and that’s a real gap.”

NHS Dumfries and Galloway has said that a new triage system has successfully reduced waiting times in CAMHS and the overall waiting list for psychological therapies fell for the sixth month in a row to 709, compared with an average of 988 in 2023-4. 

The Scottish Government has been contacted for comment. 


Where to find help

If you are struggling with your mental health or experiencing suicidal thoughts, help is available.

  • Samaritans – 116 123 (free, open 24/7)
     

  • Breathing Space – 0800 83 85 87 (6pm–2am weekdays, 24 hours at weekends)
     

  • Change Mental Health – changemh.org / 0808 8010 515

  • NHS 24 – call 111 if you need urgent out-of-hours support
     

  • If you are in immediate danger, dial 999.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos