Mark McGeoghegan

Starmer finds his voice — but Sarwar still faces the silence of voters

Keir Starmer speaks at the Labour party conference in Liverpool <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Keir Starmer speaks at the Labour party conference in Liverpool (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Sir Keir Starmer’s pivot to progressive patriotism and attacks on Nigel Farage come too late to save Scottish Labour ahead of the Holyrood elections, but don’t write off Anas Sarwar yet, writes Herald columnist Mark McGeoghegan.


On Monday, Sir Keir Starmer delivered his best speech to date to the Labour Party Conference, a conference that had at one point threatened to spark a leadership challenge and plunge the party deeper into chaos. It was a political rallying cry that his membership lapped up. He reached oratorical heights he had rarely touched before, and launched the attack on Nigel Farage and Reform UK that much of progressive Britain had been longing for. In doing so, he gave his vision for Britain definition where it had been blurry and difficult to understand.

The big question, of course, is how much it will matter. His call for a compassionate approach to immigration clashed with his Home Secretary’s announcement that migrants seeking indefinite leave to remain will be required to perform unpaid labour – a policy already unravelling under scrutiny. The economic fundamentals remain poor, and few economists expect them to improve anytime soon. A difficult budget looms in November, one most analysts expect to contain tax rises. Even if the Prime Minister receives a short-term poll boost and his reorientation bears fruit in the long run, it is too little, too late for Anas Sarwar and Scottish Labour.

A central theme of the Prime Minister’s speech was a rejection of the notion that Britain is broken. The Broken Britain narrative has become a centrepiece of our politics since the pandemic, and was one Labour leaned on to carry them to power, but it is now undermining them. Labour needs to generate a sense that Britain is on the mend, so it makes complete sense that Sir Keir – who started in power telling us that things would get worse before they get better – is now pivoting, late as it is.


Read more:


He pointed to both public and private investments, Britain’s thriving science and technology industries, and to the charitable acts of individual Britons as evidence. Nobody can deny that there is plenty of investment money flowing into Britain, nor that we have plenty of world-leading industries – just don’t mention the higher education sector, on the verge of collapse, propping up those industries.

Nor could anyone argue that the people of Britain are broken. But that’s just it, the narrative isn’t one of Broken Britons, it’s one of Broken Britain, and it’s not rooted in far-right or populist rhetoric. It’s rooted in the day-to-day experiences of people, whenever they interact with transport infrastructure, schools, the NHS, policing, or when they go shopping and find they can’t afford anything near what they used to be able to. No political rhetoric can resolve that problem, and the real-world impacts the government need to have won’t happen quickly and may not happen at all.

So don’t expect anything that came out of this Labour Party Conference to change the political environment in Scotland ahead of the Holyrood elections next year. Three polls out last week painted a challenging picture for Anas Sarwar. On average, his party are neck-and-neck with Reform UK, with the SNP between twelve and 17 points ahead of each. When Labour won the general election last July, they were neck-and-neck with the SNP in Holyrood polling.

 I find it hard not to sympathise with Mr Sarwar. His party’s support hasn’t fallen because of anything he’s done, and I don’t think he can be blamed for his falling personal approval ratings, either. If we consider Mr Sarwar and Labour as brands, as political marketers would, we can discuss the flow of “brand equity” between the two. The reality is that Mr Sarwar does not have a sufficiently strong or distinctive personal brand to offset the negativity flowing from the overall Labour brand, and suffers as a result.

Without a reversal in Labour’s fortunes overall, I can’t see how Mr Sarwar turns around those of the Scottish party or his own. Of course, anything could happen between now and May, but with every passing week, the prospects of recovery diminish.

That doesn’t mean that the May election is a done deal, because this will be the most unpredictable Holyrood election yet. While our electoral system features a regional list vote that mitigates the disproportionality of the constituency vote, 73 of the 129 seats are elected by the first-past-the-post system. Under such a system, more competitive parties means greater unpredictability.

Even if the polls today perfectly predict the vote share that each party will get, the Parliament could look very different based on the outcomes of around 15 constituency seats. These are all seats that most models currently expect the SNP to win, leading to them winning around 60 seats. But they are also expected to be tight, three-way contests between the SNP, Reform UK, and either Labour or the Conservatives. If they go against the SNP, they would win around 47 seats because they lack the list vote support to compensate for those losses.

We have already seen Labour win a tightly-fought, three-way contest with the SNP and Reform UK in the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election. Pull off more such wins in May, and Mr Sarwar could – rather than lead Scottish Labour to its worst ever Holyrood result – gain seats, make Scottish Labour the largest opposition party and, crucially, the only party except Reform UK with enough MSPs to build a two-party majority.

It's still a far cry from where Mr Sarwar thought he was last July: on course to become First Minister. But it’s not the worst consolation prize given that, as Professor Sir John Curtice has put it, Scottish Labour has a Sir Keir Starmer problem that Mr Sarwar can do little about. He would find himself with significant leverage in Holyrood, as the SNP would only be able to guarantee the passage of legislation and budgets either with his support or by balancing the support of both the Greens and the Liberal Democrats.

The past year or so has done Scottish Labour no favours, and while the Prime Minister’s speech this week was his best to date, his reorientation is too little, too late to fix the damage – damage that next month’s budget may deepen.

But it’s not curtains for Mr Sarwar, not yet, and he may still find himself the first Scottish Labour leader since 2007 to wield even a modicum of power in Holyrood after next May.


Mark McGeoghegan is a Glasgow University researcher of nationalism and contentious politics and an Associate Member of the Centre on Constitutional Change. He can be found on BlueSky @markmcgeoghegan.bsky.social

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos