Kaye Adams has been suspended from the BBC but these allegations aren't representative of the woman I know, says showbusiness writer Brian Beacom
Kaye Adams is more measured than a Savile Row suit. The broadcaster who grew up in Grangemouth has refined a career which has taken her to the top of her profession. In television, she’s a regular ITV Loose Woman. In radio, the BBC value her so much she’s paid north of £150k a year to take telephone calls.
I've known Adams for four decades. She is a Capricorn; cautious, and serious, on the outside at least. She very much likes to be in control of her destiny, a calculator who has long been regarded as a creature with a need to be in control of her life and career. "I'm a bit like Communist Russia," she once admitted, grinning. "I like a five-year plan.”
So, what has gone so wrong with the plan, that BBC Scotland have suspended the presenter from her morning radio show following bullying allegations? Why has the 62-year-old been asked to remain at her West End of Glasgow home while an investigation is conducted into claims she “shouted and screamed” at junior staff?
This sort of behaviour isn’t representative of the Kaye Adams I know, and it’s not the Adams which ITV bosses know either, who have insisted she will continue to front Loose Women.
Yes, Kaye Adams was a completely rubbish dancer on Strictly, but it’s one of the few times in her career that she’s tripped up. OK, there was an occasion in 2011 when she was given two of the belt by the Beeb after she trashed Boris Johnson on social media, over his handling of the London riots. And while few could disagree with her expletive ridden comments, she admitted that she overstepped the remit. "I didn't get the enormity of it at all. What you have to do in this job is strike a balance between not being a propagandist - but at the same time not being reduced to a Speak Your Weight machine."
What that tells you is that Kaye Adams has a social conscience. She’s prepared to speak out and argue against perceived injustice, and few could criticise her blast off at a recognised political buffoon. But what that also indicates is that while the presenter can reach for invective when the occasion requires, she is not tin eared about how accusations of bullying can easily take hold, having hosted numerous phone-in shows on that very subject.
Read more on BBC Scotland crisis
- BBC Scotland: Turmoil as bosses try to keep high-earning 'star' presenter happy
- Not 'po-faced' or 'middle-class', but Radio Scotland show in desperate need of reset
- Radio Scotland's flagship show faces axe but BBC bosses could be making a big mistake
- What is going wrong at BBC Scotland? I tuned in to find out
What we also have to consider is that the mother of two girls has worked for BBC Radio Scotland for more than 15 years - and in that time has never had any issue raised about her behaviour. And ITV certainly have no problems with her. An insider said: “Kaye is regarded as one of the calmer members of the Loose Women cast.”
So, what’s happened? Is the BBC over-reacting to claims made by an overly sensitive employee? We know the BBC was right to drop the creep that is Gregg Wallace. But is the BBC now being overly cautious given that Gregg’s bad behaviour ran on for years?
Yet, Naga Munchetty isn’t suspended for current allegations of bullying, so why is Kaye Adams? Is it a case of Snowflake syndrome? Did Adams’ critical voice ring out a little too loud one morning?
I once asked Kaye Adams if she thought her temper had cooled over the years. “Yes, I used to fight every battle,” she said of sexism and aggressive behaviour in the workplace. “But it was exhausting. Now I choose my battles. I think age has given me that."
With that sort of experience, it doesn’t seem at all likely that Kaye Adams has turned into the sort of person she once had to contend with.
Share