Sarah Campbell Review

This Scottish roadside restaurant is more than the ‘perfect pitstop’

This quirky motel, restaurant and bar is worth the stop <i>(Image: Newsquest)</i>
This quirky motel, restaurant and bar is worth the stop (Image: Newsquest)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

When a tangerine-toned tour bus stamped with a cartoon Highland cow logo pulls into the car park, things start to make a lot more sense.

We’d been wondering why so many young staff members, smartly dressed in black trousers and pressed white shirts, were flitting around this restaurant-cum-cafe-cum-motel on the A84 with just us and one other table to wait on.

But now, it’s go time. Rainproof-jacket-clad sightseers, seated. Menus, distributed. Drinks orders, dealt with. And within the space of just a few minutes, those first plates of food are making their way out from the kitchen and into the larger dining room next door.

This is clearly not the team at Mhor 84’s first rodeo, and the speed at which they ensure the group is fed, watered and ready to head right back onto the road is quite something to behold while idly picking away at our own starters.

Mhor 84 is a restaurant, café and bar - "all three are intertwined" (Image: Newsquest)

We’d arrived about half an hour before everything really kicked off, beginning with a snack portion of juicy gherkins (£4.50), quartered and deep-fried in a wonderfully thin, crackly batter that suggested the kitchen’s fish and chips would also be a safe bet.


Read more:


Surrounded by vintage posters, upcycled furniture and antiques, including a few fetching taxidermy animals perched on high shelves, next came Cullen Skink (£10): smoky, creamy and fortifying, with hunks of squidgy homemade sourdough for dipping. The sort of bowl anyone would be desperate to dive into after a day of hiking or pedalling through heavy September rain.

Frickles with thousand island dip (Image: Newsquest)

That seems to be the general vibe of the menu here at chef-hotelier Tom Lewis and his family’s quirkier, younger offshoot of the Monachyle Mhor hotel, although nestled among the likes of macaroni cheese, burgers and steaks are a number of seasonal, produce-driven dishes to show that this is not your run-of-the-mill roadside café.

That big block of confit chicken terrine (£10.50), for example, was skilfully executed, with small bursts of peppery mustard seed and fresh herbs dispersed evenly throughout. The onion chutney may have been missing from the plate, but still this meaty mix held up just fine on its own when spooned liberally onto more of that homemade sourdough toasted into thin crostini.

Confit chicken terrine with crostini (Image: Newsquest)

“That’s the Virgin Mary,” our smiley server repeats when quizzed on the suspiciously non-tomato-juice-coloured mocktail (£6) that’s now arrived during the height of the bus tour invasion. With one glance at the busy bar behind him, we think better of pointing out that it might have been confused with a booze-free piña colada.

Thankfully, my dinner date and designated driver this evening is far from fussy. And anyway, who’s to say a tropical hit of coconut milk and lime won’t pair well with the steak and ale pie (£17.50) still to come?

Steak and ale pie with truffle mash and tenderstem broccoli (Image: Newsquest)

Instead of the puff-pastry-topped stew favoured by gastropubs, Mhor 84 serves what looks like a poshed-up football-stadium snack, neat and tidy with generous chunks of beef and glossy gravy contained within its squat, structured edges. It’s unexpected, and perhaps not quite the portion a hungry hiker would hope for, but it still scratches that comfort-food itch with truffle-laced mash and buttery broccoli.

Bringing us closer yet to restaurant territory is a barley risotto (£15) with plump, gently chewy grains, stained a fabulous, vibrant golden-orange by carrot purée; its sweet base tempered by plenty of warming cumin. With more carrot shaved into ribbons of tangy pickle on top, this ode to the humble veg is a refreshingly creative plant-based option, if a little sickly by the final bites.

Carrot barley risotto - carrot puree, pickled carrots, toasted cumin seeds (Image: Newsquest)

At this point, the last of the tourist crew is paying up before being herded back on board the coach. One of them has even managed to squeeze in a whisky flight for the road, and shuffles merrily through the door while declaring a favourite from the three drams to the bemused excursion leader.

Chocolate orange delice with chantilly cream, burnt orange and almond milk (Image: Newsquest)

And with that, they’re on their way, leaving just us and a few other dinnertime diners in their wake. Devouring a wickedly rich chocolate delice (£9) with segments of burnt orange and crumbled meringue at our own pace feels like quite the luxury after seeing others on such a tight timescale, and the sun slowly setting over the surrounding hills only adds to Mhor 84’s cosy charm.

While much of this funky little spot’s appeal seems to hinge on its roadside location, right on Cycle Route 7 and the Rob Roy Way, it would be a shame to think of it as only somewhere to visit in passing.

Allow yourself time to linger, and you’ll soon discover this is not just the ‘perfect pitstop’, but an accomplished, characterful destination restaurant in its own right.


Menu: Comfort food classics alongside seasonal, restaurant-quality dishes using produce sourced from their own farm and local suppliers. 4/5

Service: The team does a fantastic job of dealing with a bus tour booking and looks after the restaurant well despite the rush. Mocktail hiccup aside, they’re friendly, efficient and clearly well practised. 4/5

Atmosphere: This space has bags of quirky charm and a relaxed vibe that’s easy to sink into. 5/5

Price: Snacks from £4.50, mains from £15 and desserts from £9. Prices are reasonable, although that pie feels a little modest for the money. 3/5

Food: The starters in particular are fantastic, but all round this is accomplished cooking that goes well beyond what you might expect from a roadside restaurant. 8/10

Total: 24/30

Mhor 84 is located in Balquhidder, Lochearnhead, Perthshire 


Sarah Campbell is The Herald’s Food and Drink writer and restaurant critic. You can find her on X or Instagram @sz_campbell.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos