Two decades on, the public health approach to masculinity championed by Movember remains as crucial as ever in the age of masculinity influencing and the ‘manosphere’, writes Herald columnist Mark McGeoghegan
A week from now, hundreds of thousands of men will clean-shave for the last time for a month and start growing a moustache for Movember. What started as a group of 30 Australian men trying to bring back the moustache in 2003 has since grown into the world’s biggest men’s health charity and a movement of over six million fundraisers over the course of two decades, funding over a thousand men’s health projects.
In a typically Australian and stereotypically male fashion, Movember took banter as an entry point to tackling some of the most impactful health challenges facing men today. There’s the obvious, like research into prostate and testicular cancer, or playing a pivotal role in lobbying for the world’s first men’s health strategy, announced last year by Sir Keir Starmer. But there’s also the less obvious, including a recent study exploring young men’s digital lives.
Much has been made in recent years of the impact of the ‘manosphere’ on young men and the implications for society. The crime drama Adolescence, name-checked by the Prime Minister in the House of Commons, drew on some of the darker corners of the masculinity influencer ecosystem to inspire its story of a teenage boy who murders a classmate who rejected him, citing concepts that one would only otherwise have come across perusing online messaging boards like 4chan.
Read more by Mark McGeoghegan
- Trump’s peace deal is real — but he shouldn’t win a Nobel
- Starmer finds his voice — but Sarwar still faces the silence of voters
- How free speech is under attack on both sides of the Atlantic
- The far right may try - but they won't manage to steal the Saltire
The best-known masculinity influencers, like Joe Rogan, have developed a reputation for endorsing right-wing politics thanks to short clips of their often hours-long podcasts and live streams spreading across social media. Their reputation has become defined by fear of right-wing politics, and that reputation has attached itself to their listeners and young men in general.
When commentators look at, for example, the United States, they see that young men favoured Donald Trump over Kamala Harris by some 14 percentage points in the 2024 Presidential election, constituting a significant swing to the right compared to previous elections. Opinion polls in the UK seem to be showing a swing towards Reform UK among young men, and we can say the same about most European far-right parties. Some have gone as far as speculating that young men want authoritarian dictatorship and are driving us towards the end of democracy.
But as with most generational claims, there is a significant amount of myth-making going on here that both obscures what is actually happening in young men’s digital lives and what they actually think and want. The idea that young men in Britain, for example, are veering to the right is entirely false.
The John Smith Centre’s UK Youth Poll found that while young men are more likely than young women to place themselves on the right of politics, and young women are more likely to place themselves on the left, both groups were overwhelmingly more likely to be in the political centre. Overall, the UK Youth Poll found that on most issues, young men and women basically think alike.
Nigel Farage (Image: PA)
While it’s true that young men are twice as likely to vote for Reform as young women, according to the UK Youth Poll, that support amounts to just 19% of young men overall, and a majority would vote for a left- or centre-left party. Similarly, while young men swung right in the 2024 US Presidential Elections, their approval of President Trump has slumped since. Among young Americans overall, his net approval has fallen from -3 to -36, largely driven by the changing views of men.
Likewise, the image of the online masculinity influencing ecosystem as a dark and radicalising corner of the web is largely false. Movember’s study found that a majority of men under 25 watch masculinity influencers online. Largely, they do so because they find such content entertaining, rather than having fallen down a conspiratorial rabbit hole. And contrary to the belief that such content convinces young men that their standing in the world is diminishing, those engaging with it are more likely than non-engaged young men to think that their personal and social circumstances will improve over the next five years.
It's important not to pretend that all is rosy. Engagement with masculinity influencers is also associated with a range of negative mental health outcomes. Young men who engage with masculinity influencers are more likely to experience feelings of worthlessness, depression and anxiety, and less likely to prioritise their mental health. They are also more likely to engage in risky behaviours, like taking steroids or testosterone injections, or exercising while injured.
They are more likely to prioritise stereotypically masculine traits and desprioritise trust and kindness in their personal relationships than young men who don’t engage with masculinity influencers. They are also more likely to hold negative beliefs about women and to be socially isolated.
It would also be unwise to act like these adverse effects don’t have wider societal and political consequences, but to date, these have been vastly overstated. The political impacts of masculinity influencing are downstream of the health impacts, physical and mental, that it is having on young men.
Read more
- Classic American play is, sadly, still so relevant today
- I've known BBC's suspended star Kaye Adams for 40 years - so what is she really like?
- From Bay City Rollers to tartan bondage trousers - here are punk's Scottish roots
- Netflix has a new serial killer drama. I watched it - and I really wish I hadn't
The Movember study broadly found that our understanding of the impacts of digital life on young men is poorly developed and underfunded, but that the health implications of those impacts are significant. In place of an understanding of digital life and young men’s health rooted in fact, the popular narrative has been overtaken by misconceptions, myth-making, and stereotypes that don’t help us understand or address the problems young men face, let alone the broader societal consequences that can flow from them.
As a society, we are stuck in a cul-de-sac on men’s health issues, constantly asking why men die younger (15 British men die ‘early’ every hour), commit suicide more often, are less likely to seek help for ailments, and are more likely to engage in substance abuse than their female peers. We fill the gaps in systematically developed knowledge by leaning on pet theories and stereotypes that have gotten us nowhere.
Digital life is exacerbating some of these issues, but it can also serve as a conduit to alleviate them, alongside wider public health interventions. That’s why developing a better understanding of how digital life is affecting young men is so important, and why, two decades on, the work of charities like Movember remains critical to improving men’s health outcomes and bettering society overall.
Mark McGeoghegan is a Glasgow University researcher of nationalism and contentious politics and an Associate Member of the Centre on Constitutional Change. He can be found on BlueSky @markmcgeoghegan.bsky.social
Share