With just weeks to go until the May elections, one cohort of Scottish voters may hold the result in their hands, says Mark Smith
With a few weeks to go, some of us are still wondering what effect Gorton and Denton might have on May’s election but I’m also thinking about Hamilton, Crosby, Bermondsey and Bradford West. Those were also by-elections (and there are lots of others) that meant a Left/Right/SDP/SNP revolution, or there’s no such thing as a safe Tory/Labour seat anymore, or two-party politics is over. So Gorton and Denton: important, yes. But should we keep it in perspective? Also yes.
The main point is that the trends that show up in events like Gorton and Denton – important though they are at the time – are usually a reflection of the fairly sophisticated way the British electorate behaves: we know the difference between various elections and vote accordingly. Some people will stick with the Greens, of course they will, but many of those who voted Green in the by-election will not do so in a bigger election because by then things will have moved on, stuff will have happened, and the stakes will be higher. Dear Hannah Spencer, I’d keep my hand in at the plumbing if I were you.
The effect the recent success for the Greens might have in the specific Scottish context is not that easy to predict. The polling by Ipsos the other day showed support for the Scottish Greens slightly sliding if anything, down one or two points on the constituency and regional lists, although the fieldwork for the poll was done just before Gorton and Denton so it may miss the effect the coverage and the momentum might have on some voters in Scotland. There’ll be a sense that the Greens are on a roll and that may pick up some extra votes.
Read more
Big plans for John Lewis in Glasgow: a sign of hope at last? | The Herald
Charging to see Glasgow city chambers is the right decision | The Herald
First listen to the new Morrissey album – is it any good? | The Herald
However, the biggest revelation of the recent polls isn’t the way the parties are shifting – the shifts have been small – it’s the huge level of indecision and swithering that exists among Scottish voters who either haven’t made up their minds yet or are prone to changing before polling day. The Ipsos poll found that 40% may change their mind about which party they’ll vote for in the constituency vote, which is way higher than it was at a similar point before the 2021 elections when it stood at around 31%.
A number of trends are going on I think, the first of which is the withering of the SNP vote to a hard core of about a third. According to the Ipsos poll, the SNP is on 36% of the constituency vote which, if it was replicated on polling day, would be a much weaker performance than 2021, when they got 48%. Many people have pointed it out before me, but let me have another go: 36% in May would make them the biggest party at Holyrood, but the idea that it would represent a mandate for another referendum on independence is laughable. Ha. Ha. Ha.
The other trend in the polls is the spread of the unionist vote (for want of a better term) across several parties, with Labour at around 20% on the constituency, the Tories on 9, Reform 16 and the Lib Dems 10, or to put it another way: 55% of the vote. The problem here is we’re seeing a move towards smaller parties such as Reform on the Right and the Greens on the Left, but the Holyrood system, even though it’s better than first-past-the-post, still isn’t set up to properly reflect a wide spread of vote, and will over-reward the bigger parties in May.
The Electoral Reform Society spelled out the problem in its recent report on the subject. At the general election in 2024, Labour turned 34% of the vote into 63% of the parliament, 29 percentage points more. But there’s a similar problem at Holyrood: in 2011, the SNP got 44% of the vote but 54% of the parliament, 10 percentage points more. The solution would be to reduce the number of first-past-the-post seats or adjust the list system so it better reflects national rather than regional trends; otherwise you and I face SNP government after SNP government, all elected on minority votes; we face life on an iceberg that never melts.
Newly-elected Green MP for Gorton and Denton, Hannah Spencer, poses for photos at Westminster Bridge, London, with Green Party leader Zack Polanski Picture by Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire
The final trend from the polling, and it might be the most important, is the least-bad effect, the process by which voters work their way through the choices until they reach the one that they can, with a heavy heart and a pinched nose, support; the one that is the least-bad. The number of people who think John Swinney and the SNP are doing a good job, for example, is staggeringly low, certainly lower than the 36% or so they may get in May. According to Ipsos, the SNP is the most trusted on the NHS, the economy, tax and cost of living but the figures are 28%, 27%, 24% and 23% respectively. As for Mr Swinney, 35% say they’re satisfied with his performance against 51% who are dissatisfied, a net satisfaction rating of -16. It means the dissatisfaction is not quite as bad as it is with the other party leaders; he is the least-bad.
I think the least-bad effect may help explain why 40% of voters in Scotland are still swithering; I would certainly count myself as part of the 40% and it’s because, like a lot of people, I’ve been working through the choices, ticking them off one by one and trying to decide which is least bad. It may be, as has happened to me many times before, that I end up wandering, unhappy and confused, towards the Lib Dems again, a familiar destination for people in search of a compromise. The Ipsos polling certainly seems to suggest that it’s the Lib Dems and the Greens who are likely to benefit most if voters do change their minds. Among those who may change their minds, 24% are considering the Greens, 21% the Lib Dems and only 14% the SNP, so it has potential to change the result quite a bit.
What will I do in the end? Don’t ask me. As the figures suggest, the dissatisfaction people feel with the parties, the polices, the people is widespread and I feel it too. But I also feel the duty to vote and so I must work my way through the options – no, no, no, no – until I hit upon the one I can stomach. Some days, when I’m in a good mood, I think of the person, the politician, who’ll come through the middle of all this one day and change the landscape because history tells us that’s what happens eventually and it’ll happen in Scotland too, one day. But until then, we know what we must do: we must cling to the iceberg and vote, and wait, and hope. Good luck everyone.
Share